5 ms·
I’m not opposed to a well-functioning healthcare for all, but I can guess at a few possible oppositions: (all of these are phrased as generic first-person state
by sokoloff 6y ago
I’m not opposed to a well-functioning healthcare for all, but I can guess at a few possible oppositions: (all of these are phrased as generic first-person statements but by people who are not me)
1. I don’t want my healthcare to be provided by the same people who brought me a lifetime of experiences at the Department of Motor Vehicles.
2. Healthcare is expensive. I’m already paying for healthcare for my family and we’re struggling to get ahead; why would I want to pay for healthcare for others as well?
3. Good healthcare is expensive and I can afford and buy the best health insurance. I don’t want the best to be unavailable to me and my family because we’re all on a “just OK” government system.
4. I’m a medical professional and think that I will make less money under a government-provided system of care.
5. I’m a prescription drug manufacturer. See #4.
6. I’m a biotech research company. See #4.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- amelius 6y agoBut have a look at other countries, e.g. Scandinavia, UK. Public healthcare doesn't need to be bad. And it doesn't exclude the possibility of private healthcare.
- Jarwain 6y agoIt's not that it doesn't need to be bad, but a lot of people don't trust the federal (or their state) gov to do it well
- mirkules 6y agoI am an immigrant from a socialist, ex-communist country in the Balkans, where socialized medicine is the norm, as is having really good doctors. The few times I’ve had to go to the doctor there, either to be seen myself or to help my grandmother, was an awful experience. I’ve had to spend 2 weeks going from office to office until I could finally get an appointment (just an appointment!) for my almost-blind grandmother, for a simple cataract procedure. The procedure was scheduled ONE YEAR from the time of appointment, which meant she was blind in one eye for a whole year. That’s the absurdity of a socialized system. Everyone already knows the absurdities of this system here so I’ll skip that part of my rant. This issue is so polarizing, it occurred to me - why don’t we have a medicare-type system (call it m4a) for those who want it, and not for those who don’t? It’s about a 50-50 split anyway. The catch is, if you don’t pay tax for m4a, you can’t use it. This way, those who are concerned about “paying for others and receiving inferior service” don’t have to, and those who can’t or don’t want to deal with a privatized system are free to use it.
- rootusrootus 6y ago> This issue is so polarizing, it occurred to me - why don’t we have a medicare-type system (call it m4a) for those who want it, and not for those who don’t? It’s about a 50-50 split anyway. I've been thinking about this a lot myself lately too. It seems like there is critical mass for the people who want universal healthcare, so why can't we make it happen? It doesn't seem that unreasonable to set up a dual system where people who want their taxes to pay for healthcare can get it, and the rest can make their way with the private insurance companies. Win/win. The difficulty would probably be in keeping the tax pools separate. And deciding at what point someone paying into the single payer system gained permanent eligibility even when unemployed. Things like that.
- ajsnigrutin 6y agoProbably because people earning less than average will want to be in the shared pool, and people earning more than the average will want individual insurance schemes.
- shagie 6y agoA dual system where we chose to have our tax dollars go where we want... why stop at healthcare? If I don't want my tax dollars to go to... say the military? Can I defund the federal flood insurance because I feel we need to disincentivize living on the coast as sea levels raise (and personably live 900' above sea level)? Having individual discretion over what tax dollars goes to leads to an unmanageable mess for those trying to actually create a budget. Additionally, sometimes a national priority and the hard choices that goes with that means having taxes spent on things that aren't necessarily popular with the entirety of the electorate. The control over the budget comes (in theory) with voting on a house member who aligns with your goals for the budget. Yes - in theory.
- mirkules 6y agoI see healthcare as a special case, though (the rule about exceptions becoming the rule, notwithstanding). The healthcare system is interwoven with rules and regulations. For instance, we already have tax rules depending on your yearly FSA/HSA contributions, tax deductions based on how much money is spent, and most importantly the Obamacare rule that one must have insurance or suffer penalties. Would another exception break the system?
- throwawayboise 6y agoScandinavia is OK, not what many people in the US would call great. My uncle had prostate cancer, was basically put in hospice to die. He was kept comfortable and it was a nice place, but he was in his 70s and basically written off. And I'm not even saying that's the wrong approach. His life expectancy was in single-digit years at that point regardless, so why spend a lot of money on low probabilites of success? But a lot of people in the US think that every effort should be made, no matter how hopeless the situation or how much it costs.
