7 ms·
The flip side of this is that modern life is really really unfriendly to people with pets. I don’t have a pet, don’t want one either so I have no horse in this
by Spivak 6y ago
The flip side of this is that modern life is really really unfriendly to people with pets. I don’t have a pet, don’t want one either so I have no horse in this race. Basically everywhere where you aren’t required by law to allow animals refuses them because making even the smallest voluntary accommodations for people is just something that doesn’t happen.
The service animal thing is just a loophole to allow people to bring their pets on available-to-the-public transport the way car owners can. Because if you aren’t in walking distance to a dog park and don’t own a car sucks for you I guess.
I don’t think anyone is arguing that untrained animals should just be let to run wild at malls but the blanket refusals that happen don’t even allow for the possibility of well-behaved animals.
Like it would be an absolutely crazy world if every single business and all transportation refused to allow children unless it was deemed medically necessary for the child that their parent be with them at all times. Being a parent would be a logistics nightmare. Being a single parent with an infant would basically be impossible. But that’s what pet owners have to deal with unless they have their own car or are fine confining their pet to their house for their entire life. If this wasn’t already the norm it would be nuts.
- nradov 6y agoIn Vienna people can bring their dogs on public transit as long as they are leashed and muzzled. It seems to work fine.
- jfim 6y ago> Basically everywhere where you aren’t required by law to allow animals refuses them because making even the smallest voluntary accommodations for people is just something that doesn’t happen. What about accommodations for people who are allergic to pets or have phobias about certain animals? Real service animals are specific breeds that are known to be trainable, docile, and are less likely to cause allergic reactions. They're a compromise that allows people who have certain disabilities to have a way to live a more normal life that they would not otherwise have access to. We can't fix blindness and many other disabilities, but service animals can help with improving the quality of life of people who are disabled. Pets aren't that though. They do provide companionship and enjoyment, but they're not necessary for providing assistance with basic needs like locomotion and navigation. They're not breeds that minimize the effects on people who have pet allergies, nor are they necessarily trained to behave properly in almost all situations. When people are putting a "service animal" vest on their pets, bringing them where they would normally not be allowed, and they cause trouble, it makes life harder for people who actually do need service animals for fulfilling their basic needs.
- yostrovs 6y agoThe writer you're replying to is saying that all the rules make it difficult for pet owners to obey them all. So they take any advantage they can. They're not trying to be law breakers. They're effectively put into a position, for example, that their dog lives a life only on a leash when outside or they go to the park and just let it run around. The park may not allow it, but many feel it's inhumane not to let a dog run free on a regular basis. I do that because my dog won't hurt anyone, and if someone in the park fears dogs, well, some people fear spiders.
- jfim 6y agoMany dogs actually do stay leashed in cities and are only free to run in dog parks and in areas where they're allowed to. Those dogs seem fine. If some pet owners decide that the rules aren't for them, that's their choice. Part of living in a society is accepting that there are rules that are inconvenient, and still complying with them. It's definitely inconvenient to have to throw trash in the bin instead of tossing it on the ground, but if everybody did that, the parks would be full of trash, hence there's a "no littering" rule. Responsible things to do would be to check whether local parks allow unleashed dogs before getting one, getting a smaller breed of dog that would get enough exercise by walking leashed, going to the dog park, writing to the city hall that there should be more areas that allow unleashed dogs, or getting housing that would have enough of a back yard to allow the dog to run freely. Out of curiosity, do you believe that people who are scared of dogs are less entitled to use public spaces?
- setr 6y ago> Part of living in a society is accepting that there are rules that are inconvenient, and still complying with them. Another part of living in a society is accepting that rules are blunt and broadly applied, and should not be complied with blindly. They may be broadly correct, but specifically may not be (or overly conservative). The law is the law is not sufficient justification for really anything, except for an officer of the law, the court, or judge dredd.
- curryst 6y ago
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> The flip side of this is that modern life is really really unfriendly to people with pets. Pets—unlike service animals—are a privilege, not a right. No one is born needing a pet to survive, or to participate in society. If a pet inconveniences someone else, the pet owner needs to make accommodations, and not the other way around.
- msrenee 6y agoPets are a privilege? Granted by whom? Am I seriously not free in society to own an animal without the express permission of whatever entity you look to in order to function? I don't need a coffee table to survive. Is that a privilege? Carpeted floors?I mean, indoor plumbing's kind of a modern frivolity if you think about it.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoCoffee tables are also a privilege. If a coffee table inconveniences someone else, the coffee table owner needs to make accommodations, and not the other way around. The difference is that a coffee table rarely affects the life of anyone other than its owner.
- brippalcharrid 6y agoThere's a big difference between refusing to allow a blind person to take their rigorously-trained guide dog into an Uber or a restaurant, or an aeroplane, and refusing access access to someone's service pitbull (or, as you mention it, service pony[1]). The concept of service animals and unofficial assistance dogs as opposed to guide dogs abuses the accommodations that societies have made to help blind people. And now businesses are being put in a position where they have to find a way of limiting the downsides from the proliferation of "service animals" and "emotional assistance animals" without discriminating against blind people, with both hands tied behind their backs. Cities are unfriendly to people with pets. Private rented accommodation and transportation are unfriendly to people with pets. And an Uber surcharge that covered finding drivers who were willing to [generally] transport people with dogs would probably be unpopular with dog owners, as are additional deposits and cleaning fees for apartments. Have you considered that many people would prefer not to use an Uber that had previously been used to transport a dog (guide dogs excepted), or to go to a mall that had dogs (apart from guide dogs)? And there's the question of training. Do you know how much it costs to train a guide dog (even excluding the helping-blind-people parts)? Or that many breeds of dog aren't suitable for the high level of training that enables guide dogs to be accepted and respected? Realistically, the vast majority of people wouldn't go to the lengths of training their [emotional support] animal to that level. And would you be happy with restricting access to malls to pet owners that could afford that level of training? Some would see it as discriminatory. And it would all be completely unenforceable and lead to massive liability for business owners. 1. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/miniature-horse-on-plane-woman-took-service-animal-flight-could-be-his-last-airlines/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/miniature-horse-on-plane-woman-...