13 ms·
New study detects lottery-like behavior in cryptocurrency markets
- tryonenow 6y ago>Interestingly, the sharp increase in the prices for cryptocurrencies happens in a period where the uncertainty in the market for traditional currencies has risen due to the enormous amounts of money that governments worldwide In my experience, until 1-2 years ago, btc movements were anticorrelated with the market. This seems to have reversed around the time that financial institutions entered into the BTC market.
- pinkybanana 6y agoSounds like someone missed the train, again.
- throwawayfire 6y agoYou understand that you're characterising crypto as a pyramid scheme, I guess?
- viklove 6y agoWe missed the train on MSFT, AAPL, TSLA, etc. as well. Are those pyramid schemes in your eyes, too?
- yunohn 6y agoNo, they’re called companies.
- viklove 6y agoBravo, 10/10 response. Since you seem to be ignorant of this, Bernard L. Madoff Investment Securities LLC and Enron were also "companies," so your response isn't as witty as you think.
- yunohn 6y agoI really think “MSFT, AAPL, TSLA” aren’t comparable to your examples.
- viklove 6y agoYes, and I don't think cryptocurrencies are either. I thought it was clear that this was the object of our disagreement. Going back to the reason for this thread, saying we "missed the boat" on anything does not mean it is a pyramid scheme -- I think I've demonstrated that and I'm not sure what the point of your comments is any more.
- willis936 6y ago>the researchers examined the role of speculative behavior in cryptocurrency markets, that is, lottery-like demand Is this an industry-standard term? It seems like an awful definition and awful use of the word “lottery”.
- svachalek 6y agoMy thought exactly. There's a crazy amount of speculation in real estate, stocks, and commodities, but I've never heard it called "lottery-like".
- qeternity 6y agoThat’s because all of those things are predominantly traded due to their underlying utility. Like lotteries, which have no utility other than taxes and speculation, crypto currencies are almost entirely valuable as tools for speculation.
- rodiger 6y agoWhat? Plenty of crypto projects have real utility. Also for a counterpoint: commodities such as gold and other precious metals are predominantly traded as speculative vehicles.
- andrewmutz 6y agoWhich crypto projects are providing real utility to people outside the crypto space? I can think of using bitcoin for remittances or drug purchases, but other than that I have trouble thinking of compelling examples.
- methodin 6y agoHaving only cursory knowledge of this space I'll take a stab at an answer: every consumer of a company that uses crypto internally. AWS doesn't provide any real utility for people outside of the AWS space except for consumers of companies that use AWS. Feel free to point out I'm wrong as again I don't follow this space in-depth.
- undefined1 6y agohow does it compare to the gambling of stocks on Robinhood?
- bhouston 6y agoIt is probably very similar when it is stocks that are nearing bankruptcy or otherwise have horrid fundamentals. If the stocks do have fundamentals and the PE ratio makes sense relative to the growth factor, then it isn't pure gambling.
- iso1631 6y agoThe S&P hit 4,000 today, with a P/E ratio of about 40:1. On Jan 1st 2020 it had a P/E radio of 25:1 Does that make sense?
- pedrosorio 6y agoGiven the past few months have seen conditions that led to abnormally low "E" that are not expected to be repeated, and at the same time the amount of cash available to inflate "P" increased dramatically... maybe? Disclaimer: I know nothing
- jandrese 6y agoI think there is an argument to be made that as stock growth has outpaced GDP growth for many years now that the connection between the markets and the real world has become tenuous. The fundamentals become less important over time as crazy speculation continues to win out. GME is a symptom of a broken system.
- frockington1 6y agoWhat is broken about it? People were over leveraged and others acted on it. Seems to be working as intended. If GME is at this P/E a year from I'll agree with you
- 6y ago
- henvic 6y agoIt's trivial. Just say any is pure speculation of thin air and you'll be right. There's no sense in the currently existing crypto currencies. They're all fiat money. Peter Schiff was right back then... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sgRGBNekFIw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sgRGBNekFIw and he's still right now. https://twitter.com/peterschiff/status/1345427870546538509 https://twitter.com/peterschiff/status/1345427870546538509
- bhouston 6y agoYou're getting crazy down voted, instead people should reply.
- celticninja 6y agoWhat is there to reply about? Schiff has been calling bitcoin a scam for years. The linked tweet says that no one will be making a profit, which ignores a lot of people who have already made a lot of money. So it's disingenuous, also he has been wrong for a decade.
