14 ms·
One thing I don't understand about monetizing on the Internet. I see the author considered ads, tried an affiliate scheme and even did an NFT. But what about p
by TeMPOraL 6y ago
One thing I don't understand about monetizing on the Internet.
I see the author considered ads, tried an affiliate scheme and even did an NFT. But what about plain old, honest to God payment? Couldn't they just put a paragraph of text on the site, "Hey folks, I'm worried about hosting costs, if you find this page useful, please [Donate]", with a button redirecting to Paypal or Stripe or whatever, collect the money and declare it as donations on the IRS form? Why try all these convoluted schemes, instead of giving a straightforward way for people to tip?
They had 50 million views. If 0.01% of these visitors left a dollar, the author would've still come up way ahead over all the crazy schemes, even post-tax.
- brentm 6y agoThe best path probably would of been getting in touch with Flexport and getting them to sponsor it for a couple grand + hosting.
- twox2 6y agoWho would pay $1 for getting a chuckle out of a meme? Also 50 million views is not 50 million visitors. If he had a normal ad monetization channel in place, he should have easily been able to garnish a minimum of a 10 cent CPM and walked away with at least $5k from his 15 minutes of fame. The problem is that learning as you go makes it a little too late to monetize the peak. There are companies whose entire business is in pumping out viral sites like this. Some explode for a a little while and others never make a penny. You can bet your butt that in the hands of someone who does this professionally these 50 million views would have been thousands and thousands of dollars.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoI would, particularly if the blurb was very honest (or very creative). I have no trouble throwing someone even a one-time $5 if the website is funny enough.
- pjc50 6y agoHow often do you do this per month? How many webpages do you read per month? Now divide one by the other.
- bfgoodrich 6y agoZero times. They never have. When people give the "oh yeah I'd be generous" spiel, they're lying. Indeed, they're usually the cheapest of all (in the same way that the people who tell you how generous they are with tips are usually the ones who stiff wait staff).
- rchaud 6y agoIMO this wouldn't be a bad thing. There would be a stronger market mechanism at play here. It could cut down on the amount of garbage internet we consume, while incentivizing producers to create higher-value content that people will pay for, and that won't be forgotten immediately like this Suez website.
- colpabar 6y agoUnfortunately you are in the extreme minority. I was watching a stream on youtube that has an optional patreon subscription and people were complaining that $0.99 per MONTH was too much because the stream was too quiet for a bit. Paying directly for things you like on the internet doesn't seem like a big deal to us here on HN, but the overwhelming majority of people will never even consider it. Everything else is free, why should anyone have to pay for anything?
- rchaud 6y agoIMO the pricing itself signals that the product isn't worth paying for. $0.99 per month? For what I'm sure includes hours of streaming? It's close enough to $0 that I don't even think about whether an additional buck is going to make a difference.
- rebelde 6y ago> he should have easily been able to garnish a minimum of a 10 cent CPM Uh, not in my experience. I haven't tried to monetize a site like this, but I would expect a CPM around 1 cent. Still, times 50 million, it isn't nothing.
- troydavis 6y ago> I would expect a CPM around 1 cent. Still, times 50 million, it isn't nothing. CPM is cost per mille, AKA cost per thousand impressions. Revenue from 50,000,000 impressions would be CPM * 50,000.
- retsibsi 6y agoThanks for specifying this. There's a typo/arithmetic error in the original comment, which led me to assume CPM must mean 'per 100'.
- twox2 6y agoIt's tough as an individual that's just dipping their toes into the water, but if you have some experience, then you typically have an optimized setup with partners in place, etc.
- at_a_remove 6y agoIn the grim future of 2050, we have finally implemented micropayments on the Internet, down to amounts as tiny as a thousandth of one cent and trending downward as we account for hyperinflation of other currencies. Advanced technologies, ubiquitous computing, brilliant algorithms, and near-sentient fraud watchdog programs have combined to make this dream at last possible. Only then we will have proved that the vast majority of people will not pay a dime for content on the web.