- rootusrootus 6y agoPeople are afraid of government 'death panels' while completely ignoring the fact that such panels definitely exist now, but they are opaque. Try arguing with the insurance company when they've decided to deny your coverage.
- eric_h 6y agothe blame is delegated to a number on an excel spreadsheet ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- rootusrootus 6y agoA long while back, my brother worked for a local "non-profit" health insurance company. Same part of the building as some of the lawyers. They'd brag amongst themselves in the break room about the various ways they'd managed to avoid responsibility for paying a big claim. He ended up quitting his job because he couldn't stomach working in that environment.
- risyachka 6y agoIt's really easy to reason like that when you are not the one that needs treatment. Otherwise I am pretty sure 100% of people will think that every effort should be made.
- sokoloff 6y ago
- Alupis 6y ago> Scandinavia, UK. Public healthcare doesn't need to be bad Here's an article from 2018 (Pre-COVID) claiming the NHS has 4.3 Million people in it's operation backlog with over half waiting for more than one year[1]. That sounds outrageous, and a massive step backwards from what most in the US have today (even with low tier health insurance plans). I do not know why this is the reality in nations with Universal Healthcare, but the UK is not alone. I constantly hear anecdotes about people waiting 6+ months for minor operations in the UK (corroborated by this article and others), and how the wealthy/elites of Canada fly into the US for treatments. Why is it that Universal Healthcare seems to universally turn into massive backlogs and poorer service? I'm also not convinced we need some new "Universal" system in the US. Everyone in the US already does have access to healthcare (Medicare/Medicaid/Private). The only difference is above a certain income level you're expected to shop for your own. I much rather prefer that instead of it coming out of my paycheck in another mandatory tax without choice of provider. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/jul/13/nhs-operation-waiting-lists-reach-10-year-high-at-43m-patients https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/jul/13/nhs-operatio...
- ekimekim 6y ago> I constantly hear anecdotes about people waiting 6+ months for minor operations in the UK Emphasis on the "minor operations". Things are prioritised by need and urgency, so naturally you end up with a long tail of non-urgent, minor operations. > how the wealthy/elites of Canada fly into the US for treatments There's a reasonable argument here that the US system has advantages for the wealthy. Generally however this is seen as undesirable. > Everyone in the US already does have access to healthcare There's several issues with this statement. The first is that 32.8 million people (12% of the population) were uninsured in 2019[1]. The second is that even if you have health insurance on paper, it's generally prohibitively expensive to use, only kicking in once a deductible is reached that will bankrupt you regardless (40% of Americans can't cover a surprise $400 expense [2] and these deductibles can run into several $1000). The reality for many is that if they're sick, they tough it out because going to a doctor may cause them financial ruin. > above a certain income level you're expected to shop for your own. I much rather prefer that instead of it coming out of my paycheck in another mandatory tax without choice of provider. I'm not sure what your experiences have been, but the only context where I've been able to "shop for my own" provider was when an employer happened to offer one of two providers in their available plans, which wasn't always. Functionally I had almost no choice in my health insurance coverage short of specifically finding a job that offered what I wanted, which given my priveliged position as a software engineer would be possible but would be laughable for most professions. Functionally, my health insurance was a mandatory tax without a choice of provider, it just wasn't a tax paid to the government. I should also note that I now live in Australia, where we have a universal public system where I am still able to choose my doctor and other care providers. In fact, I feel that I have far more choice here than I ever did while living in the US. [1] https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/health-insurance.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/health-insurance.htm [2] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/nearly-40-of-americans-cant-cover-a-surprise-400-expense/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/nearly-40-of-americans-cant-cov...
- gcheong 6y ago# 2 is what gets me. There seems to be some rather odd idea here that having any portion of ones taxes go to supporting people who can't afford health insurance otherwise, even if it means that people would pay less overall for healthcare, is somehow more unfair than having each person take the personal risk of bankruptcy due to an expensive illness. There also seems to be some thinking along the lines of not having a "choice in the market" if we're all covered by the same system as if the market really provides much of a choice now.
- conanbatt 6y agoThe people without healthcare are not the ones driving this conversation. It is not about this at all.
