5 ms·
It’s been banished from non religious parts of academia because it’s not falsifiable or testable, so it belongs in the theology department.
by selimthegrim 6y ago
It’s been banished from non religious parts of academia because it’s not falsifiable or testable, so it belongs in the theology department.
- camjohnson26 6y agoIt is testable, if a scientist creates life in a laboratory then intelligent design exists. It is falsifiable, you can compute the amount of information contained in biological structures, and compute whether known natural processes can create that amount of information on the timescale of the universe. If they can, intelligent design is falsified. Regardless, where the theory lives in the org chart is irrelevant to whether it is true or not, and it’s certainly no worse than all the other origin of life speculation.
- whatshisface 6y ago>If they can, intelligent design is falsified. That's not true, demonstrating that process A could have resulted in the observed effect does not show that process B did not cause it.
- camjohnson26 6y agoIf that’s true every paper that references life’s origins needs to be retracted. If natural processes can be responsible for abiogenesis then intelligent design becomes much less likely, which is as close to falsifiable as you can get for a statement of history.
- api 6y agoThe larger metaphysical claims are not testable. Some of the narrower claims are, such as that self-replicating evolvable structures cannot arise naturally. This basically amounts to the claim that the complexity floor of life is too high for such a structure to arise naturally over terrestrial time spans. Obviously a demonstration of abiogenesis would invalidate that claim. This could also be challenged by computational models that are sufficiently physically plausible, or the discovery or creation of even simpler lifeforms that extend the lower complexity bound of life down to regions that challenge the argument. Of course another possibility is that this is our Fermi paradox answer: life is in fact so profoundly unlikely that its frequency of occurrence is e.g. less than once per billion years per galaxy!
- camjohnson26 6y agoExactly, these are major themes in the books I posted. Darwin’s Doubt deals specifically with the Cambrian Explosion and the explosion of information over a short time span that it represented. It digs deep into the search space of protein folds and epigenetic information and whether known evolutionary processes can be responsible for the original emergence of the simplest forms of life, or if there are even simpler forms of life possible that lived before the Cambrian Explosion.
- hnitbanalns 6y agoI appreciate your posted alternative theory on this subject. It's refreshing.
- mssundaram 6y agoLooks like you've been shadow banned? All of your comments are dead (check your post history in a private/non logged in window). I am not sure if you'll even get this reply!
- api 6y agoWe don't know how much information was required for the Cambrian explosion because we don't have DNA sequence information from that era. We can only guess based on the DNA sequence information of today or from recent (in geological terms) fossils frozen in ice cores, etc. All the DNA sequence info we have is actually extremely recent. It's possible that the very long "boring" period before the Cambrian explosion was in reality when a whole lot of stuff was being evolved that later all came together to allow large scale cellular cooperation. An analogy I like is a barn raising. If you watched a barn raising from very far away it would appear that nothing is happening and then boom, you get a barn. In reality the structure is being assembled slowly on the ground for a long time before anything "macro" happens. This analogy also comes up in regard to macroevolution and perhaps even abiogenesis. BTW it's important to remember that modern evolutionary theory does not include a theory of abiogenesis. Life is assumed to exist and evolutionary theory deals with how it changes over time. The origin of life is a separate (albeit related) scientific question and one for which we do not currently have an established answer. There are many credible hypotheses but so far no way to really test them.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoThe ironic thing is that now many physicists are studying non-falsifiable theories like the multiverse.
- camjohnson26 6y agoI can’t find a complete version but the last minute of this clip from Silicon Valley nails that disconnect, the whole clip is spot on. (NSFW, language) https://youtu.be/TWoRVaGlFRc https://youtu.be/TWoRVaGlFRc
- mensetmanusman 6y agoMy favorite test is to check whether life is anywhere else in the universe. If we were to follow the science, then absolutely there is. But if you checked and there wasn’t? Unfortunately it would take more energy than exists in the universe to travel and a check everywhere. :)