- iamacyborg 6y ago> Who would pay $1 for getting a chuckle out of a meme? That sort of feels like the core issue. Why even try to monetise a page like this?
- VBprogrammer 6y agoIn the article he mentioned this; he was worried about the hosting costs. Thankfully his host got a laugh out of it and donated the hosting cost and he has in turn donated any proceeds.
- iamacyborg 6y agoRight, but if you're incurring significant hosting costs for a static site in 2021 then you're doing something wrong.
- FalconSensei 6y agounless you have images?
- filoleg 6y agoCloudflare Pages[0] claims to have unlimited bandwidth, even for their free tier. 0. https://pages.cloudflare.com/#plans https://pages.cloudflare.com/#plans
- tomjohnneill 6y agoIn hindsight, you're right. And obviously I didn't. However at the time, it was the uncertainty as a result of never having done something like this that made me worried.
- ampdepolymerase 6y agoIf you can build a PaaS around it like Giphy and sell user data, sure.
- 6y ago
- dillondoyle 6y agoReddit gold seems to fit here. It makes no sense to me but it seems to be working. I find it funny the threads complaining about Reddit's recent horrible hiring an mod decisions all had TONS of gold lol
- T-hawk 6y agoReddit gold makes tons of sense. People can pay money to amplify the opinions they want amplified. Reddit actually monetized internet arguing.
- rchaud 6y ago> Reddit actually monetized internet arguing. I never thought about it like this. I always just thought of Reddit Gold as just another weird Internet quirk I will never understand. I kind of wonder if NFTs for artwork will become the same thing. Like amplifying comments, maybe high NFT prices will be a way to amplify one artist over another in what is a very crowded marketplace.
- retsibsi 6y agoDoes gold affect the ranking of a comment (i.e. where it is displayed on the page)? I guess I never really thought about it, but I assumed not. If it's all about the icon displayed next to the comment header, I suppose that's a kind of amplification -- but it seems like less of a zero-sum game, because it's not forcing another opinion out of view.
- T-hawk 6y agoYes, it does. I think most of the various silly awards they have nowadays don't do it, but at least the original Reddit Gold award before all that other stuff does elevate a post or comment.
- dillondoyle 6y agoSorry I meant it makes no sense for redditers to buy gold for posts that they are specifically calling out Reddit for bad behavior
- danparsonson 6y agoI suspect 0.01% is highly optimistic, especially for a meme-related site that's essentially a drive-by laugh for most people.
- oefrha 6y agoIf my developer tool with thousands of stars on GitHub generates $15/yr in donations, I would say 0.01% of visitors each donating $1 to a website they on average spend 1 minute or less on (seems a reasonable assumption?) is far too optimistic.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoCan you give any other metric for its popularity? Stars aren't a good one - Github stars are bookmarks, not a reflection of whether one actually uses a given repository. Personally, I have 301 starred repositories, of which I maybe use... 5?
- oefrha 6y agoI'd say a repo needs more than 150k views to get ~5k stars. I can confidently say the number of users who derive actual value from it is measured in the hundreds at least (compared to none on a viral meme site). If those views aren't generating 0.01% * $1, I can bet the house on viral meme site not generating that much, unless they happen to land very generous donors. Edit: Just checked Homebrew analytics. >10k recorded installs in the past year (low single digit number of releases during that period, no major publicity event). I don't have readily available analytics for other installation channels on macOS, or analytics for Linux and Windows which are pretty fractured. Point is the user base is sizable.
- spijdar 6y agoI think regardless of how good a metric stars are, it's still more likely to receive donations than a meme site about a recent event. I can't remember ever hearing someone talk about how successful their donation button was. I can remember plenty of people describing how few people ever click it, though...
- WJW 6y agoStars are even worse than bookmarks, they're more like likes on social media. Costs nothing and worth nothing, literally imaginary internet validation points. "Oh this is a cool thing, I'll star it why not."
