4 ms·
If Chicago didn't exist, someone else would have put a city within a handful of miles of the same location. It's about as centrally located to the US as you ca
by hinkley 6y ago
If Chicago didn't exist, someone else would have put a city within a handful of miles of the same location.
It's about as centrally located to the US as you can get from the Great Lakes, and once a canal opened (in this case, the Eerie, but shorter canals could have existed, it was just in NYC's interests to have that particular canal), then that's about as far as a boat can go, and water traffic is more efficient than rail.
So you would have trains leaving 'Chicago' to go everywhere, and someone would have thought to build a canal to get to the Illinois river and hence the Mississippi.
I'm not so sure that "St Louis" had to be exactly where it is, but Chicago is virtually a foregone geographical conclusion.
- Scoundreller 6y agoReminds me of US Steel selling off a rail that bypassed the Chicago railtraffic jam for big money: https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-2007-09-27-0709260847-story.html https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-2007-09-27-070926...
- OldHand2018 6y agoFrench explorers recognized the strategic importance of the area in the 1600s. For sure, a large city would eventually sprout in the area where Chicago is. When France ceded the lands of the Illinois Country (east of the Mississippi) to Great Britain in the 1700s, all the French had to GTFO. St Louis was the highest land along the Mississippi anywhere close to the confluences of the Missouri, Ohio and Illinois rivers. Since the Mississippi flooded almost every spring, this was the best place to put a city and it allowed the French to maintain more control over the area than they were supposed to have. The railroads were built by men, however, and could have gone anywhere. The negotiations and influencing that got them all built through Chicago has had a huge ROI for the last 150+ years.
- hinkley 6y ago> St Louis was the highest land That explains it. I kept thinking there must be better spots to put it. It does appear though that it’s surrounded by wide flood plains on several sides and certain spots would be harder to ford than the narrows that bracket the city on two sides.
- Wohlf 6y agoSt. Louis would have likely been in the same general area too because of the Missouri river.
- bobthepanda 6y agoThe Chicago portage is also the shortest distance between the Mississippi and the Great Lakes. So it was more or less destiny.