6 ms·
But this article is about the US, where there have been no lockdowns. Only (mostly) unenforced stay-at-home orders, (mostly) unenforced business closures, and (
by ryandrake 6y ago
But this article is about the US, where there have been no lockdowns. Only (mostly) unenforced stay-at-home orders, (mostly) unenforced business closures, and (mostly) unenforced mask mandates. I don't see the link. Lots of people have been out horsing around, doing whatever they wanted this past year, and sidestepping the token, unenforced roadblocks that were half-assed by governments. Something must be causing all these terrible things, but it's not lockdowns.
I would start looking at lack of government action rather than the little they actually did.
- an_opabinia 6y ago> I would start looking at lack of government action rather than the little they actually did. The simple reality of it is that there was a colossal finance related economic crash, similar to 2008, that was blamed on the lockdown when the lockdown wasn't really to blame. We're still in the "dead cat bounce" phase of that crash.
- tastyfreeze 6y agoHit the nail on the head. The pain of the 2008 crash was just kicked down the road by bailing out banks. We will have to reckon with the consequences of government economic meddling at some point. Shutting down the economy was just a shove towards the cliff. I think that we are going to really see the crash kick off whenever the eviction moratorium is lifted. There is no way that all landlords are able to service their loans. Anybody that has been patient with savings will be cleaning house snatching up cheap properties and businesses.
- ericmcer 6y agoYeah sure lol, the federal reserve is willing to float asset prices indefinitely. Neither party wants to be incumbent the one that deals with the fallout of raising interest rates. Anyone who has been patient with savings will get wrecked by inflation.
- tastyfreeze 6y agoOnly if you're savings is in USD. If you have the foresight to see the impending crisis you would also have the foresight to exit USD well before it happens. Savings isn't just cash. The way I see it playing out is the government is going to try to print prosperity. Foreign governments stop buying our debt and move on to a new reserve currency without the US. If the US is willing to use force to try to maintain USD reserve status things get really ugly. Domestically this is a world of hurt for middle and low income classes. Any country that is preparing for this eventuality is going to do better. But, all countries are playing the same monetary debasement game. Just a few countries are increasing their purchase of gold and decreasing their purchase of US debt.
- hanniabu 6y agoAnother great reason for bitcoin/ethereum
- an_opabinia 6y agoThe eviction moratorium is overblown. Forbearance on mortgages is an extremely cheap way to keep landlords from feeling the pain, and lenders have little upside and much downside from mass selling among landlords when financing is so cheap nowadays. Anyway NY state is $61b estimated lost rent which is comparable to student loan debt (like $40b), neither of these things matter as much as people think they do. Why? These people are already in default. The renters who need the moratorium were already “in default,” you just didn’t account for it yet. To the degree that the market has known NYC and LA renters’ rent was “too damn high” for decades now, it’s hard to see how people predictably on the verge of default (ie economic default) now having to live somewhere they can afford (ie accounting default) will cause a crash. If anything REITs prices will rise as information (ie who is really capable of paying rents) flows into the system. The renters who can actually afford to live in NYC and LA are richer, and the people who move out will be richer than many people where they’re moving to. Another way to look at this is that CDOs were responsible for the 2008 crash. Not people taking mortgages they can’t afford. Constantly economic crashes are the result of derivatives. My feeling is that we will find out what toxic derivative will crash the economy for real when someone takes a long look at PIPEs for SPAC transactions. Another place I would look for nasty derivatives is untaxed cash of large corporations in offshore accounts, especially of the major tech companies.
- gruez 6y ago>Why? These people are already in default. The renters who need the moratorium were already “in default,” you just didn’t account for it yet. source?
- quickthrowman 6y ago> We will have to reckon with the consequences of government economic meddling at some point. Not necessarily, the Fed isn’t obligated to unwind its QE purchases. They may not even be willing to, see ‘taper tantrum’ and Oct-Dec 2018. We won’t see another bear market without another black swan. House prices may come down when the moratorium is lifted, back to 2020 prices. There won’t be as much selling by landlords as you think, lots of them likely qualified for forbearance which makes non-payment of rent a virtual non-issue. It’ll take a 2.5-3% 10y yield to really push mortgage rates up enough to where it starts to affect house prices, or the Fed needs to stop buying MBSes, or both.
- tastyfreeze 6y agoThe Fed doesn't need to unwind its purchase to kill the dollar. All that needs to happen is the people lose trust in the dollar. There is nothing special about the dollar. It is worth just as much as any other national currency. Some people have already realized this. When the masses catch on it is already too late. What percentage of landlords do you think are qualified for forbearance? It certainly isn't all of them. What percentage of landlords need to default before there is a crisis? I wouldn't be looking at the Fed to change their practices. They believe they are in the right and can fix the economy with what they are doing.
- Pyramus 6y agoAbsolutely. Now add the absence of a welfare system that is meant to alleviate the distress.
- swebs 6y agoThe USA is actually in the top 10 welfare states in terms of spending per capita, behind only some northern European countries. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_social_welfare_spending#Per_capita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_social_we...
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoSpending pocketed by wealthy middlemen.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoAre you saying it's a bloat and graft problem and not a funding problem? Because if so, I agree.
