7 ms·
Covid 'fuse' may have been lit weeks or months before the 'bomb' in Wuhan market
- PartiallyTyped 6y agoPerhaps monitoring twitter and other social media for symptoms that deviate from the expected for the timeframe is the kind of surveillance mentioned in the article [1]. It is definitely unrealistic to be on the hunt for pathogens by inspecting every single person, but using social media for guided search could prove useful. [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32937679/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32937679/
- mc32 6y agoThere was the Wuhan ophthalmologist[1] who pulled the alarm but got a visit by police and eventually succumbed to the disease. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Li_Wenliang https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Li_Wenliang
- SiempreViernes 6y agoHe was the first that publicly recognised the original outbreak as something new, but that's not the sort of preventive surveillance we're interested in. Of course it would have been great if the Chinese were more transparent during those early days (and in general honestly), but it's pretty clear that the original outbreak was just the first smoke escaping from inside the burning roof: by late December it was already an uncontained epidemic that had spread far outside Wuhan. We'd like something that would pick up the disease before it makes it to the epidemic status.
- beagle3 6y agoWhich is weird in itself - The probability of death for a healthy 30-something year old is lower than their probability to die in a car crash (1/10 to 1/100 of all cause mortality for that age group). It’s a game of probability, of course, but it turns out that whistle blowers often suffer from “coincidences” and “low probability events”, and whenever that happens, I try to take note.
- Retric 6y agoI think doctors at outbreaks like this are at much higher risk of death than the average person due to stress and a much higher viral load than normal. Medical professionals only start to use protective gear after they realized how dangerous a disease is. Before that their spending significant time around highly infectious people in inclosed spaces while under extreme stress. Wuhan lost a significant number of medical professionals presumably due to this.
- ad404b8a372f2b9 6y agoI assume that's the average death rate for healthy 30 year olds over the whole pandemic, I don't think it applies to how things were in the beginning with overrun hospitals and overworked health professionals. If you look at the SARS epidemic you see plenty of cases like these.
- SketchySeaBeast 6y agoNot only that, but no known effective medications or treatments. They were flying totally blind at the beginning.
- herendin2 6y agoIt is unlikely, but unlikely events happen. It does not have to be a conspiracy. Think about this: If he hadn't died, he probably would have received much less attention. There were a few other eloquent Chinese whistle-blowers from the early days, Jan-Feb 2020, who have been silenced by government threats or by being detained, who do not have the public recognition of Dr Li - probably because they didn't die.
- jjk166 6y agoWith regards to the car crash probability: those are the odds that if something were to kill you that it would be a car crash, not the odds of actually dying in a car crash. In reality the odds of any specific 30 year old male in the US dying in a car crash over the course of a year is 0.02% (I don't have data for driving fatalities for china, but I presume they are not substantially higher). This is about 50 times less likely than a 30 year old who has tested positive for covid dying from covid, or equivalently getting covid at 30 raises your risk of death as much as a second lifetime worth of driving.
- johnchristopher 6y agoThere are already long term studies (in France for instance there is the constance cohorte https://www.constances.fr/cohorte/presentation-constances.php https://www.constances.fr/cohorte/presentation-constances.ph...) that ask volunteers to come and get tested for a lot of things. This data is being looked at and it seems there were already covid cases months before reports of cases in Wuhan https://www.francetvinfo.fr/replay-radio/samedi-investigation/covid-19-des-francais-contamines-bien-avant-les-premiers-cas-officiels-temoignent-pour-la-premiere-fois_4348403.html https://www.francetvinfo.fr/replay-radio/samedi-investigatio....
- PartiallyTyped 6y agoThis is very interesting, do you have a translated article?
- johnchristopher 6y agohttps://www.rfi.fr/en/france/20210311-surprises-about-french-health-emerge-from-long-term-cohort-study-covid-19-november-2019-constances https://www.rfi.fr/en/france/20210311-surprises-about-french...
- xyzzy21 6y agoMore evidence of a leak from the virus lab, which satisfies Occam's Razor far, far better.
- seventytwo 6y agoNo it’s not.
- jaywalk 6y agoIt doesn't appear to be evidence in either direction, honestly. They stick with the bat > human jump theory in the article, but it's more of an offhand remark than anything else.
