13 ms·
That's sad. I must be the only one who thinks full self driving will not happen before year 2100. Is there an example of anything that's completely automated t
by endisneigh 6y ago
That's sad.
I must be the only one who thinks full self driving will not happen before year 2100. Is there an example of anything that's completely automated that's dangerous? I cannot think of a single thing. At best things are partially automated and need humans still.
The thing is, if you have "partial" self driving, you might as well just drive yourself IMHO. The consequence of being wrong with a car is literally your life. I know people like comparing this with airplanes, trains, or the elevator, but cars in the USA is just too chaotic an environment. It's nothing like any of those.
- meteor333 6y agoEven for airplanes and trains, we still have pilots and humans behind the controller with 100% attention.
- minhazm 6y agoWe don't have fully automated planes because they're already safe enough and the economics aren't there. The probability of crashing with a plane is extremely low, even factoring in the higher risk of takeoffs and landings. The entire process is coordinated with Air Traffic Control. Since planes are so safe already and pilots are relatively inexpensive, there's no strong financial incentive to fully automate planes.
- endisneigh 6y agoPlanes are also substantially regulated. I mean if there was a Vehicular Traffic Control on every intersection the same way there's Air Traffic Control we probably wouldn't have any accidents now, negating the main purported benefit of self driving to begin with.
- meteor333 6y agoDisagree on the economics. Pilots cost significant money and since the airline industry runs on low margins this can be a huge plus. But the main reason we won't see planes without pilots is political and related to trust. I think for the same reasons we are less likely to see truly driverless cars.
- giobox 6y agoThere's plenty of examples of driverless trains throughout the world. > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_automated_train_systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_automated_train_system...
- meteor333 6y agoFair enough. Thanks for correcting me. But i stand corrected. Guided tracks is hardly a good comparison for this.
- seanmcdirmid 6y ago> we still have pilots and humans behind the controller with 100% attention. That really isn't true. Pilots, in particular, have huge challenges in keeping attention up between take off and landing. Likewise for trains, it turns out if you don't require humans to do anything but watch...it is much harder than if they were actually doing the flying/driving themselves. The airforce is moving to unpiloted drones, though there is someone at a center to intervene as needed. It is only a matter of time before they decide that cargo can be moved in this way (think: fedex).
- dmitrygr 6y ago> I must be the only one who thinks full self driving will not happen before year 2100. Nope. Me as well. I think self driving is AGI-complete, and we are as far from AGI now as when we were living in caves, banging rocks together.
- bumby 6y agoThere’s a decent amount of factory automation that is essentially fully autonomous with the exception of a “big red emergency shutdown” button for a human to press if all the other safeties fail. Many operate without continuous oversight and in the cases where a human is positioned to watch its usually for economic reasons rather than safety (e.g., to stop the operation if there is a quality issue that will render the product unusable) Edit: downvoting is fine but please at least add to the discussion by stating why you disagree. I’m speaking only from my personal experience working in factory automation and realize there’s probably a lot of differing experience
- endisneigh 6y agoMy understanding is that with factory automation usually it's designed to the human is not in danger (usually they aren't even present at all). Are there factories that exist that are automated in a way where the human is exposed to a potentially lethal injury?
- bumby 6y ago>Are there factories that exist that are automated in a way where the human is exposed to a potentially lethal injury? Yes, but probably to a lesser extent than driving a car. Everything has sensors that are meant to identify a risk to a human and stop whatever operation poses that risk. E.g., there may be robots picking thousands of pounds of parts and driving them around a facility but they stop if they sense a human a their path. Same for welding, stamping, etc. All those operations can injure or kill but unlike vehicles they can rely on the mitigation of “stop and wait”. It’s a much easier problem than self-driving
- jeffy90 6y agoI wonder if perhaps we can't get self driving cars, but maybe we can can't self driving train carts and move completely away from cars?