- refurb 6y agoYou mean politicians?
- ezequiel-garzon 6y agoI don’t live there, but isn’t there a large portion of the student population that is returning to schools after a year? I doubt most parents in that case were setting up play dates, so in effect this has been almost a lockdown for those children.
- lazyasciiart 6y agoThat seems to be the exact problem - why weren't parents setting up play dates?? It's shocking to me how many families seem to think that their kid has no opportunity to talk to another child until schools open again.
- swiley 6y ago>unenforced business closures, No, these were enforced by the police and courts in most places (certainly where I live.) Lots of people didn't/don't have work.
- msrenee 6y agoIt was not enforced at all where I live. We had a mask mandate in our county for less than a week this summer. Businesses chose what measures to take and they were all over the place. Thankfully it's a pretty well-to-do county. Only 2 counties in my state had any kind of regulation and there were no mandated business closures to my knowledge in either.
- loveistheanswer 6y ago>But this article is about the US, where there have been no lockdowns. Only (mostly) unenforced stay-at-home orders, (mostly) unenforced business closures, and (mostly) unenforced mask mandates. I don't see the link. Your privileged, pedantic ignorance of the major socioeconomic problems caused by the covid 19 response perfectly illustrates OP's point.
- Pyramus 6y agoNo it doesn't. We have been doing the whole spiel for over a year now, running different experiments in different countries. Lockdowns are not silver bullets - what drives viral spread is behaviour, not legal measures. In fact, if everybody would stay at home for 14 days, the virus dies (decays exponentially). What actually happened is that folks made the wearing of a piece of cloth, meant to protect others, a political statement and a 'restriction of personal freedom'.
- Mountain_Skies 6y agoYou're disingenuously ignoring that those pushing for mask wearing destroyed their credibility by earlier claiming masks didn't work. It doesn't matter what the goals of their lies were, they were lies and the costs of loss of credibility is at the heart of all of this. Spin it all you want and try to win political points on your ideological enemies all you want, nothing can change the fact that lies were knowingly told and that's the seed that started the skepticism about masks. No amount of gaslighting and screaming that it didn't happen or that it was for everyone's own good will undo that damage. Denying this only harms the credibility of the cause even more.
- loveistheanswer 6y agoWhat does that have to do with the major socioecomic hardships that were created and exacerbated for millions of poor people around the world which are largely ignored by politicians and many other people as evidenced in this thread? Members of the WHO covid team have estimated that lockdowns may well end up doubling world poverty. Until you acknowledge these negative side effects, rather than narrow mindedly defaulting to american partisan politics, your response again further helps illustrate OPs point.
- nradov 6y agoSanta Clara County in the middle of Silicon Valley aggressively enforced lockdown rules and fined hundreds of businesses. This wrecked many segments of the local economy, and drove people into poverty and hunger. https://www.mercurynews.com/2021/03/28/why-san-mateo-county-businesses-are-far-less-likely-to-get-a-covid-fine-than-those-in-santa-clara https://www.mercurynews.com/2021/03/28/why-san-mateo-county-... Those of us fortunate enough to still be employed can help by donating to local food banks like Martha's Kitchen. https://www.marthas-kitchen.org/donate.html https://www.marthas-kitchen.org/donate.html
- ryandrake 6y agoWhat wrecked the economies was the length of the pandemic. If we actually locked down for a month or so we might have had a shot at beating it with less long-term misery, but since covid was so politicized and government was too timid to actually do that, we half-assed it instead, and here we are a year later. Go outside Silicon Valley and a few other metro areas, and you'll still see widespread lack of enforcement. Most of the good behavior has been voluntary. Good people/businesses listening to health guidance. Nobody is getting pulled over in rural America and fined for violating stay-at-home. If I wanted to, I could "unessentially" drive across the state of CA right now, sit down at a fully-open bar or restaurant unmasked, and nobody would lift a finger to stop me.
- Mountain_Skies 6y agoWhat exactly do you mean by "actually locked down"? That 100% of the population would be prohibited from leaving their homes? What about food? What about medical emergencies? What about a house burning down or a tree falling on the roof? What if a watermain bursts? There are endless edge cases that keep the virus around so when the lockdown ends, all you've done is delayed host exposure a bit. And this ignores the possibility of animals serving as reservoirs of the virus. It also ignores multi-family housing. What if most of the people on the 3rd floor have COVID the first week and then it spreads to the 4th floor the next week, the 5th floor the next, and so on? Now you have people exiting the lockdown who have just been infected and can spread it all over the place. The only thing a lockdown can do is slow things down in order to have time to get more prepared. The notion that the virus can be extinguished by lockdowns simply is not workable. It's an idea that is attractive because it's simple but only because it ignores the logistic realities of a planet with nearly eight billion people, or on the national level, 330 million people.
- CWuestefeld 6y agoYour emphasis on "unenforced" ignores the fact that there's a huge amount of people trying to do what they're told is the right thing, even without a gun to their head.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 6y agoUnenforced orders are kind of a worst of all worlds where you get most of the economic harm of a lockdown (because the force of guidance and the potential of enforcement gets enough compliance to slow economic activity significantly), but very little of the public health benefit (because a critical mass of noncompliance keeps disease spreading.