- africanboy 6y agobitcoins are valued at $ 600 billions, with 6 million active users it's an average of $ 100,000 per user, which is not much in 10 years time. probably less than 1% made a lot of money, the rest lost some.
- celticninja 6y agoAlso your numbers are nonsense. A bitcoin is currently worth $60,000. 10 years ago they were worth perhaps 0.1 cents each. I am pretty sure you could not find anyone who would agree that the gains made by bitcoin over the last decade could have been beaten by any other investment.
- africanboy 6y agobitcoins are worthless their nominal (aka imaginary) value is right now $60,000 dollars each, in real money if btc could not be traded in fiat currencies, which is the real goal of every btc investor, their value would drop again to zero because that's their real (aka physical) value
- varispeed 6y agoIs this sort of a precursor for classifying cryptocurrency as a lottery and therefore making it a subject of strict regulation?
- heymartinadams 6y agoNo shit.
- whoisjuan 6y agoOf course. Anyone who claims to understand cryptocurrencies pretty well is lying. I consider myself an intelligent person. Maybe I'm not, but I try to take informed decisions and stay up to date with the latest technology developments. Even with this, I have a very mediocre understanding of cryptocurrencies. I do understand well how a blockchain works, but I would be lying if I said that I understand well the economic dynamics of the cryptocurrency market. For starters, there are a gazillion of tradeable cryptocurrencies with different premises and value propositions. They all have extremely different dynamics with the only common denominator being the concept of a blockchain. I do invest on cryptocurrencies and I try to use some signals, mainly trying to understand the viability of the coins I pick in the long term and their potential impact on the financial system. It's not a very scientific analysis, but I can tell you it's deeper than the analysis than most people who invest in crypto do. Most people just put money on Crypto markets because its exuberant growth. They are not thinking on whether this is a viable investment or not. They just want to participate and most times this is with an all-in win or lose mentality. And I'm not only talking about retail investment. Many institutional investors are operating on the same idea. Crypto is extremely speculative. The more speculative an investment is, the less predictable. So, I totally buy the idea of a lottery-like behavior. This is going to be the case until crypto coins start morphing into actual transactable currencies that can be used for commerce, remittances, wages, etc.
- ayngg 6y agoMy take on it is basically nobody knows what it is about. Like you said, even people with deep understandings of the technology probably aren't capable of fully understanding its implications, anyone that tries to tell you definitively is speculating. It is like "satoshi" made a sandbox and everyone else has been spending the past decade either trying to figure it out, or dismissing it as a scam. It's a gold rush in the wild west, it starts off very inefficient, actual scams abound and crazy speculation is everywhere, like a gold rush at the end of the day there is probably something with value under all the craziness, that is what happens when things are new and people don't understand it, they are the ones that are establishing the parameters of its function, what it can and cant do. It seems like all mainstream blockchain related discussion is basically people circle jerking about how it is 100000% a scam or how it is the new paradigm with no space in between, which is pretty disappointing.
- christiansakai 6y agoThank you Captain Obvious!
- endisneigh 6y agoIt makes sense. In my experience the primary goal for most crypto holders is to be a part of a new elite. This is why the most popular currencies have a fixed supply. That way, if they're popular earlier adopters get to be a part of the elite. With such a premise it makes sense to treat crypto like the lottery as the gain/loss likelihood is very similar to say, Mega Millions. I do see value in a crypto that's pinned at a weighted average of every single currencies' worldwide weight. That way you get the advantage of crypto, but it's a perfectly stable currency. Needless to say, very few people at least on HN have bragged about owning an inflationary crypto currency. Why? Because they're not getting rich nor is there an opportunity for them to be a part of the techno-elite. My biggest concern is a fixed-supply currency gives no government the ability to provide stimulus if necessary. Many advocates argue that governments shouldn't provide stimulus but history shows that's generally a terrible idea (the gold standard, for example, contributed in some ways to The Great Depression). EDIT: I don't feel like responding individually, but I will say that I've read both the Bitcoin and Ethereum whitepaper and there's nothing about grievances of traditional governments usage of printing of their currencies. I feel that the "that's a feature" is more a post-hoc rationalization that allows one to say they're in the right while simultaneously benefiting early adopters. Regardless, every government in world history that's pinned their currency to something that's relatively fixed has had a severe depression with some part of that depression being contributed to said pinning. It's just not good economics. Feel free to respond with a contrary example if you'd like.
