5 ms·
I think what changed was that when Perl was popular people were generally a bit more into lots of wacky way to do the same thing, deliberately whimsical termino
by chrisseaton 6y ago
I think what changed was that when Perl was popular people were generally a bit more into lots of wacky way to do the same thing, deliberately whimsical terminology, puns in their programs, the program equivalent of creative writing, and being a bit different for the sake of it. I think I had a Perl book at the time that tried to make a serious case for Perl programs being poetry.
I think the culture has just changed since then and most people aren't into that any more. People now seem to value one clearer way to do everything, and more straightforward terminology. Look at the popularity of much more no-nonsense languages these days.
I think unfortunately Perl just now looks deeply unfashionable, and I think even the context of why it is the way it is and how people saw things back then has sort of been lost so it's somewhat hard to explain to younger people in the community.
- emodendroket 6y agoNot really a mystery why though, is it? Cute and novel ways to do things are less charming when you’re trying to figure out what earth they do well after the fact to solve some problem.
- jiofih 6y agoI’ve heard this a few times but never really saw any of that creative culture working close to a few Perl folks, besides a few funny package names. More a culture of roughness, “hacker cred” and a defensive, short-sighted, we-know-better attitude that left people stranded and is totally not welcoming to creative types. I learned very little during this time. What you describe is what the Ruby community was in the early 2000s.
- chrisseaton 6y agoMy favourite example is the 'bless' function. It attaches a class to an object, if people didn't know. I can't imagine such a name getting approved in any other language. I think any other community would say 'hang on shall we give it a descriptive name that anyone can understand without context, rather than doing this whole faux-religion schtick that will need to be explained to everyone?'
- kqr 6y agoProgramming is filled with weird terminology that only means something because we've gotten used to it. String? Method? Abstract method? Stack? Sure, there's a weak link between pre-existing meanings and the programming one, but so is there with bless.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> String? Method? Abstract method? Stack? These aren't per-language terms that people have to learn just to use Perl, though are they? 'bless' is. A new term for something that could have been described so simply as 'set-class' or 'give-class' or anything else using plain language.
- kqr 6y agoWell, they do mean slightly different things in different languages. But I suspect "set-class" or "give-class" would be a bit cumbersome to trip over every time it happens. A relatively core concept should have a relatively short name (in the Perl philosophy of working like a natural language) so we'd still probably have to find something around 5 characters or fewer.
- jiofih 6y agoSee, that’s not even that funny. Especially followed by the lesson on how it makes total sense to attach a class to an object after its creation and how every other language is doing it wrong. And then the 47 ways blessed objects can trip you up, but they are all obvious because you should know the inner workings of the compiler and runtime or you’re not a real developer!
- WesolyKubeczek 6y ago> I can't imagine such a name getting approved in any other language. Now look at what bless(8) does on macOS. Not a programming language, but the disconnect between what it says on the tin and what it actually does is quite apparent.
- pansa2 6y ago> deliberately whimsical terminology, puns in their programs Python was like this as well, the language is even named after a comedy group. Perhaps as the culture has changed, Python has done a better job of adapting (e.g. changing the name of the "Cheese Shop" to PyPI)?
- marcosdumay 6y agoAs a late coming to Python, was PyPi actually named Cheese Shop?! That's great. But well, I guess once libraries start to actually appear there, the name change was unavoidable.
- dmingod666 6y agoOh, the 'woo' thing was really big in the Ruby on Rails community as well.. it was very culty back in the 2000s.