- 6y ago
- Kalium 6y agoThe conventional wisdom on the internet, often backed by common experience, is that significantly less than 0.01% of visitors leave a dollar. Internet donation plates are not known for producing consistent revenue.
- davedx 6y ago> Couldn't they just [...] :D
- TeMPOraL 6y agoYes :). But otherwise, the question is serious.
- bkanber 6y agoFor the last 10 years or so I've been running a free-to-use Morse Code online radio thing. It has cost me about $1000 to host so far, and has a couple of hundred DAUs. The users are not shy about feature requests, and they're not shy about complaining that I haven't implemented their feature requests. So I made a pledge to the userbase that if they collectively donate $1000 to the site, I'll start working on v2. I posted that pledge to the site a year ago. Total donations: $80. There are a couple of hundred people who use the site for hours per day and post on the forums that they love it, but haven't donated a fiver. Asking for donations doesn't work.
- input_sh 6y agoI don't know, I always feel like there has to be some reward to incentivize people, even if it's dead simple. Like, you can choose to have your name publicly displayed on a thank you page (this would work well with BMAC, since donations can be both anonymous and not), or have your username be of different colour or have some badge next to it. But then again, I don't know how I would fit that into this meme page, and I'm definitely not an expert having earned a total of two euros of donations (yet to implement some reward system).
- thrashh 6y agoI’ve run a few donation schemes and those things don’t do much. People just don’t donate. Subscriptions are the best, but obv that won’t work for a meme page.
- iamacyborg 6y agoSo how does Wikipedia manage to get donations? Is it just a scale problem where you needs hundreds of millions of pageviews a day to generate any meaningful number of donations?
- jowsie 6y agoWikipedia has a lot more utility than a website about a current event you're gonna visit 2 or 3 times before the issue is resolved. It's a lot easier to justify that donation.
- mrtksn 6y ago>They had 50 million views. If 0.01% of these visitors left a dollar, the author would've still come up way ahead over all the crazy schemes, even post-tax. IMHO that is a fallacy. Although %0.01 looks like a really small number there's no reason for it for not being %0.001 or %0.000001. When people do napkin math , it's a common theme to say that "If we only capture %1 of the market we would be $$$rich$$$" and they proceed to find out that there are smaller percentiles than %1. To receive donations people need to be sympathetic to you or your cause. You need to actively sell it, making it a considerable part of the user experience. It's really hard to build that relationship with just one visit. Maybe there are visitors deeply invested in the situation and they may actually obsess with your product but you need to look into the analytics to see if it's the case. If there are visitors that appear to be visiting extremely frequently, you need to explore ways to ask for the money and for that you will need data(profiles of the visitors) to develop your message however the OP doesn't do detailed analytics and profiling. It could be possible to monetise it and even catch a few whales but chances are that you can also alienate those people with the wrong messaging, so you probably will need to do personalisation which requires data and cookies and what not, which means data collection and sharing permission popups. Of course you can try your chances and pick a group of people that you believe are using your product and proceed with A/B testing etc instead of profiling. If you happen to choose the privacy nerds as a target you will find out how much the privacy nerds like donating.
- WaitWaitWha 6y ago>IMHO that is a fallacy. Email spam works exactly this way. I think what you are pointing out correctly, is that the percentage might be incorrect; the principle is not.
- mrtksn 6y agoI don’t think that spam is a fair comparison. Spammers send out offer for stuff that people want. It’s completely different than first giving out what people want and then asking for a gratitude payment. Spam’s success rate would be dictated by the percentage of the people who want the product in the general population after passing through the spam delivery funnel. With the donations it’s completely different mechanism. Nevertheless, the fallacy is that small looking number of market share is the smallest possible market share.