- uncletammy 6y ago> My biggest concern is a fixed-supply currency gives no government the ability to provide stimulus if necessary. That's a feature. Not a bug.
- therein 6y ago> My biggest concern is a fixed-supply currency gives no government the ability to provide stimulus if necessary. Good, that's the intention.
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago
- mrkramer 6y agoThere are more irrational agents than rational agents in cryptocurrency markets so no surprise there is lottery like behavior. Irrational agents bet on luck earning them profit or something like gut feeling and rational agents bet on analysis they've done and information they've gathered thought out research. And whole cryptomarket is largely unregulated so there are many cases of market manipulation. You could see what happens when large group of irrational agents enters the market in the case of GameStop.
- young_unixer 6y agoTo the anti-BTC crowd: Yes, the current price of crypto is based on speculation, not in their current utility. But there also was a dotcom bubble 20 years ago. Does that mean that the World Wide Web is useless? Cryptocurrencies will be highly useful as stores of value and maybe as currency. We're just not there yet. This is just the Gartner hype cycle, with the addition that for the first time we have a global market completely parallel to the traditional one with much less regulation. No wonder people are going to speculate with it. It's our new toy.
- Daishiman 6y agoThere is absolutely no evidence backing this. The utility of the WWW was eminently visible to experts even before it existed. I have yet to meet an expert in equivalent fields who complains that the core issues in finance can be solved by cryptocurrencies. In fact I don't really see any issues that can be solved by crypto. Trust issues? Crypto users are as likely if not more to be scammed and the technology itself doesn't build trust any more than a webpage does; it's the backing of a legal system that does. International transfers? Google for a few minutes and you can find plenty of places where you can get mostly decent rates. The only places I can think of where this is an issue are Argentina and Venezuela, but that's not a niche that corresponds with the current or future crypto market valuations. Descentralized trust? If there's one thing I trust less than human institutions, it's "bug-free" code.
- kache_ 6y agoPurchasing controlled substances and illegal weapons is a problem it solves.
- didi987 6y agoMr. Ulbricht has been in prison for 8 years now, a lot has changed since the Silk Road
- lostmsu 6y agoIn 2000 have you seen experts in landline companies, who would see WWW as the core solution to their problems?
- kurthr 6y agoOne thing I find interesting in the analysis is the claim that crypto-currencies do not have effective short selling opportunities requiring a "long only" strategy. That is interesting as it seems like one of the few contracts that Etherium should provide, if one trusted any particular "stablecoin". Furthermore, it does seem that Binance (and probably others) do allow some shorting opportunities.
- max_ 6y agoResearchers have finally discovered that swimming makes people wet.
- kabdib 6y agoFor me, the thing that will always define cryptocurrencies was what occurred a few years ago at a datacenter I frequent. Someone had built-out a cage with 50 to 60 really nice high-end racks of shiny, new bitcoin mining hardware. Snazzy logos, brushed steel chassis and lots of blue LEDs (I think the LEDs are required, in order to be cool). The structured cabling was a work of art. They really went the extra mile to look good. These machines crunched away for maybe a month, and the next time I visited the datacenter, every machine in the cage was turned off and dark. No more blue LEDs. They stayed that way for months, until the datacenter needed the floor space and carted the junk away. I believe the hardware was recycled, I don't know who got the racks. I dug into the story a little and found that the company hadn't paid their power bill. I believe that the hardware wasn't paid for, either, but it was not as efficient as newer hardware and not useful to anyone, so they just left it. Scammers and waste, all the way down.
- dathinab 6y agoIt's a bit different then lottery. Each crypto currency (well most) act like a collectors marked, i.e like art, antiques, trading cards and so on. The only lottery aspect is weather or not niche currencies become well established, kinda like weather or new sources of classical collectibles become well established. Some now would argue that collectibles in difference to crypto currencies have a real world value which backs them but that's a misconception such real world value is most times completely negligible if the collectors marked fails. In some cases it will even cost you money to get right of the now basically worthless collectibles. Also similar to there being cryptocurrency which are a scam there are collectibles which are such. Like supposedly priceless pictures being sold for over a thousand dollar being only worth like 5 dollar or so, i.e. you basically lose the full investment
- watertom 6y agoUltimately cryptocurrency is a game, just like the stock market and people will play it like a game, just like the stock market.