- edwr 6y agoself driving light rail would be interesting
- KirillPanov 6y agoThis is basically where we will end up when the tech industry gets its head out of the clouds. The carpool lanes will be converted to rail tracks. You can pay extra for a rail-compatible car if you want and sleep during your commute. As implausible as it sounds this is still way more likely than driverless wheeled vehicles becoming both safe and useful.
- piptastic 6y agoI don't know about 2100 but I've made some bets that self driving cars won't be available in the next 5 years.. 2 years ago.
- billfruit 6y agoDoes anyone else think that may be full autonomous flying of aircraft will be easier to make practical than driving of automobiles?
- craftinator 6y agoI thought this was obvious. The complexity that cars deal with during travel is many orders of magnitude higher than the complexity aircraft deal with, and cars actually have an effect on the complexity of the environment they travel in, unlike aircraft. For the most part, aircraft one have ONE object that they have to avoid hitting, and it's the size of a planet, and engages in zero direction changes. Aircraft are simple.
- bumby 6y agoYes. It’s a much more regulated industry that already has mandatory equipment that helps solve the problem (e.g., transponders), there’s often more time to perceive and mitigate a risk (outside of takeoff and landing), less variable environments etc
- fullshark 6y agoThe upside is much smaller though. There are lot more drivers than pilots, and crashes are so less common.
- sp3000 6y ago2100 is almost 80 years from now. Think back to 1940 and how different our world was then. Cars will certainly be automated to some degree. And that will cause a great reduction in the almost 1.35 million people killed globally by motor vehicle accidents. A US statistic: In 2010, there were an estimated 5,419,000 crashes, 30,296 deadly, killing 32,999, and injuring 2,239,000. It is hard for me to imagine a scenario where automated driving is as unsafe as that. We will truly look back and think, "Did we really trust others to operate multi ton metal machinery at exceedingly high speeds at each other day after day?"
- endisneigh 6y ago> Cars will certainly be automated to some degree. And that will cause a great reduction in the almost 1.35 million people killed globally by motor vehicle accidents. They already are. I'm talking about full self driving. A car without a steering wheel. Cruise control (arguably the first car automation) has existed since the 1900s. Potentially earlier depending on how you define it.
- specialp 6y agoAs a whole this is true and could probably be bested. But it would have to be by many magnitudes of order to have people accept it. There's a feeling that isn't necessarily true that one can control their destiny driving and avoid being a statistic. Now we know that isn't always true as you are at the mercy of many other elements. But if autonomous cars were even 90% less fatalities it would still be hard to get humans to give up control for that. It would have to be on the realm of air travel safety.
- gota 6y agoI think there's a crucial issue with sensoring. Companies are tackling the problem mainly using sensors that are contained within the car. Even with LIDAR (and not just cameras) it is very hard to "sense" the full scene[1]. What if our roads were built to communicate with the cars? What if there were only AVs on the street and they communicated with each other? What if every bicycle, school backpack, shopping cart did so too, identifying itself in the process? I think the problem of self-driving is harder right now in the transitional period in which they have to coexist with human drivers and essentially trying to "emulate" how a human driver gathers information (not really, but you get my meaning) I'm not sure it won't take decades, but I feel like there will be a magical few-months period in which we go from "can it be done?" to "oh, ok,we got it" [1] shoot, I lost the reference. But Cruise apparently assumes "use whatever is available until it works, we'll make it cost-effective later"
- dmitrygr 6y ago> What if every bicycle, school backpack, shopping cart did so too, identifying itself in the process? That sounds like a nazi-state dream - easily track every backpack, car, bicycle, etc... no thank you
- nicoburns 6y agoThat's a really good idea. You probably wouldn't need too many sensors either. Now that I think about it, a few strategically placed cameras around blind conrners woul be pretty useful for human drivers too!
- stefan_ 6y agoThen we can just build trains instead. Perfectly automated today.