- at_a_remove 6y agoI could throw in "glorious regulatory capture" making healthcare for all a cash bonanza for some companies as our taxes spiral ever upward.
- ppseafield 6y agoEdit: I missed the part where this was a list of excuses that had been heard. I was too hasty to reply. Disregard the following. 1) I'd just like to say the DMV in Oregon is an incredible experience. It certainly doesn't have to bad. I've experienced it in Georgia, which was awful. But health care now is a massive problem. I've had to change health care providers six times in the last two years because of it being tied to employment. 2) Because it's actually cheaper to have single payer. It's huge leverage in negotiation. It will catch things quicker in more people, which means better outcomes and less dire (and expensive) treatments. 3) In Germany you can get supplemental medical insurance on top of your national Healthcare which can get you better care. Additionally there are still private practices. 4,5,6) Compared to the rest of the world the US does indeed pay dramatically inflated prices, which has a depressive effecton the finances of the less wealthy. If you're saying you'd rather people (like those waiting for Medicare to get diagnosed) suffer so you can be richer, well... at least you are honest.
- sokoloff 6y agoI explicitly said these are not my statements but rather arguments I’ve heard (sometimes vehemently) from people opposed.
- ppseafield 6y agoI apologize. The topic is personal to me, and I was seeing red. I'll edit my comment and step away from HN for a bit.
- bushbaba 6y agoSingle payer can be cheaper. It doesn’t actually mean it will.
- mkr-hn 6y agoGeorgia had a bad spell back before some new rules for new drivers came into effect, but it seems to have cleared up.
- arrosenberg 6y agoGood list of objections I've heard. The people who say #1 will never get on board. The DMV is a state-level agency, and people have plenty of good (maybe not great) experiences with government agencies like Medicare, USPS or SSA. That's more of a talking point for opposition parties who oppose central government altogether. #2 isn't a serious objection, because the math is pretty clear that almost everyone winds up spending less. #4-6 are intractable and come down to the population having the will to overcome objections from capital and doctors. I do think that doctors and nurses are gettable if we bring down the costs of malpractice insurance and education so that overall take home doesn't suffer. In my experience trying to sell the idea, the biggest impediment to real progress is #3, though I am certain I have a local bias. That's the issue that keeps the knowledge working class separate from the labor-working class. I haven't come up with a good answer other than accommodating them by allowing first-class treatment for those with money and second-class treatment for everyone else. Not the most altruistic answer, but probably the most achievable. No one with premium healthcare now is going to risk it, and that's an important political block.
- leetcrew 6y agoregarding #2, the math isn't necessarily clear at all. I actually have no idea how much my health insurance costs. my employer isn't required to fill that box on my W-2, so they don't. I'm mostly convinced that the average cost would be lower, but governments in the US do seem to have an incredible ability to waste money.
- vlowther 6y agoWell, my insurance for a family of four cost slightly more than 10,000 last year (both employer and employee sides). You could triple the amount I paid into Medicare in exchange for Medicare covering everyone and I and my company would come out ahead. There has never been a year where I have been paying for insurance that it has not grown faster than inflation.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoYou can estimate it from this table NJ publishes: https://www.nj.gov/dobi/division_insurance/ihcseh/ihcrates2021.pdf https://www.nj.gov/dobi/division_insurance/ihcseh/ihcrates20... Add or subtract 10% based on your cost of living compared to NJ.
- sudosysgen 6y agoIt's important to note that a lot of why people think the federal government isn't good at doing things is because ideologues (from both parties) make it less efficient and more painful for no practical reason. That is sometimes called "starving the beast", or "means testing".
- fweespeech 6y ago> 1. I don’t want my healthcare to be provided by the same people who brought me a lifetime of experiences at the Department of Motor Vehicles. The public option still doesn't create that situation because its health insurance. They still aren't going to be healthcare providers. > 2. Healthcare is expensive. I’m already paying for healthcare for my family; why would I want to pay for healthcare for others as well? You already are through Medicare, Medicaid, and the Hospital System. In the articles example, you have people waiting until 65 to get more expensive surgical intervention that is less likely to preserve their life due to the wait. > 3. Good healthcare is expensive and I can afford and buy the best health insurance. I don’t want the best to be unavailable to me and my family because we’re all on a “just OK” government system. Under a public option system, you'd still be able to buy private insurance. No one is banning this. I think its misguided because the quality of insurance doesn't guarantee the quality of doctor and frankly, unless you are a specialist in their field, its unlikely you'll be able to accurately gauge the quality of care you receive. I've known plenty of people in the profession of manufacturing dental implants/equipment who thought they could judge the quality of their dentists and failed miserably to the point of needing to switch dentists due to poor workmanship. > 4. I’m a medical professional and think that I will make less money under a government-provided system of care. Alright, how do you feel about lowering the federal tax rate for me personally? Not everyone else, just me. Seems a bit unreasonable when phrased that way doesn't it?