- Tostino 6y agoI've seen no evidence either way. How are you so sure one way or the other?
- mgamache 6y agoyes, it is... There's no evidence of cases months earlier. Virus don't typically jump species and are effective immediately. They need time to adapt. Therefore: a) The virus learned about humans over weeks or months in public with no one noticing b) The virus learned about humans in a lab then leaked resulting in a fast moving pandemic
- ab7675226 6y agoThere are thousands of wet markets throughout China. Even if you restrict your view to major cities only, there's over 100 cities in China with a million inhabitants. There were 2 known locations in China where coronaviruses were being studied - Beijing and Wuhan. Now apply Bayesian analysis. This is before you look at the coverup and the history of diseases escaping from research labs all over the world and the documented inadequate safety measures in the Chinese labs.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThe longer time-line makes a lab leak incredibly unlikely. WIV publishes data and shares it with international collaborators frequently, given the fact that every paper on bat coronaviruses from the WIV has international collaborators, how does it make sense that the sample wasn't known to anyone else in the months between the leak and detection?
- underseacables 6y agoThe more we learn the more it points to a lab leak, but Chinese commenters will deny it, claim racism, many on the left will say it’s simply not true, and yet here we are. Something caused it and it came from China. With a government that 100% cannot be trusted to tell the truth let alone defend human life, it’s more likely than not this was an accidental leak.
- SketchySeaBeast 6y ago> Something caused it Yes > and it came from China. Yes, it seems that way. >With a government that 100% cannot be trusted to tell the truth let alone defend human life, Sure. > it’s more likely than not this was an accidental leak. This does not follow your other points. Just because it's within the realm of possibility that someone could have done it doesn't mean they did it. Just because someone is a bad guy doesn't mean you can attribute everything bad that happens in their house to them. Sometimes bad stuff happens and it's not anyone's fault.
- underseacables 6y agoThere’s no evidence that it’s a deliberate leak, and it’s highly doubtful we will ever learn what exactly happened, but I think it’s highly likely that this came from a Chinese lab and the apologists for China decry this line of inquiry
- SketchySeaBeast 6y agoThat's fine, but you're treating your beliefs as facts and assuming that because you find it convincing that must be the reality of the situation. I was trying to explain how that's not necessarily the case.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoWas with you until this "many on the left" nonsense. Been "left" all my life and I don't recognize myself in your comment nor do many others. It's not team sports, it's world issues.
- lordnacho 6y agoAren't all exponential processed like this? Fragile in the beginning, unstoppable past some point? I don't think we were unlucky at all. If there was a 70% chance of this petering out it doesn't take a lot of tries to get one that doesn't.
- SiempreViernes 6y agoEven if the outcome isn't particularly rare, I still think any bad outcome from a random process counts as unlucky.
- SketchySeaBeast 6y agoI suppose you're right, but if you're paying Russian Roulette with 5 out of 6 bullets loaded I'm going to be more predisposed to thinking you were playing a really stupid game. I don't consider my lottery losses every time I buy a ticket unlucky, I just consider them the expected result.
- eCa 6y agoThe 70% is my issue with the article as well. That seems to indicate a 30% chance for the pandemic that actually happened, but that seems awfully high.
- abrowne 6y agoOr, to quote Ernest Hemingway, "Gradually, then suddenly."
- JulianMorrison 6y agoNext question y'all should be thinking about: how many other fuses are smouldering right now?
- adolph 6y agoProbably most “research” labs are fuses, the smoldering part is tougher.
- Symmetry 6y agoZoonotic coronavirus infections from bats are pretty common in south east Asia when scientists have done antibody surveys of villagers. Most of those probably aren't well suited to human to human transmission. And if a virus spreads to infect everybody in a village and herd immunity is reached that's the end of that. But as commerce increases we're going to have to worry about taking more preventative measures.
- maxerickson 6y agoSeems like it wouldn't be that expensive to do routine genetic surveillance of symptomatic infections in regions of concern. And of people that work with livestock. Setting it up would be hard, and pulling the interesting data out of the firehouse would likely be hard.
