5 ms·
> while a car lasts only 10-15 years While it might be the case that today’s EVs will not be economically longer-lived than 15 years, the overall average age o
by sokoloff 6y ago
> while a car lasts only 10-15 years
While it might be the case that today’s EVs will not be economically longer-lived than 15 years, the overall average age of a car in the US is 12 years, and most of my cars have been bought with 10 or more years on them as it makes for very inexpensive motoring (no need for collision or comprehensive insurance, no financing interest, and nearly no depreciation).
I bought my 2015 LEAF new and suspect it will not be economically viable in 2030 while our 2005 Honda CR-V is 16 years old now, still going strong, and most likely will still be in service in 2030.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> no need for collision or comprehensive insurance, no financing interest, and nearly no depreciation But you need to maintain it and have it inspected instead! And you're also paying with your safety - ten years is a very long time in safety technology these days!
- r00fus 6y agoSurely you jest. What safety features on standard vehicles became indispensable in the past 10 years? Note: things like collision avoidance and adaptive cruise are still luxury features and the OG poster wouldn’t have bought those anyway.
- lumost 6y agoCollision avoidance is now standard tech. Subaru has been making automatic breaking/adaptive cruise control a standard feature of all new model designs. Legacies MSRP at 22k, and the 18k impreza is due for a redesign in 2022. A quick google shows that the 2021 versa may be the cheapest car with automatic breaking at $16600 MSRP. https://www.subaru.com/engineering/safety.html https://www.subaru.com/engineering/safety.html https://www.nissanusa.com/shopping-tools/build-price?models=versa&modelYear=current-year https://www.nissanusa.com/shopping-tools/build-price?models=...
- brucehoult 6y agoMy 2008 Outback 2.5XT has Eyesight adaptive cruise control including automatic breaking! Cost me US$6k a year ago with 55000 miles. Thirteen years old!
- chrisseaton 6y agoCollision avoidance, speed limiting, adaptive speed limiting, adaptive headlights, lane keeping, blind-spot warning, ISO-FIX anchors, far stronger pillars, reversing cameras, lane exit monitors, SOS buttons and GPS reporting, far more air bags, door-cyclist collision warnings, seat-belt pre-tensioning, some have pre-collision suspension raising, etc, etc, etc. I just went from a 2009 Land Rover to a 2020 Land Rover, so almost exactly 10 years, and one of the the main reasons I did it was safety features. They weren't standard on my model before and they are now. It's night and day.
- waiseristy 6y agoDon't forget TPMS! Probably one of the best safety-to-dollar-spent advancements in the last *13 years
- mrfusion 6y agoInteresting. What makes you say that?
- chrisseaton 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firestone_and_Ford_tire_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firestone_and_Ford_tire_contro... "271 fatalities and over eight hundred injuries in the United States with more injuries and fatalities occurring internationally" and would have been detected by a TPMS which costs a few dollars.
- alisonkisk 6y agoA few dollars times tens of millions of cars.
- throwawayboise 6y agoBlowing out an underinflated tire at high speed is probably a reasonably common cause of accidents.
- brucehoult 6y agoMy 2008 Subaru Outback 2.5XT (JDM model) has camera-based adaptive cruise control, lane departure warning, lead vehicle start warning ("stop looking at your phone"), and pre-collision braking. Also AWD, 265 HP turbo engine. I bought it for NZ$10k (US$6000) in May last year, with 87000 km. https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EnuwXA6VcAAH9MJ.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EnuwXA6VcAAH9MJ.jpg
- sokoloff 6y agoMaintenance beyond consumables (brakes, wipers, and tires) costs less than the difference in excise tax ($25 tax per $1000 of imputed value every year). All cars are inspected annually here. At 4K miles per year (my average pre-COVID), if my risk is average, I’d expect to be in a fatal accident slightly less than once every 22K years. I’m OK without the latest driver aids at that low level of risk.
- oblio 6y ago> I’m OK without the latest driver aids at that low level of risk. Driver aid, ok. But passive safety?
- ghaff 6y agoI have a 10 year old vehicle. The current model has the basic advanced safety features (auto-braking, adaptive cruise control). But, no, I wouldn't get a new vehicle just to get those features. And this is coming from someone who does generally buy new cars.
- sokoloff 6y agoI expect I’d get more passive safety improvement from buying a 5000# 2011 car/SUV than a 3500# 2021 car/SUV, but if I move my risk from once every 22K (or even 20K) years to once every 25K or 30K years, it’s not clear that’s meaningfully different. I’d probably be much better off to take less stress at work over car payments and/or lose 5 pounds on an all-risks basis.
- dzhiurgis 6y agoIf you look at some people dedicated to testing EV’s - Tesla’s phantom braking has become huge driving factor away from their cars.
