4 ms·
> The whole system of relying on cheap labor in developing countries would have to change somewhat with decelerating population. The stuff in the West would be
by eru 6y ago
> The whole system of relying on cheap labor in developing countries would have to change somewhat with decelerating population. The stuff in the West would be more expensive, although maybe with fewer workers wages couldn't be so stagnant.
I don't think so. Lots of stuff we consume in the west is made in China. Chinese wages have gone up like crazy in the last few decades. (Not that they are particularly high now, they just used to be sooo low.) Yet, stuff hasn't gotten more expensive for us.
The causality runs the other way:
Wages go up when productivity goes up. Productivity going up in China means they can make more with less work.
So if anything, the proportion of the price in our cheap imported stuff that goes towards labour costs tends to fall as Chinese labour gets more productive.
- starfallg 6y ago>Chinese wages have gone up like crazy in the last few decades. (Not that they are particularly high now, they just used to be sooo low.) Yet, stuff hasn't gotten more expensive for us. That's because of several factors - 1. China has a massive massive population and the majority is still relatively poor. This is still lots of untapped labour available at low cost. 2. The skilled workers that have been trained in the past 3 decades is allowing China to move up in the value chain. They are capturing more of the profits because of this. Look at how many Chinese tech brands establishing significant presence in western markets. They are able to offer lower prices as they are mostly vertically integrated and labour costs of even the skilled positions are generally lower in China (where they centralise a lot of their functions) compared to the west. 3. And at the same time, countries with even cheaper labour are competing with Chinese producers on the low end. You see this particularly with things like clothes and shoes which are labour intensive but relatively low tech.
- cocoland2 6y agoDo not flame a nationalist thing just being very pragmatic here from what i read / watched from a few documentaties. Just paraphrasing what I saw on the netflix series where one of the furniture manufacturer candidly asks a Chinese factory how they are breaking even at the prices that are being sold. The exporter chuckles and says , this is an investment to bleed the local furniture manufacturer (effectively get more demand and forcing other competitors to close , akin to customer acquisition burning VC money ) and become a monopoly in a sense. This is very evident in PPE equipment , masks and on the rare earths supply chain.
- starfallg 6y agoSame thing happening in electronics. The margins are so thin you'd be wondering where they get financing.
- eru 6y agoRare earths supply has diversified quite a bit in recent years. Of course, there has been some government intervention on all sides, but companies are also willing to pay a bit of a premium to secure a second supplier.
- eru 6y ago> 1. China has a massive massive population and the majority is still relatively poor. This is still lots of untapped labour available at low cost. Well, at low cost compared to western labour, but at high cost compared to recent Chinese past. (We would need to introduce some actual numbers in the discussion to say anything more precise.) > They are capturing more of the profits because of this. Just to clarify: things are still becoming cheaper for consumers around the world. Overall the pie has grown. China might be getting relatively more of the pie, but the rest of the world also got more in absolute terms. > 3. And at the same time, countries with even cheaper labour are competing with Chinese producers on the low end. You see this particularly with things like clothes and shoes which are labour intensive but relatively low tech. Yes. But yet, Chinese wages are going up.
- artem247 6y agoHey, I'd like to clarify a couple of points about prices on goods and commodities which I feel often are misunderstood. 1. Prices of goods and price of labour do not correlate. As in decrease/increase in wages do not lead to a change in price of goods. That feels counterintuitive, yet if examined closely you see that price of something is always at the point of maximum profit. So increase in price will lead to less sales and less profit regardless of labour cost. To give you an example - you run a SaaS business with annual $100 price for your most popular plan. You have profits enough to pay you and a couple of developers a salary. Your competitor has similar offering with the same price. Your developers demand a pay increase of 15% - which will put you at a loss. What options are for you without magically getting more market share, getting outside investment etc: A. Cave-in to the wage increase and operate at a loss. B. Increase price of your most popular plan which would lead to less profit and you will have to operate at even greater loss. C. Somehow fire developers and find new ones. This leads to the conclusion that wages and profit margins have inverse causal relationship. Price of goods is determined by supply/demand and non-market forces (regulation etc). 2. Price of labour has no causal relationship with productivity. Price of labour does not have any specific market differences from any other commodity. If the demand for labour is high and supply is low (think software developers) and no monopsony (one buyer market) then the price will go up. I live in Eastern Europe which became a major outsourcing hub in last 15 years or so. Salaries for devs have gone up at least 1000% (number of zeroes is correct) compared to time before outsourcing boom. If there is a monopsony - there is no competition for labour only one company hires people - then the wage would be as low as it can get regardless of productivity. Big employers like Amazon and Walmart can perform crazy fits of neo-taylorism without any kind of wage increase - because they can. If supply of labour increases - then wages will fall, regardless of productivity. The whole reason behind offshoring, outsourcing. 3. Why wages can rise in China: A. A lot of what they do right now demands a higher-skilled workforce which is not in abundance. Low in supply != high productivity. B. China is not only a big factory that supplies goods for the West. As profits are invested into institutions - new opportunities appear. Chinese goods were seen as cheap copies 30 years ago, now it is often price/quality competitive products such Oneplus phones, some of the Chinese cars or even market leaders such as DJI drones and gimbals. All of that requires skilled engineers, designers, marketing people. C. Non-market forces. CCP can pressure business owners to pay better wages or to better comply to labour standards. I'm not sure if that's happening to be honest but that's possible. As a sidenote: If you want to know more about the disconnect between wages and productivity you can read David Ricardo's magnum opus On the Principles of Political Economy and Taxation from 1817, it is not an easy read yet I think in many ways it yet be refuted (in good faith).