8 ms·
> 100% of the payment will go to the creator ... Clubhouse will take nothing. Well imagine if they had an Android app in the first place or earlier right befor
by rvz 6y ago
> 100% of the payment will go to the creator ... Clubhouse will take nothing.
Well imagine if they had an Android app in the first place or earlier right before all the big players started copying them, then it would have been attractive to the users. Right now, what is the point if the invite system is still there.
Another platform can just announce the same thing and they are back to square zero.
> We are excited to see how people use it, and to continue working hard to help the amazing members of the Clubhouse community grow and thrive.
Yet, with no Android app and an increasing amount of competitors copying the hell out of Clubhouse, I can only see this going in the way of Meerkat, Yik Yak and Periscope. (By being shut down)
- echelon 6y agoHow do apps like this survive and grow? Giants can clone the entire product with a small team. I'm worried about this exact problem. Edit: First thought that comes to mind is filing a few patents and then throwing 50% of funding into a lawsuit against the first giant to clone you. This is traditionally not the way, but with the incumbents so nimble and readily able to pick off good ideas, it seems like it might be the only defense.
- mylons 6y agoGiants will clone and make a piece of shit. Apps like this survive by creating a network of people. They do that by creating demand to join the service. How do you do that? Make it invite only, and invite a ton of high profile people and get them using and talking about it, creating FOMO. The only people who threaten this are Facebook and Twitter. Twitter _actually_ could clone it or buy a competitor. But, look at Twitter’s history of that. They literally KILLED a TikTok by buying it and shutting it down. They are in the process of killing a live video competitor to twitch and youtube called periscope. Don’t be afraid of The Big Bois.
- echelon 6y ago> Giants will clone and make a piece of shit. Facebook does a damn good job of sinking ships. The only two survivors I can think of are TikTok and Snapchat. And Snapchat pivoted.
- iforgetti 6y agoSerious question, what did snap chat pivot to?
- antoniuschan99 6y agoI would like to know too. Snapchat was ephermerial messages, stories, and filters? Tik tok is reels?
- shaklee3 6y agoThey made glasses with a camera in them
- busymom0 6y agoWhat did Snapchat pivot to? The only pivot I know they did was changing from disappearing messages to stories (not sure if the disappearing messages are still there?). But this wasn't exactly a pivot as far as I know because of FB copying the stories feature afterwards.
- mylons 6y agomy intuition on FB agrees with you but I can’t think of something like clubhouse that they didn’t buy or attempt to? any particular ships you’re referring to? the ones you’re referring to were social photo/video plays which FB was perfectly setup to enter. FB doesn’t have an audio product as far as i know.
- artur_makly 6y agoTheir IP is the high caliber of people/creators/cult/tribes that has amassed and been refined. But clearly not their UX...yet.
- picodguyo 6y agoWhat would they patent exactly? Group voice chat? I imagine someone patented that decades ago and if anything, Clubhouse will be licensing or fighting patent trolls soon if they aren't already.
- azinman2 6y agoThe way they do moderated group chat. It isn't just a giant chat room.
- herendin2 6y ago>Giants can clone the entire product with a small team Giants are more likely to buy the entire project with a small amount of shares Neither option is likely to turn out well, but at least the founders could be rewarded
- artur_makly 6y agoAndroid app is coming out in a few days ( as per founder's townhall chat yesterday )
- grishka 6y agoOh wow. It only took them two months or what? I made my unofficial app based on reverse engineered API in 1.5 days. It was quite popular at the time.
- dogma1138 6y agoYeah I don’t understand their business model, there is a cost to process a payment so even if I give someone $100 the credit card company and payment processors will take a cut. Now there is a difference between a platform that takes 15-30% cut and <5% but I really don’t see how they’ll be able to operate. And this ofc goes beyond the fact as you mentioned that the big players can simply kill this by having a similar policy especially for smaller creators. The only purpose of clubhouse that I can think off is if that’s exactly their plan in the first place. The only other thing I can think off is if they’ll offer a content discovery platform and then charge creators to promote their content on the system but that’s arguably a worse off deal for creators since they’ll have to put in money upfront without any guarantee of returns.
- Ceezy 6y agoThey may not process the payment but just have a deal with cash app/stripe and have a free access to an api
- 015a 6y agoIf you read the linked announcement: > 100% of the payment will go to the creator. The person sending the money will also be charged a small card processing fee, which will go directly to our payment processing partner, Stripe. Clubhouse will take nothing.
