4 ms·
People on the ground never have use for such tech. These deals are all political and the actual equipment arrives by the truckloads and sits unboxed. When peop
by paxys 6y ago
People on the ground never have use for such tech. These deals are all political and the actual equipment arrives by the truckloads and sits unboxed.
When people rant about ridiculous military budgets and spending it isn't about cutting soldiers' salaries but shit like this.
- ausbah 6y agogood for R&D I suppose
- paxys 6y agoPrivate, patented R&D which benefits a single trillion-dollar corporation funded by public dollars. Too common in this country sadly.
- quickthrowman 6y agoI own MSFT shares, why don’t you?
- verdverm 6y agoYou might consider the awesome open-source software MSFT is developing for this device, the Mixed Reality Toolkit, which many benefit from. There are ancillary benefits. MRTK also works for non-MSFT products and with Unity
- rtx 6y ago>corporation Public corporation, buy shares and enjoy the loot.
- axlee 6y agoIt's nothing more than welfare and stimulus that republicans can get behind.
- anon_tor_12345 6y agoThere's a very obvious analogy here that proves you wrong: nvgs
- wcarss 6y agofor anyone else who was confused and about to google it: Night Vision Goggles[1]. 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Night-vision_device https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Night-vision_device
- remarkEon 6y agoHis take is a little cyclical, but it's not wrong necessarily. For every set of PVS-14s there were 3 or 4 little pieces of "tech" that were utterly useless.
- MichaelMcG 6y agoNot just useless, but a major PITA when the next inventory rolls around and you have to find the individual sub-components of that "tech" when no one has any idea of what it looks like because it's never been used and ultimately serves no purpose. Then if it somehow falls through the cracks, it's on the commanders shoulders to pay for that piece of high-speed unused tech that the lobbyist swore would revolutionize the battle-space.
- remarkEon 6y agoI actually met some of the contractors who were "in-country", as they called it, to train and re-train folks on how to use all these sensors. While I was at KAF, I had dinner with one of them and very clearly explained that the equipment he was representing was completely useless to my platoon and me and the rest of the PLs in the company ordered our guys to not worry about it and toss it back in the container. He was fully aware of the feedback that infantry folks had for this stuff, which was really eyeopening to me for how the defense contracting world really works.
- munk-a 6y agoIs one in five such a bad ratio for useful innovation? It might speak to there being some problems with state-side testing of devices for appropriateness on the battlefield but a 20% success rate of cutting edge equipment seems pretty good. Infantry folk are probably going to use the useful bits and pack away the useless ones - that feedback will eventually trickle back to fulfillment and the kit will be updated. Also - I have a lot of faith in infantrymen finding really creative uses for tech that folks in the lab might disregard.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> People on the ground never have use for such tech. Strong disagree. I would absolutely love to have access to field and barracks VR and AR tech. I think there are many immediate and practical and simple applications.
- ryanmarsh 6y agoPlease point me to an example of this. Short of prepo supply, I never once saw an example of this.
- fwip 6y agoThe army has a little under 500K active-duty soldiers. As a gross overestimation, if they were delivering one headset per soldier, napkin math shows: $22B / 500K = $44K per headset. Even if the tech were super useful and every single soldier got one, that price tag seems absolutely absurd. How can anyone be okay with this?
- wcarss 6y agoI'm not necessarily supportive of the contract or the spending or whatever, but I just want to present a reframing of the costs: imagine it's just 1000 headsets, but they're so useful they cut $1B/year+ in costs (or allow for $1B/year+ in extra operational capacity) annually for the next 50+ years. This is, allegedly, foundational work on a transformative technology, so maybe that's "the dream". Now ... is that realistic? haha
- verdverm 6y agoYou're on point, these will save the military more money than they are spending. There are two very key areas off the battlefield, planning and maintenance, where this will save big time on people hours / salary
- fwip 6y agoSo say that they're for planning and maintenance, and we only need 50 thousand headsets. That's $450,000 per headset/person. You'd have to have some pretty amazing efficiency upgrades to save money on salary.
- formercoder 6y agoGiven you’d only be making 500k units, and you’re making them to milspec, sounds like a pretty good deal to me.
- therobot24 6y agocontract award doesn't mean all 22B was spent, that often means the contract ceiling where money can be obligated to it as we buy
- Tossrock 6y agoUS air superiority fighters already include AR in their helmets.
- shubb 6y agoThis is probably related to training. Apparently, training is quite expensive - actually flying planes or firing guns and missiles, especially large ones, is expensive. I think in an ideal world they would want to just strap soldiers into 'the matrix' and train them for free in a computer. Maybe they are hoping that they can do the cheap parts of the training with AR headsets on, and see the results of what they are doing (firing a very expensive missile at a helicopter target that would burn fuel if real) in simulation? Traditionally I understand this has been done by shouting 'bang' and pretending a helicopter exploded. Do Hollywood special effects that only they can see actually make soldiers more effective? Huge military research budgets usually mean that this kind of spending is driven by something like a clinical trial - maybe a 3rd military research contractor trained some soldiers the normal way, and some with VR, and then compared their performance at doing 'the real task'. This was probably then sold as a cost saving.
- proc0 6y agoLet's not forget how the Internet started. Maybe a huge portion of the military is relatively low tech, but they're definitely on the cutting edge (probably have to).