5 ms·
Schoonschip – Unique residential area: floating, sustainable, circular
- gleenn 6y agoTheir argument that 2/3rds the world is covered in water means it's a good place to build houses seems strained at best. Diversifying housing styles seems like a good idea in general but the number of problems you get probably outweigh the benefits, like your house could sink, get blown away in a storm, where would you "dock" it to begin with, and how do you manage all the utility connections. Good luck to them but leaving my home firmly attached to earth thanks.
- antonvs 6y ago> Their argument that 2/3rds the world is covered in water means it's a good place to build houses seems strained at best. Agreed. The houses in the article's pictures are in a city canal and docked. They're basically using urban real estate that happens to be covered in water. Locations where you can do that are a very small fraction of Earth's area. How this translates into using the 2/3rds of the world that's covered in water doesn't seem to be something they've really addressed.
- brnt 6y agoMost of humanity lives near coasts and rivers. The idea of these houses is that they're flooding resistant: they just move up and down with changing water levels. They're well anchored, but indeed utility connection are a weak spot, perhaps modulated by having solar panels. In either case, they obviate the need for precise and expensive regional water table control, for which the Netherlands is famous. That kind of control isn't a feasible solution for many countries, whereas floating houses would be. I'm not sure these houses are the answer though, but perhaps they'll come with some other answers to questions related to living in this way.
- jmiskovic 6y agoSure, floating houses in middle of ocean is awful idea. But one can imagine some habitats that could work in lakes and calmer seas and this could be important step. First learn which materials work over long periods, achieve structural stability, and solve numerous other practical matters in safe environment. It is easier to iterate and failure is less expensive. I have bigger problem with sticking the open source label when all they share is couple of email addresses.
- jillesvangurp 6y agoPeople have been living on docked boats in the Netherlands for very long. Lots of cities have old barges with students living on them. Some of these are very old. Going circular here opens up a lot more areas to habitation as you need less infrastructure to make it work. Those old house boats have electricity, water, sewage, and gas connections. You don't need any of that if you can do everything on site. You are floating in water. All you need to do to use it is filter it. For waste water, you need to clean it up before you release it back to where it came from. Most of the tap water in Amsterdam comes from the water that surrounds it in any case. For energy, solar, wind, and batteries should go a long way. The main thing you need is enough square meters for the panels. 50KW should go a long way even on very cloudy winter days. If you insulate the houses/boats properly (i.e. lower your energy needs) it barely needs any heating or cooling. Also, you are floating in water, which makes heat exchange pumps really easy (no need to dig in the ground). Lots of nice engineering problems to solve there. Phone/internet can be wireless these days 4G/5G, or space link. There is no need for gas if you heat & cook electric. This looks like it still uses some shared infrastructure (probably for cost/efficiency reasons) but you could feasibly design something that is completely self sufficient. The key thing is to make durable structures that don't need a lot of maintenance, that are energy efficient, etc. As for the other risks. Boats sink occasionally but rarely when they are safely docked in a harbor. You obviously don't want to dock in a place that has currents, large waves, etc. There are plenty of secluded lakes, channels, etc. that should be perfectly fine for this.
- bluGill 6y ago> There are plenty of secluded lakes, channels, etc. that should be perfectly fine for this. No there are not plenty. Sure 70% of the earth is covered in water, but only 2.5% is freshwater, and a fair amount of that is lakes large enough to have currents and large waves as well (I don't know how to figure out how much is stable enough that you could consider living on a boat there. I think we can estimate that 2% of the earth is the type of place where you could consider living in a boat - and much of that isn't a place where you want to live (ie not a city), and the rest needs to a lot of land reserved for shipping lanes. Living in a boat is an interesting niche that a few people can do. However it isn't a solution for any housing problem.
- m463 6y agoI think a more interesting thought might be - many if not most cities have been built next to water, and now the purpose of the water has disappeared. Since the rise of container shipping, lots of city infrastructure near the water has been made obsolete. Loading docks, warehouses, manufacturing and all the rest have been replaced. Now you have a container parking lot and a gantry usually in a cheaper location with uncongested rail and freeway access, which is no longer directly in an urban center. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Containerization#Effects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Containerization#Effects "This fundamental transformation of where warehouse work was performed freed up valuable waterfront real estate near the central business districts of port cities around the world for redevelopment and led to a plethora of waterfront revitalization projects (such as warehouse districts)."
- KaiserPro 6y agoIf you're in the lowlands, then the risk of flooding during a storm is most definitely non-zero. In the UK, developers have been building on flood planes because the land is cheap. So a floating house just cuts out the middleman. In holland, people have been living on barges for _years_. It's partly why I'd never swim in the canals in amsterdam, because those old barges discharge effluent. However hooking up utilities is trivial, pipes are bendy, and moorings are mostly fixed. The advantage of floating houses in this instance is the portability. Not only can a house be built at a factory and moved, reducing price. But if the mooring terms and conditions are terrible, one can move.
- jacquesm 6y ago> because those old barges discharge effluent. No they don't. In 2008 the government decided that by 2018 all houseboats/barges/other boats that people live on had to be connected to the sewage system. It's possible that there are still a few stragglers but as a rule they don't.
- bryanrasmussen 6y ago>Their argument that 2/3rds the world is covered in water means it's a good place to build houses seems strained at best that's strained for sure, but it does follow that it is a good idea to solve the problem of building housing on water that solves the attendant problems.