- thu2111 6y agoNo, the physics of that don't work at all. Trains for example cannot handle gradients that cars manage with ease.
- 6y ago
- tialaramex 6y ago> Is there an example of anything that's completely automated that's dangerous? I think this is just the usual goal post moving, if a machine does it then we decide it wasn't really dangerous for a machine to do it. Garmin Autoland will take a plane which is otherwise working and is in the sky and put it back on the ground because the pilot has a problem (e.g. your plane nut husband finally has another stroke† while taking you and the kids cross country, you've never learned to fly but you just press the button like you were taught and the plane will tell you to remain calm while it figures out where to land and gets itself back down). It isn't cheap (the system needs to control flight surfaces, engines, radios, brakes, more or less everything on a plane) and of course it can't fix a broken plane, but a random non-pilot is going to do a much worse job and "land an aeroplane" seems like it counts as dangerous to me. > The thing is, if you have "partial" self driving, you might as well just drive yourself IMHO. If you live in the relatively small service zone for Waymo, you just get in the car and it drives you elsewhere in the zone, like a taxi, except the car is driving. Waymo doesn't want you "partially" driving anything, it doesn't want you near the wheel or pedals, it would prefer if you watch a video or read a book. † In some countries private pilots have to be fit, but the US has gradually decided that eh, it's your plane, your risk, the main obstacle today for medically unfit private pilots is getting insurance.
- endisneigh 6y ago> I think this is just the usual goal post moving, if a machine does it then we decide it wasn't really dangerous for a machine to do it. I strongly disagree. Most machines are not capable of killing you because it makes a mistake. Do you have an example of something humans did that could kill them that was automated completely that still can kill them, but generally does not anymore? An elevator is one example, but in the case of an elevator its a very bounded problem to solve, and even still hundreds die for unnecessary elevator deaths yearly. Not to mention an elevator is not an entropic environment. A full self driving car would have to be able to deal with ice suddenly falling on the ground, people crashing around them, etc.
- nsp 6y agoFully automated train systems? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_automated_train_systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_automated_train_system... Not nearly as complex a problem as self driving cars, but I'd still rather not get hit by a train
- dqpb 6y agoWaymo is full self driving, not partial
- jefft255 6y ago*Waymo is trying to develop full self driving, not partial
- solutron 6y agoWaymo is little more than a Jurassic Park jeep ride. Only works on the tracks. Take a Waymo vehicle anywhere their engineering staff hasn't spent countless hours driving around back and forth with those ridiculous spinning lidar sensors and roof rack full of who-knows-what and see what's left of their 'self driving'.
- ra7 6y agoSo a 50 square mile city with live traffic, pedestrians and objects is a "little more than a Jurassic Park jeep ride"? What are you going to say when they go to SF next? Just another Jurassic Park ride?
- jefft255 6y agoI’m very skeptical about achieving FSD in the next few years, but I don’t think your giving them enough credit. Even if you’re limiting yourself to a known city, you still have to deal with human drivers and pedestrians doing weird shit all the time. That’s no small feat, even though it’s far from the ultimate goal of being able to pass out drunk in the back of the car while it gets you home safely.
- slibhb 6y agoA interesting analogy is the Washington DC Metro, which was automated but now isn't due to a significant accident in 2009 which killed 9 people. That's a train on rails. We have much less tolerance for computers killing people compared to people killing people.
- wjamesg 6y agoThe DC metro was once automated? Interesting
- jedberg 6y agoBART in SF was too.
- stefan_ 6y agoYou would think that but then that Uber car ran over a pedestrian in the middle of a typical ultra wide deserted American throughfare with perfect lighting and.. kinda nothing happened? My pulse still rises when I think of that dashcam video they released that predictably shows nothing to blame that lady their negligence killed. Maybe the common denominator is just cars. The regulators are fully absent - they care about the shape of your headlights, but do they care that SUVs have them mounted at the height of mirrors for every other car? Do they care that cars have absurdly overpowered engines that have no imaginable use? Do they care that trucks have fronts so high it's impossible to see a kid walking on a crosswalk and when you hit it, it's hit head-height and thrown under the wheels? None of these things would ever fly on a train or airplane.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- senkora 6y agoThat incident basically ended Uber ATG. I wouldn’t say that nothing happened.