- jahewson 6y agoHey, if it was a $10 donation they’d only need 0.001% of users and for $100 just 0.0001%. /s
- jahewson 6y agoHmm, if was a $10 donation they’d only need 0.001% of users and for $100 just 0.0001%. Boom!! But yeah 1/1000 people are not going to randomly pay for something with a market price of $0.
- codingdave 6y agoReverse that - how many websites do you visit, and look for a way to give them a dollar? It just isn't how web audiences operate. I'm not saying that it is a bad idea - paying for good content could solve many problems. It just isn't where we are today.
- carabiner 6y ago> If 0.01% of these visitors left a dollar... 0.01% is a fantasy, massively high conversion rate, just so you know.
- PedroBatista 6y ago> If 0.01% of these visitors left a dollar, You're correct, but reality doesn't agree. It has been proven time and time again that 0.01% almost always DON'T leave a dollar for anything.
- rchaud 6y ago> They had 50 million views. If 0.01% of these visitors left a dollar If it wasn't a simple meme website to spend 5 seconds on and never visit again, it would not have gotten 50 million views. Trying to monetize that is like squeezing blood from a stone. I imagine that's one reason why he's posting this from a Substack domain.
- passivate 6y ago>Why try all these convoluted schemes, instead of giving a straightforward way for people to tip? >They had 50 million views. If 0.01% of these visitors left a dollar, the author would've still come up way ahead over all the crazy schemes, even post-tax. Currently ads are the easiest way to monetize a not-well-known web property in the short-term. Long-term you can build a brand/trust/community/etc and leverage that into patreon/donations.
- jefftk 6y agoFor Bucket Brigade I ask for donations [1] which has covered about 50% of my costs so far [2]. I think how well this works depends a lot on how useful people find your site vs what your costs are? [1] https://echo.jefftk.com/#About https://echo.jefftk.com/#About [2] https://www.jefftk.com/bucket-brigade-payments https://www.jefftk.com/bucket-brigade-payments
- nicbou 6y agoI wouldn't say it works if it doesn't even support your running costs. A website I live from generates about 50€ per month in donations.
- draw_down 6y agoDo you think people just haven’t tried this, or something? They didn’t think of it? People try other things because this doesn’t work, in general.
- weird-eye-issue 6y agoThis never works. People just don't donate. Only developers think donations are a viable form of monetization.
- dktalks 6y agoI had a popular website which had 20MM views per month but made most of my money through ad banners. I tried direct sell for banners, links etc but they never materialized because you could actually pay cents on the dollar to do that through a network. Also, one thing I learned on the website was that having 20 million views on your website does not equate to a consistent amount of money because the ads don't pay the sam e in every country. For example, I had some ads pay $20CPM and some that paid $0.00001 because they were fillers, so I had to tweak my low fillers by signing up with local country ad networks who could provide better CPMs. In the end, it still did not evolve into a large shift and the average was still lower, good but not great. I think that these days, running your own website is good, you might still get 50MM views but not much income because ads are still not going to give you the best returns which is why some or more websites are shifting to a paywall. For the most time, everyone was good with ads, because that was what worked. Now it's paywalls and it will trend that way because they get the most value and a consistent payment that way (not many cancel active subscriptions over a period of time). Ads will still play significant amount of money for direct sellers like Google, Facebook, Twitter & Amazon, but not for third party sites who will have to find different ways. There is also the upgrades to search engines and facebook/twitter etc to now keep you on their own website for everything and corner a full $$ vs paying third party websites a cut, which is why we see snippets etc in search engines and then people engage there more and click on a higher paying ad to them. Also, there is ad-blockers, which means you are not getting any impressions on some percentage of the visitors in the first place.
- briefcomment 6y agoRemember that McDonalds ice cream machine status site[1]? The guy has a buy me a coffee link right up top. I think he gets a solid stream of donations. I remember dozens per day a couple months ago. [1]https://mcbroken.com https://mcbroken.com
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- markogresak 6y agoI’m genuinely interested in how one would pull $0.5MM in donations from a one-off meme site. Why would one donate to such a site?