- PostThisTooFast 6y agoThen why not just use Venmo?
- PeterisP 6y agoIt's still a risky business model, since in certain fraud cases it will be left holding the bag for chargebacks if it has released the money to a fraudster but they don't have a revenue stream proportional to the payment amount to cover whatever percentage of the transactions are fraudulent.
- kyrra 6y ago
- xiii1408 6y ago> Yet, with no Android app and an increasing amount of competitors copying the hell out of Clubhouse, I can only see this going in the way of Meerkat, Yik Yak and Periscope. (By being shut down) We'll of course have to wait and see, but I don't imagine that Clubhouse will be entirely displaced. What's unique about Clubhouse is not the concept of a Clubhouse room itself, which is essentially a Discord channel with basic moderation capabilities, but the community it has created. For the moment at least, Clubhouse is chock full of cool and influential people. Clubhouse rooms range from typical seminars, to loosely moderated discussions, to essentially chat rooms. The cool thing is you run into people who have interesting stories and lives. For instance, attending a seminar on nuclear disarmament with New York Times reporters, public policymakers, and whatever random influential people show up to pop up on stage. Or attending a discussion on Tibet where Ai Wei Wei, Tibetan monks, and other dissidents pop in. Another interesting product of Clubhouse is that it's opened a large forum for Chinese-language public discussion. Clubhouse is one of the very few online places I've seen people willing to speak frankly on sensitive political issues in Chinese, perhaps because Clubhouse rooms are (at least nominally) ephemeral, leaving no record. Even though Clubhouse is now blocked in China, a lot of this discussion is continuing, with voices on all sides of the political spectrum.
- secondcoming 6y agoBut isn't it invite only?
- xiii1408 6y agoYou can create an account even without an invite. If you give it access to your contacts, your friends will get a notification to invite you, if they have an invite to give. Once you get an invite, your account will be activated, and you can use Clubhouse. This is how I got in, through a friend I hadn't talked to in a while.
- dd36 6y agoThat’s an interesting way to scrape people’s connections and phone numbers.
- Scoundreller 6y ago> 100% of the payment will go to the creator Ohhh, this is going to be a disaster for Manufactured Spend.
- pjc50 6y agoWhat?
- astrange 6y agoHe's suggesting two people can pay each other and get a ton of credit card points off it. This happens anytime you can refill something with 100% of the value you charged to a CC. I've noticed this with Ko-fi too.
- oceliker 6y agoIt sounds like you also need to pay the Stripe processing fee, so I don't think that's viable in this case?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- alwillis 6y agoPeople forget that Instagram was iOS-only for quite a while before an Android version was available. I’ve been on Clubhouse for over two months now; it’s very polished for a beta app and the community it has attracted is unlike anything I’ve ever experienced and I’ve been online since the BBS days of the 80s and everything since then. The $100 million they raised from a16z gives them the runway to do things right. I see the copies shutting down before in their attempts to displace Clubhouse.
- wrinkl3 6y agoInstagram was a much more niche app back when it was iOS-only, and it didn't have the likes of FB, Twitter and Microsoft racing to copy all of its features.
- alwillis 6y agoThere’s over 1 billion iOS devices out there; not having an Android version isn't a limiting factor. I’m aware of lots of Android users who have bought used iPhones or are using their kid’s iPod Touch to access Clubhouse.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mellosouls 6y agoIt's certainly a limiting factor to its supposed principles which claim it to be "inclusive" and "diverse". https://www.notion.so/Community-Guidelines-461a6860abda41649e17c34dc1dd4b5f https://www.notion.so/Community-Guidelines-461a6860abda41649...
- alwillis 6y agoI doubt it. I've spoken with people from all over the world, including those in developing countries, in Clubhouse rooms.
- tiborsaas 6y agoYou've spoken to iPhone owners only, of course they don't see a problem :)
- alwillis 6y agoLet me put it this way: there’s no lack of diversity or inclusiveness now on Clubhouse. The days of only wealthy westerners having iPhones has long past.
- tiborsaas 6y agoAn iPhone only social app is by definition a bubble. Let me make a prediction. When the Android version lands, all the "magic" and exclusiveness of it will be gone.