6 ms·
I mean, at this point I think everyone should just accept that at the very least their name, age, address(es), email(s), phone number(s) and screen name(s) have
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
I mean, at this point I think everyone should just accept that at the very least their name, age, address(es), email(s), phone number(s) and screen name(s) have been fully leaked if you have ever had any kind of online presence. Not saying that's right or good, but at this point it's just a fact.
So if that's the case, I think we should move beyond really even trying to think of this info as private or a marker of identity, and we need to move everyone to more secure forms of identity verification.
As has been pointed out on HN before, "identity theft" is a made-up concept to make it seem as if you had something stolen from you, when the real problem is banks and other service providers do an absolute shit job of identity verification. They're the ones at fault, and they try to shift the onus onto you to fix things when they screw up.
Indeed, a social security number is pretty much the only additional piece of data to the stuff above that one would need to open up a bank account in someone else's name, and those have been leaked plenty of times too.
The government needs to make harsher penalties for banks and others that can ruin your credit, etc. because they accept all this leaked info as "proof" of identity.
- anticristi 6y agoLike really? Don't you have to walk to a bank or show some ID? I live in the EU and I do operate under the assumption that banks take reasonable measures to ensure an account is linked to a legal identity.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoNo. Many online services will let you open a bank account with name, address, phone, DOB and social security number.
- iso1210 6y agoWithout sending a confirmation letter to the address and SMS to the phone?
- brendoelfrendo 6y agoIf you're the fraudster, you're providing the address and phone number.
- iso1210 6y agoIn which case it surely wouldn't match with credit report databases?
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoIt turns out that signing up for a new bank account is something that people commonly do at the same time as they're moving to a new place and change their address and phone number.
- iso1210 6y agoSo you're saying there's effectively no checks for ID for opening a bank account in the US?
- cwillu 6y ago"As has been pointed out on HN before, "identity theft" is a made-up concept to make it seem as if you had something stolen from you, when the real problem is banks and other service providers do an absolute shit job of identity verification. They're the ones at fault, and they try to shift the onus onto you to fix things when they screw up."
- the_svd_doctor 6y agoNo in the Us you can easily open one online just by answering a few questions and giving your SSN. Sometimes they will ask you to upload an ID. But that could also have been leaked.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- seaman1921 6y agos/if you have ever had any kind of online presence./if you, your friends, your family, your cleaning lady etc. has ever had any kind of online presence.
- ubertoop 6y agoThe scary thing is how much ones phone number (a somewhat ephemeral thing) is actually bound to your IDENTITY. Considering your phone number is more and more being used in 2FA ... if you were to ever change your number and someone else got it, this would pose a serious security risk if you failed to change over ALL of your internet accounts 2FA to the new number.
- ourcat 6y agoI've always thought the most scary thing about this practice is that your (unique) phone number is a powerful "foreign key" which could potentially join data from many other leaked databases, forming an even larger dataset on you. There are plently of other places we give our phone numbers to, which might not have anywhere near the protections that Facebook say they provide.
- mopsi 6y agoAbsolutely, and e-mail or Paypal account name too. Neither of them are trivial to change. If you try to create a new account for each thing at a generic mail provider such as Gmail, your accounts will be shut down by automatic abuse filters. If you roll your own domain, then, well... the domain becomes the foreign key.
- seng 6y agoWould using a separate service email accounts help mitigate issues? seng-baking@gmail.com, then seng-banking+icici@gmail.com, seng-banking+axis@gmail.com, etc? That way my primary email would stay private and will used only for email, not for identity.
- sammax 6y agoYour private email that you don't use for signing up anywhere is irrelevant except for phishing and spam. Your secondary email address will become the foreign key that is used to correlate the datasets from everywhere you signed up with it. The +tags can just be removed since it is known how they work. Might give you a small protection against attackers who don't know about email address tags.
- ransom1538 6y ago"I mean, at this point I think everyone should just accept that at the very least their name, age, address(es), email(s), phone number(s) and screen name(s) have" Yes. I think the scary part is WHAT these identifiers are connected to. EG. your email being linked to a private antifa community, pro-Taiwan communities, adulteration meetups, etc.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoThe problem is completely the opposite. The flaw is the existence of social security numbers. Prohibit them from being used for anything but social security. Then there is no "your social security number" or "your identity" for someone to open a bank account against. You open a bank account and they give you a bank card and you set an address and phone number. The day you open it, they shouldn't need to know who you are, because it's a new account with $0 in it. After that, the owner of the account is the person with that bank card who can be reached at the address and phone number given when the account was created. Get rid of centralized identity and there is no centralized identity to steal.
- jand 6y agoI stand by your SSN only for social security point. But the rest sounds plain wrong to me. Your phone might get stolen, your name might change due to marriage, your address might change because you moved/got evicted. What now?
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoYour phone gets stolen so you use your bank card and password to set a new phone number on your account. Your bank card gets stolen so you use your phone and password to get a new bank card. If someone steals your phone and password and bank card and ability to receive mail at your home address all at once then you're pretty screwed, but you're pretty screwed then regardless, right? That's the level of screwed where somebody else can also get a government ID in your name.
- jand 6y agoWell, you did not mention a password before. With a password, you introduce a new 'security feature' which changes your argument in a non-trivial way. This might work better than your proposal before.
- laurent92 6y agoFor sufficient amounts or suspicious operations, banks should be in charge of authentification, ie showing up in-person for bank transfers such as a car, showing up and supplying fingerprints if the bank transfer buys a house... And in fact, for poor people, anything that might engage their entire savings might also benefit from a more advanced identity verification. For example my stock exchange account just takes a password. It’s a scandal.
- johnchristopher 6y ago> So if that's the case, I think we should move beyond really even trying to think of this info as private or a marker of identity, and we need to move everyone to more secure forms of identity verification. Even if this info wouldn't be good enough to sign for official stuff it's still private and unique enough to target you though.
- black_puppydog 6y agoWell, I think at this point we can conclude that companies will not be good shepherds of our should-be-private data if we don't incentivize them to. Who'd have guessed? I appreciate the pragmatic stance you take, and we should definitely move to more robust identification methods. But making this case for better ID tech should IMHO not be confused with giving facebook and the others a pass. This should never have happened, and the very fact that we have a data trove this big is already a problem. That they don't seem to even attempt to protect that data is another one. Close that shop up. The fines for this kind of stuff (and the other stunts they've pulled) should make it economically no longer viable to keep it open, really. The first time you fuck up this hard, the fines should hurt. This is not their first time.
- op03 6y agoWont happen. All the politicians world over have been trained like Pavlovs dogs to chase Likes as a route to power. So its like asking addicts to not just give up their drugs but to take down the cartels. The time to shutdown Facebook has past. Now we just have to suck it up and endure them and their effects like we do Cancer.
- black_puppydog 6y agoAgain, I get the sentiment, but I disagree.
- ldbooth 6y agoCompanies effectively run the government, via the 2 party system and the back and forth of high level corporate execs back and forth into gov't. They don't want to rock the boat once that bountiful position is achieved. That said, how to get the government to regulate corporations who regulate the government. Maybe I'm becoming too cynical, but there has to be an externality like the great depression in order for The People to take back the reigns of power (at least in the US).
- fragile_frogs 6y ago> Indeed, a social security number is pretty much the only additional piece of data to the stuff above that one would need to open up a bank account in someone else's name I am not from the US, but is this really all you need to "proof" your identity? The most common thing I have seen in the EU when companies have a KYC requirement is that during the sign up process you will have a quick video call where you have show your ID card while they verify that your ID is legit.