3 ms·

I see this logic a lot, and it doesn't quite sit right with me because it doesn't really address the actual problem, which is: I'm not as afraid of being dead,

by rewgs 6y ago

I see this logic a lot, and it doesn't quite sit right with me because it doesn't really address the actual problem, which is: I'm not as afraid of being dead, so much as I am most afraid of the short time before. Knowing that I'm dying, that soon I will be dead. And also the finality of it. Pre-birth ended with my birth. Death will never end.

adrusi 6y ago
That's not quite right. If you can't be afraid of actually being dead because you won't be experiencing anything, then you in fact won't be afraid in the moments before, so there would be no reason to be afraid of the moments before either. But you actually can be afraid of death, even though death doesn't come with any negative experiences, because you can and do care about things besides anticipated experiences. It's a common misconception that you can only care about experiences, but the counter to any conceptual argument that purports to prove that is that you do in fact care about some things that aren't experiences, death being a great example. My friend Ronny discusses this at some length in this podcast https://clearerthinkingpodcast.com/?ep=032 https://clearerthinkingpodcast.com/?ep=032
Aeolun 6y ago
> Death will never end. As far as we know. It seems logical based on our existing knowledge, but really, anything can happen. Certainly we’ve never seen someone come back from the dead in recent history.
- BuyMyBitcoins 6y ago
  I don’t know why, but your comment seems pretty profound. Especially if you’ve ever looked at those timelines of the far future on Wikipedia where something like 10^10^10^10...........^10 quadrillion years will pass but a there’s a probability that a quantum fluctuation could create a new universe in that time.
rland 6y ago
The only thing we have in life is the present moment. So, the only thing we lose in death is the present moment.
alexashka 6y ago
I've heard of an actor who got so into role-playing, he forgot he was an actor playing a role. He was meant to slay dragons, but terribly afraid of getting eaten in the process. It kept him up at night, he asked people how to cope with the stress and got plenty of advice, to which he replied the suggestions don't address his actual problem.

by rewgs 6y ago

adrusi 6y ago

That's not quite right. If you can't be afraid of actually being dead because you won't be experiencing anything, then you in fact won't be afraid in the moments before, so there would be no reason to be afraid of the moments before either. But you actually can be afraid of death, even though death doesn't come with any negative experiences, because you can and do care about things besides anticipated experiences. It's a common misconception that you can only care about experiences, but the counter to any conceptual argument that purports to prove that is that you do in fact care about some things that aren't experiences, death being a great example. My friend Ronny discusses this at some length in this podcast https://clearerthinkingpodcast.com/?ep=032 https://clearerthinkingpodcast.com/?ep=032

Aeolun 6y ago

> Death will never end. As far as we know. It seems logical based on our existing knowledge, but really, anything can happen. Certainly we’ve never seen someone come back from the dead in recent history.

BuyMyBitcoins 6y ago
I don’t know why, but your comment seems pretty profound. Especially if you’ve ever looked at those timelines of the far future on Wikipedia where something like 10^10^10^10...........^10 quadrillion years will pass but a there’s a probability that a quantum fluctuation could create a new universe in that time.

rland 6y ago

The only thing we have in life is the present moment. So, the only thing we lose in death is the present moment.

alexashka 6y ago

I've heard of an actor who got so into role-playing, he forgot he was an actor playing a role. He was meant to slay dragons, but terribly afraid of getting eaten in the process. It kept him up at night, he asked people how to cope with the stress and got plenty of advice, to which he replied the suggestions don't address his actual problem.