- adewinter 6y ago> Is there an example of anything that's completely automated that's dangerous? Monorail trains (like at the airport) Combine Harvesters Airplane Autopilot/autoland Elevators
- adewinter 6y agoLiterally any operational (and unattended) machine in a modern factory
- Tomte 6y agoFactory automation usually has fail-stop behaviour (in process automation like chemical plants, things get more interesting). And resumption of operation after an emergency stop happens only after a human check and intentional operator acknowledge. So you're technically right, but the circumstances are vastly different. Nobody will buy a car that does a full emergency brake whenever a leaf falls off a tree. The environment is so much more difficult on the street than in a factory.
- croes 6y agoHow many of these completely automated things have lots of humans interacting and are outside an closed area?
- Shivetya 6y agofull self driving would far easier if they weren't all trying to cover all cases at once. I, along with others, have mentioned that a far simpler problem to solve is freeway travel. HOV and Express lanes make this easy. They have well established markings, limited access, and traffic goes in one direction. So industry and regulators would work together to solve standardization of markings for travel and entry and exiting. Then you take it to the rest of the interstate system and then to limited access highways. Eventually you get down to the neighborhoods and city driving. I see real promise in Tesla's beta system which has a few thousand drivers. What it tracks is far more advanced than what my current software does in my 3. They finally went to a persistent model and far better labeling. Now where my car shows cones around a parked vehicle they show the vehicle as well. They show all parked and stationary objects. Something the current software does not always do if at all. Just within the US the lane markings, signage, and even signaling, is not consistent from state to state. Worse the rules for what is an acceptable lane is not consistent either. So the first step there is to standardize it all across the nation.
- solutron 6y agoTesla is 100% going to win in this space. And as Musk and Karpathy have said, the general solution will be in place and work nearly everywhere, but a long tail of edge scenarios will have to be ironed out over time. This is nascent, world changing technology solving hard problems. As a M3 owner you get to see the feature set growing over time, but the zero-to-one moment is when that FSD is finally rolled out in 9.x I can't wait. It's going to be amazing.
- qzw 6y agoThe advancements in AI tend to happen in intermittent large leaps, but people tend to make linear projections based on the most recent leap. That’s why there’s always a big hype cycle followed by disillusionment and some sort of AI winter. I personally think 2100 is extremely pessimistic, but all those projections of full self-driving by 2025 were certainly even more extreme in their optimism.
- mrshadowgoose 6y agoYou can, today, go to Pheonix Arizona, download the Waymo One app, and summon a full self driving vehicle. This happened silently at the end of 2020, and was overshadowed by the ongoing pandemic doom and gloom. https://blog.waymo.com/2020/10/waymo-is-opening-its-fully-driverless.html https://blog.waymo.com/2020/10/waymo-is-opening-its-fully-dr... On the subject of danger. Literally everything we do is dangerous to some degree. Everything. Self-driving does not need to be perfect, but only better than human drivers. We're likely already at that point with Waymo vehicles. On the subject of automation. Humanity is on track to have the computational power to perform whole brain emulation decades before 2100. Even if we don't solve the general AI problem through other pathways, we will solve it through this path. Ethical problems aside, once this is achieved, everything will be automatable at a human level of competence.
- endisneigh 6y ago> On the subject of automation. Humanity is on track to have the computational power to perform whole brain emulation decades before 2100. Even if we don't solve the general AI problem through other pathways, we will solve it through this path. Ethical problems aside, once this is achieved, everything will be automatable at a human level of competence. Is this actually true? I haven't heard of this. You're saying we will have an AI as good as a grown educated adult before 2100? I can't believe this at all - do you have a citation?