- dr_dshiv 6y agoWikipedia on Almere: "Almere is the newest city in the Netherlands: the land on which the city sits, the Southern Flevoland polder, was reclaimed from the IJsselmeer from 1959 to 1968. " Reclaimed isn't quite the right word. They turned ocean into land. This was possible because of a megadike construction project: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zuiderzee_Works https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zuiderzee_Works This created buildable waters. But rather than just building land on the water and houses on the land, one can directly build houses on the (buildable) water. The scope of ambition is truly inspiring.
- stephc_int13 6y agoIn some places, Neolithic houses were built on lakes, probably to offer protection against predators and easy access to fish.
- reportgunner 6y agoWhere does the toilet water go?
- skrebbel 6y agoIt's the "black water" pipe in the diagram.
- reportgunner 6y agoOhh now I see it, thanks. I was looking at the bottom of the picture and I didn't see it connected. I completely missed that there is stuff connected to solid ground under the bridge.
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoProcessed by the bio-refinery, and turned into (mostly) energy. These systems already exist; they're expensive, and not really modular, but for ~100 people it should be doable without too many problems. Harder and more expensive to do for a single family home.
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoSo interesting to read about this. I am working on a (side) project to plan and launch a small community of houses built on water, pretty much in a similar way. (in my case, the candidate site is the Venice lagoon in Italy). The main advantage is that you can remove most of the senseless regulatory constraints - and if you do it right, there's mostly just upside. Building costs are slightly higher, but you also get other benefits, such as protection from earthquakes. Granted, this has to be done in a water area that is not subject to unusual weather situations. It is not for everybody, sure. But it is something probably worth experimenting with.
- messo 6y agoA nicer and more detailed presentation is available at https://greenprint.schoonschipamsterdam.org/ https://greenprint.schoonschipamsterdam.org/ (both in English and Dutch).
- shellfishgene 6y agoThe text is refreshingly honest about the lessons learned.
- messo 6y agoIt is, and having spent much time in The Netherlands, I find this honesty to be typically Dutch. They usually don't mince words and seem to have a somewhat shared and implicit understanding that real cooperation can't happen without acknowledging and addressing the problems facing them.
- rainworld 6y agoUpper middle class liberals love this kind of thing because it lets them live amongst themselves with plausible deniability. Open borders for thee; selective high trust community for me!
- nerdponx 6y agoFine by me, let people who actually need to commute live in housing close to where they work, and let the rich people who have the money to beta test eco tech do so, even if they're just doing it to flex on each other.
- tengbretson 6y agoIf they want to live in a child-hostile alcatraz, let them.
- antonvs 6y agoGives new meaning to the phrase "sink or swim"!
- spiritplumber 6y agoMeanwhile in Sausalito if you want to live on a houseboat that you own the fixed expenses are something like $4K/month.
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoDo you know why expenses are that high?
- antonvs 6y agoAccording to https://www.california.com/sausalitos-floating-homes-and-houseboats/ https://www.california.com/sausalitos-floating-homes-and-hou... from 2019: > ...the cost of docking, water, garbage, sewer, and parking. In total, residents typically spend around $1,100 on these expenses, with additional budgets for other amenities like cable and Internet [which may be more expensive than normal?] Given the smaller house payments, however, these fees become less burdensome.
- nerdponx 6y agoHow important is the "floating" part here? How much of this can be adapted to inland dwelling? Also how resistant is this type of home to storms? New York for instance gets big dangerous storm surges once in a while, not to mention areas farther south along the east coast of the USA.
- einpoklum 6y ago> How much of this can be adapted to inland dwelling? From a cursory glance - most of it. But it's a semi-commune, anyway, so you need willing participants. I would _love_ to move into a place like that myself... but capitalist societies don't tend to encourage this type of communal projects as an alternative to atomized individualist social arrangements.
- rodelrod 6y agoCommunities like this pop up regularly but are naturally unstable. They sometimes (often?) work great while their members are like-minded, young and healthy. Over the years the population inevitably drifts and the community either collapses or becomes more and more embedded in the surrounding society, which has more stable institutions to deal with people not thinking alike. Check out the Utopia series [0] from "The Theory of Everything" podcast for some examples. [0] https://theoryofeverythingpodcast.com/series/utopia/ https://theoryofeverythingpodcast.com/series/utopia/
- Johnyma22 6y agoAre we now okay with a project like this calling itself "Open Source"? Is it "Open Source"? If yes, why? If no? What are our concerns and how can we take action?
- Aeolun 6y agoThey have a really weird definition of circular. That looks distinctly rectangular to me. The alternative interpretation sounds faintly new age to me.
- junon 6y agoI'm sure there's a term for this but it's a common marketing strategy to create a new buzzword to cause inquisitive minds to wonder and then make your website the only place where information is found. I believe this is one of those cases, and I wouldn't be surprised if it were deliberate.
- antonvs 6y agoThey're using an established term, referring partly to circularity in resource consumption, i.e. a closed loop. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circular_economy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circular_economy
- SideburnsOfDoom 6y agoI can only assume that it refers to Circular Economy (1) not circular shape. 1) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circular_economy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circular_economy
- Klwohu 6y agoLooks pretty impractical, plus there's gonna be a LOT of garbage that winds up in the water.
- wdb 6y agoMaybe it's because I am visiting the site abroad but there isn't a Dutch version of this page? The Englishification of Amsterdam and other major cities in The Netherlands are starting to worry me.
- waffletower 6y agoFloating homes are also quite common in the United States; many examples can be found along the Mississippi and Columbia rivers.