- throwawayboise 6y ago> Under a public option system, you'd still be able to buy private insurance. No one is banning this. Sounds a lot like "if you like your doctor, you can keep your doctor."
- ta20210405 6y ago>"if you like your doctor, you can keep your doctor." Which was always a stupid line because it's not "your" doctor, it was never your doctor. It was your insurance's doctor. If you get a new job and "your" doctor isn't in the insurance network, they're no longer your doctor.
- 6y ago
- barbazoo 6y agoPeople who argue #2 might simply not understand how insurance works.
- ajsnigrutin 6y agoIf the insurance is fixed price (eg. pay $X and get $Y services), then yes. If it's a tax, you pay percentage of what you earn, and if you earn above average, you'll also be paying above average insurance rate but still getting average service.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoWith health care, average is just what health care is. Being rich shouldn't get you better actual health care. Cancer is cancer. A broken bone is a broken bone. Everything else is bells and whistles. Want to pay to get that MRI next week instead of in two months? Fine. Want to pay for an fancy room? Fine. You still get the same health care, though. Even if you pay more tax
- ajsnigrutin 6y ago> Being rich shouldn't get you better actual health care. Why not? If the healthcare is perfect, then there's no need to pay for better helathcare... but if it's not (eg. long wait times, outdated procedures,...), if someone pays to get a dentist tomorrow (instead of waiting 6monts for a government one), why not?
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoBeing rich shouldn't mean that you get better health care because your net worth doesn't make you a more deserving human than someone poor. Being poor doesnt mean you should suffer or get substandard care. And to be fair: I have socialized medicine, but I only got that lucky in my 30's after I moved from the US. I don't have long wait times for a doctor's appointment: Non-urgent has more wait time. (And it's OK: It doesn't matter if I have a cervical cancer screening tomorrow or in 2 months). I can get into the dentist urgently if needed. If I need to wait for 6 months to get a surgery, it means it isn't urgent and there is a safety net to get me through. IF you don't have a safety net, wait times are cruel. All that said, there is a private option here and folks do pay to skip some wait time - I'm generally against this as again, your net worth shouldn't determine whether you get care due to humanity and all - but I'm fine with folks paying for general bells and whistles. Sure, have a fancy room with fancy food if you want.
- deergomoo 6y ago> I’m already paying for healthcare for my family and we’re struggling to get ahead; why would I want to pay for healthcare for others as well? This one is my favourite because it’s literally how insurance works.
- ihm 6y agoActually insurance is even worse because you’re also paying for insurance company profits (and advertising, etc.)!
- closeparen 6y agoIn an insurance pool the other members subsidize you just as much as you subsidize them. Government healthcare could work that way in theory! But making government the administrator of a traditional risk pool is a boring technocratic argument. The substance of universal healthcare is a one way subsidy from higher earners to lower earners.
- klyrs 6y ago7. I'm a private medical insurance company. See #4 8. I'm a privately owned hospital. See #4 Overheads in the US are pretty ridiculous, and lobbying gets 5 through 8 incredible ROI. In addition to all of these reasons, we have tribal affiliation. Health care for all has been spun as socialism for so long that real progress here seems utterly intractable. Even if you could convince politicians that your list of reasons don't add up, they'd still look you dead in the eye and tell you that it won't happen because their constituents would come for their heads.
- pixel_fcker 6y ago2. The US federal government already spends about as much on healthcare per capita as countries where it is free at the point of use. You’re currently getting massively ripped off so insurance CEOs can buy another yacht. 3. All civilised countries have private healthcare as well as public. If you really want to pay more to avoid waiting lists and fancier wards, you can do so.