- JulianMorrison 6y agoSewage sampling can look for a specific germ, and has been used to track Covid and its variants. We aren't realistically yet at a tech level where we DNA sequence everyone's minor sniffle just in case it's something new. But not too terribly far off it. There evidently already are mechanisms in place to respond to alerts of new notable breakout diseases by DNA sequencing them, that happened to Covid very early.
- maxerickson 6y agoI think we have the tech, we are just bad at figuring out how much it would be worth to spend (underestimating the value by a lot).
- illiilliiililil 6y agoThe way HN comes down so hard against the lab leak hypothesis is spooky. Opinion about this is thrown around so heavily. Credentials: NPR listener AKA elite understander of things? The tide of understanding the origin of this virus is turning as Chinese propaganda wears thin. Many of you may recieve your comeuppance and I hope you're embarassed by your sheepishness.
- Loughla 6y agoExtraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, is the problem. Animal to human transmission is a thing that exists and is known. Much less extraordinary, much more mundane, but much more plausible. Until there is extraordinary proof of your claim, and not just 'I feel it' type of arguments, I will steadfastly believe it started from a bat, as originally claimed. If you have proof of your claim, and I have missed it, please provide it. I would appreciate it.
- illiilliiililil 6y agoYou speak on the virus as if you have expertise, or have studied the subject. Yet I suspect you, and so many posters here, are mere podcast listeners. The arrogance is almost a virus in spirit.
- Loughla 6y agoNo, I don't speak as if I have expertise. I speak as someone who has been alive to experience various diseases that started from animals. I'm not being arrogant, and I don't understand your attitude. You are making an absolutely extraordinary claim. This absolutely requires extraordinary proof. Again, I would be really excited to read about any proof you have of your claims. Please link to something, I would appreciate it.
- illiilliiililil 6y agoI've never even claimed it came from a lab. I'm commenting on YOUR arrogance and YOUR vehement dismissal that it didn't. You, despite never having studied viruses, are parroting publications and podcasts by your assertion that the lab leak hypothesis is "extraordinary" in the first place. The articles are just beginning to consider a lab leak, the podcasts are just beginning to pop up seriously considering it, the former CDC director has just expressed that he thinks it was a lab leak, and WHO now considers it still on the table. Careful, you may be embarrassed down the road.
- Symmetry 6y agoI sort of think the most likely origin is that some pangolin farmer from the back end of rural Yunnan was the first host but the virus couldn't explode until someone went to bring the pangolins to market in a city with real crowds.
- adrianb 6y agoNot impossible, but how plausible is that a farmer sells his animals in a single location in a big city more than 1000 km away? More likely the animals would be sold closer to his farm or sold in multiple big cities igniting separate outbreaks with distinct lineages.
- Loughla 6y agoIn my experience, it is relatively plausible that the animals are sold in a single location, that far away. Granted, this is absolutely anecdata, but it does prove a point. My experience: For decades, my father, my grandfather, and my great grandfather sold cattle via the Chicago markets. This is a trip of around 1000 km. This also originally started when our part of the US would have been no different than a very backwater part of a developing nation. No roads, no rail, no infrastructure, really, until you got to within 400-500 km of Chicago from where we live. And yet, they moved cattle that far to one single marketplace.
- freddealmeida 6y agoI highly doubt this. Lab leak while unpopular is hard to disprove. While these fictions are easy to do so.
- curmudgeon22 6y agoI’m curious what people make of coronavirus antibodies being detected in Italy in September 2019: https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/11/coronavirus-italy-covid-19-pandemic-europe-date-antibodies-study https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/11/coronavirus-italy-cov...
- SketchySeaBeast 6y agohttps://www.livescience.com/coronavirus-circulating-italy-earlier-thought.html https://www.livescience.com/coronavirus-circulating-italy-ea... There's some good points about jumping to conclusions in this article.
- curmudgeon22 6y agoInteresting, thanks for the link. The livescience article mentions the possibility of false positives and doing different types of antibody testing to confirm, not only with potential WHO involvement. Do you know if there was any further testing? A quick search didn’t yield helpful results.
- adrianb 6y agoThe paper has earned an expression of concern regarding its peer review process, I don't think many scientists rely on it at the moment: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0300891620987756 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0300891620987756