- theshrike79 6y ago4k miles per year isn't really anything, no point in getting anything more than the bare minimum. According to most studies EVs are more eco-friendly after around 50-100k miles depending on each individual country's energy production profile. At 4k miles per year you'd need to drive a brand new EV for over 12 years to break even CO2 wise.
- VBprogrammer 6y agoTime will tell but I've got my fingers crossed that in 15 years time any backstreet garage will exchange your battery on a car of that age for a cost proportionate to the fact that you could reasonably expect another 10 years of trouble free motoring. With luck with a 50% increase on its original capacity.
- theshrike79 6y agoThey already do. A battery swap/refresh/replacement for a Leaf is 5-10k€ over here, depending on how bad shape the original is and whether you want a larger battery in there. It's kinda sorta doable by yourself, but it's a HVDC circuit so you _really_ need to know what you're doing. Actual brand-name shops are slowly able to replace individual failed cell packs instead of just swapping the whole battery. The big problem is that batteries aren't really failing and because of that the manufacturers don't really have a process in place for replacements, each operation is a custom job.
- VBprogrammer 6y ago> Leaf is 5-10k€ Those are pretty wide error bars, last time I looked at used Leaf's they were selling for somewhere in that range. Admittedly first gen leafs with the 24KWh battery.
- turtlebits 6y agoThe 2015 Leaf has the worst battery degradation of any EV. That's Nissan's fault. However, battery prices are going drop further. Your Leaf has a 24kWh pack. At the current $100/kwh price, thats $2400 for a completely new battery. In the future I'm sure you could get an even higher capacity replacement.
- dehrmann 6y agoThat might have been an intentional choice if they knew either they'd sell to suckers and leave them on the hook for the new battery, or have to subsidize a new battery in 5 years, knowing it would be cheaper, like writing a call on batteries.
- theshrike79 6y agoThe battery had literally zero temperature management, no heating or cooling. They literally could've added a 12 volt chassis fan to make it not suck so bad. Rapidgate was a thing, the battery heated up when driving, you stop to recharge -> battery heats up even more -> overheat -> limiters engage and you're charging at hand crank levels of power.
- sokoloff 6y agoThe LEAF has a battery heater. It does suck for having only passive cooling.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoThe funny thing is their electric vans do have thermal battery management.
- manmal 6y agoThe Leaf was built with Japanese climate in mind, where peak temperatures are usually not as high. I always found that strange, given that automotive components are usually tested for outlier conditions.
- wazoox 6y agoThe new Dacia Spring has a 27kWh battery and costs only 12k€. In the electric car market, the situation is evolving extremely rapidly.
- Reason077 6y ago> "I bought my 2015 LEAF new and suspect it will not be economically viable in 2030" Why not? There are already companies who specialize in replacing early-model LEAF batteries with new, higher-capacity ones. By 2030, I imagine this could be a pretty widespread industry - perhaps even rebuilding/remanufacturing OEM battery packs with new cells. And so long as the battery still works, that LEAF will always be "economically viable" because unlike combustion vehicles, there are practically no ongoing maintenance costs.
- sokoloff 6y agoBecause it will cost around $2-3K for the battery replacement on a car chassis that’ll be worth around $2K to get back to a range and set of features that won’t be competitive with the then-current (no pun intended) EVs or other $5K cars. If you want to spend $5K on a car in 2030, you’ll have way better options than a 75 mile range, 6kW charging (20-24 miles per hour) 2015 LEAF (CHAdeMO will be fully dead by then and most 2015 LEAFs don't even have it.)
- deelowe 6y agoI wish a battery replacement was 2 grand. Try like 8 if you can find one.
- Reason077 6y agoA $5k, 75-mile used EV still offers a lot of utility and value because it will cost almost nothing to run and maintain. No doubt you’ll be able to buy great $5k combustion cars in 2030, but ongoing fuel and maintenance means their true cost is a lot more than that! And in some parts of the world, increasingly stringent emissions controls mean that combustion cars become more expensive, or even illegal, to drive in cities. You’re right about CHAdeMO, but anyone buying a 75 mile EV isn’t going to care too much about fast charging anyway. And by 2030, someone may have come up with a retrofit and/or adapter to make old LEAFs compatible with CCS?
- sokoloff 6y agoA 2018 model 3 or X might be a sub-$5K (in 2021 dollars) car by 2030. If they are, very few batteries will be replaced in old LEAFs. The faster that new EVs mature/evolve, the less comparative value older ones have meaning they will be getting scrapped when the next battery replacement is needed. I do all the maintenance on our cars (ex- tires, body, and warranty/recalls). The LEAF has already had one battery repair under warranty (at around 17K miles, out of service for several weeks and likely a $2K+ repair at future independent rates-was 2 techs for most of a day plus pages of special sealants and consumables) Other than that it has needed wipers and windshield fluid and that’s it. If that pattern keeps up, they’re still headed to the scrapyard en masse, I think.