6 ms·
That's interesting, since my assumption is that Google would be fairly data driven. I'd be curious if Googlers feel like this is because they are really seeing
by tyingq 6y ago
That's interesting, since my assumption is that Google would be fairly data driven. I'd be curious if Googlers feel like this is because they are really seeing reduced productivity, or if there's a different motivation.
- dmitrygr 6y ago> Google would be fairly data driven That was Google. No longer. Xoogler (2012-2019)
- d3ntb3ev1l 6y agoGoogle HR told me “data showed remote doesn’t work” I asked for the data and never got it. I don’t work their anymore
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoI think you'll be looking for a while if your standards for an employer is that you have arbitrary access to the data they use to make decisions. There are a handful of radically transparent employers out there but it is the vanishing exception, not the rule.
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoWell the trouble is if you tell everyone that you are data-driven, and do so in most cases, then people are definitely going to ask about what data you used to make a decision. If you're explicitly HiPPO based decision making, this tends not to happen.
- bla3 6y agoHow do they know it's "remote" and not "working during a pandemic"?
- acover 6y agoCompanies have been testing this for ages. It's the holy grail to have remote work on par with in office.
- Frost1x 6y agoAs someone who has done it for over a decade, in software, it's totally doable providing your org has all the infrastructure and has a culture that successful business requires treating their employees like humans who need to socialize, communicate, and slack off a bit like they would in a physical office. Usually online work turns into a push to maximizing efficiency and minimizing time you'd normally be "wasting" at an office. People then hate it, informal socialization doesn't happen, and hidden business processes that live in those informal social interactions that keep things moving don't happen. They can happen online, the most difficult part of building trust with others to create positive cohesive relationships.
- saagarjha 6y ago"Data driven" is frequently code for "we'll pick metrics that support what we want".
- azemetre 6y agoYeah, it's very easy to pick and gain metrics to support whatever view point you want to espouse. We see this in politics all the time, sometimes even multiple politicians using the same data set to push wildly different proposals. Why would Google be any different? Kinda seems odd too because the only metric that you would think matters (stock price) would have heavy consideration (~90% growth since March 2020).
- alexgmcm 6y agoYep, and then employees have a harder time challenging it - because how is an employee without the power of HR, facilities etc. going to gather the almighty data?
- postalrat 6y agoThe people who think they are more productive working from home know that better than anyone.
- azurezyq 6y agoDisclaimer: Googler managing a small product engineering team. I have to say WFH has a considerable impact on productivity. Coding is actually fine, but the problems are: 1. Designing over VC is very difficult, especially for something entirely new. 3~4 people working on a single whiteboard is far more efficient. 2. Personal relationships are difficult to grow, especially for newbies. Usually those things got grown via coffee chats, launch meets, ad-hoc talks, but those are all gone. You know, a lot of cases, whether you know someone in the other team matters a lot. I don't have a word to describe it precisely, maybe "lower team coherency". 3. Really bad work-life balance in general. When busy and everyone's WFH, boundary between work and life really got blurred. There's nothing like "gotta go, chat tomorrow" stuff. Those are things may not be easily tracked from data, but really harmful in the long run. I cannot imagine how to manage effectively after another year of WFH.
- humanrebar 6y ago>...whether you know someone in the other team matters a lot... I was kind of hoping the remote work experience would help folks make that sort of inside baseball less important. There are real equity concerns to consider, but practically speaking, you end up with narrower and less open decision-making processes in general. It's definitely a complicated subject, but maybe some folks are partly missing some privilege that they need to learn to let go.
- azurezyq 6y agoI have to say it's human nature. When asking for a favor, you always feel more comfortable if the other guy had a nice chat with you yesterday. There are always things cannot be easily rationalized via formal processes.
- hrktb 6y agoIt goes both ways though. Up until now the nice chat zone was limited to people on the same floor. With WFH we got people in other countries joigning the chats on equal footing. The info density difference also seem to be compensated by everyone being more open and comfortable (not packed in noisy office for the day) There's definitely less random chats, it's more formal and less intense, but also broader and the hurdle is lower. I think for companies above some size it's not better or worse, just different.
- lacker 6y agoI don’t think it’s possible to be completely data driven about a company-wide cultural change that you can’t a/b test. A year or so after they make the decision, though, I’m sure they’ll have data on whether they have a spike in losing employees to competitors like Facebook that are more remote-friendly.
- dividefuel 6y ago(Googler, opinions are my own) I don't think Google has really justified why the return to the office is necessary for all employees, beyond saying that it's a key part of the culture. Obviously the office is a part of the culture, and most employees want to be in the office at least some of the time. But to me, that doesn't explain why you can't offer a remote option for the employees who want it. A charitable explanation might be what we've heard from execs: we don't want to rush to go remote, we'd like to dip our toes in and slowly explore broader options. Thus the hybrid 3/2 model. A less charitable explanation might be that Google has spent a lot of money on real estate. Or simply that leadership is out of touch and can't relate to the reasons why employees might want to be remote. I imagine it's a mix of both types of explanations.
- frongpik 6y agoOr even simpler: execs own super expensive real estate in the tech hubs and the only thing that supports the prices is the hoards of employees that have to live in the area.
- wu_187 6y agoThis is the true answer. A lot of people have moved into far away (cheaper) bedroom communities to save money. Also Google themselves would have a huge issue justifying their own real estate if people aren't in it "post covid". They are a publicly traded company so they would be forced to sell it off to appease investors. All in all I think Google has shown it's true colors here. They don't have a damn about their employees. This reeks of boomer micromanaging 101. I think that to fight this stockholders should push Alphabet to sell of their properties now. Should do the same with Amazon as well.
- DataJunkie 6y ago> All in all I think Google has shown it's true colors here. They don't have a damn about their employees. That's exactly how I feel.
- doktorhladnjak 6y ago
- titzer 6y agoXoogler here, left pre-pandemic. Google has always been very data-driven. It just seeks data that support management's ideas of how they want to run the company. Despite ample evidence showing that cramped, loud working spaces both decrease productivity and increase sick days for coworkers (because flu and the common cold, and other reasons), management went for densification to meet growth targets and cut real estate outlays. Google workspaces would have been the absolute perfect super spreader spaces for COVID. TBH I feel a bit of schadenfreude for their deliberate choice to create that environment, and this article saddens me to see that Google hasn't learned much. I, for one, hated the densification and tight working environments, but I didn't have the "data" to make a hill of beans difference.
- danans 6y agoGoogler, but opinions are my own. A lot of employees like me would like to go back to the office, but would also like to have a few days at home for personal reasons (exercise time, kids school events, etc), fewer hours of exhausting commuting, and even just to have lunch at the restaurants in my own neighborhood. This would reduce the exhaustion one can feel at the end of a 5 day office week and leave you feeling fresher next time you come in to the office. The 3-in-office/2-at-home week referenced would work well in this regard.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]