- mrshadowgoose 6y agoYes, and the methodology I've described (whole brain emulation/WBE) is the worst-case, brute-force, but guaranteed approach. The following diagram captures the expected growth rate of computing power, and contrasts it with several thresholds (in blue) for emulation fidelity ultimately required: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind_uploading#/media/File:Whole_brain_emulation.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind_uploading#/media/File:Who... The human brain works, therefore this technique will work, it's just a matter of having enough computing power. I will re-iterate though, we are pursuing various alternative pathways to artificial intelligence, and modern machine learning has already demonstrated super-human performance within constrained domains. It's my personal belief that we will achieve human-level general intelligence long before WBE becomes practical.
- jedberg 6y ago> Is there an example of anything that's completely automated that's dangerous? Flying an airplane. They put pilots in there to make people comfortable, but if need be, a modern passenger plane can fly itself, including take off and landing. Driving a subway. BART in San Francisco launched as self driving in the 60s. It freaked people out so much that they put a human in front. But if you sit up there you'll see the human doesn't do much. They press a button to close the doors, but that could easily be automated. Also, I took a ride in a self driving car in SF a few years ago. It had a safety driver, but he didn't do anything (he grabbed the wheel once, but then they looked at the data and found the car was about to do the right thing anyway). It handled things like cars going the wrong way, double parked trucks, trash bags in the street, jaywalkers, etc.
- Laremere 6y agoIt really depends on what you mean by "full self driving". Eg, I wouldn't consider the stuff Tesla is doing as self driving at all. I have significant worry because to reduces attention while still requiring it for safety. If you're talking "Hail robocab, don't touch a steering wheel, arrive at your destination", then Waymo is already there: https://blog.waymo.com/2020/10/waymo-is-opening-its-fully-driverless.html https://blog.waymo.com/2020/10/waymo-is-opening-its-fully-dr... You might mean "does everything everyone uses a vehicle for today", however I feel that's perhaps moving the goalposts to unattainable. Eg, replacing nascar racers with self driving cars would defeat the point of nascar, so that's won't happen. (though it might be an interesting side event.) Between the two extremes of public pilot in limited area and handling every situation, there's a very large space for tremendous value. Just serving urban areas would significantly reduce the need for vehicles. There are many people who only use public transit, or could if they had more economical ways to handle sporadic trips such as grocery shopping and visiting friends across town.
- solutron 6y agoWaymo has to learn the exact space it's going to drive in ahead of time, and then have high resolution lidar maps generated to assist. It's currently limited to use in grid-like pre-mapped areas like Phoenix AZ. Tesla is building a general learning solution such that you can take the vehicle anywhere, and not have the requirement that the area be pre-mapped or 'learned' by Tesla beforehand. Tesla has orders of magnitude more data and mileage driven than Waymo could possibly ever imagine having. Waymo is not going to scale. CEO departures like this are a big red flag. Pin this comment. Google will shutter Waymo in less than five years.
- bobsil1 6y agoYep, Waymo approach is brittle
- Geee 6y agoYeah. Andrej Karpathy said in a recent interview that at this point it's almost completely a data problem, instead of a machine learning research problem. Most of their work is in figuring out the best way to collect and annotate lots of good data. Waymo has a few hundred cars and Tesla has millions, and in this problem space, scale wins over more precise sensors. Here's the interview: https://open.spotify.com/episode/0IuwH7eTZ3TQBfU8XsMaRr?si=6ca5e5d8fd1b4e20 https://open.spotify.com/episode/0IuwH7eTZ3TQBfU8XsMaRr?si=6...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- komocode 6y agoThe metric to beat isn't "is self driving dangerous, yes or no?" The metric to beat is "is self driving on average substantially safer than human driving?". Once you beat that metric, it would be insane not to allow self driving. This won't take 100 years.