5 ms·
It blows my mind that so much money is being spent on companies that seemingly have no road to profitability, or expect that their users will stay when they ris
by nicbou 6y ago
It blows my mind that so much money is being spent on companies that seemingly have no road to profitability, or expect that their users will stay when they rise the prices to a profitable level.
I wonder how many more mobility startups we can dump money into before accepting that it will fail like the five identical companies before it.
I always joke that my humble little website is more profitable than Uber, Airbnb, Lyft, Pinterest, Slack, Dropbox and a few other companies combined, and was so since day 1. (E: not Twitter)
Maybe I think too small, but when I divide these companies' losses by their number of users, I can't imagine how they could possibly work if they weren't sustained with massive amounts of money.
- pas 6y agoTwitter had very good years recently. (The user experience has not improved though.)
- nl 6y agoYou realise that Twitter is profitable, right? And Facebook wasn't profitable once, too.
- nicbou 6y agoHas it made up for the decade of losses? EDIT: Yes, it's apparently up ~53 million now. I replaced Twitter with 5 other giant companies that are losing money.
- virgilp 6y agoThis does show you the fallacy in your line of thinking, right? Twitter was on that list, and now it's not. In 5 years, maybe none of the companies in your list will be in it; sure you will easily find "replacements" that are just as popular/well known, but the thing is that that's exactly the model: "grow aggressively, capture the market, become profitable once you're market leader". It doesn't always work, but it's hard to dispute that it sometimes works, and when it does, it yields tremendous profits. It's not a bug, it's a feature :)
- thu2111 6y agoBut 53M is not much for a decade of business at that scale. For the size of some of these VC investments they could just put it into the market and get similar returns, I'd think?
- nl 6y agoThe VCs made their (large) returns on the share price of Twitter, not anything to do with profits Twitter made. Profits are just money a company has been unable to invest in growth.
- fakedang 6y agoTwitter hasn't captured the market, but has become only slightly profitable compared to its industry peers. Meanwhile Doordash or Deliveroo or Uber could capture entire markets, but that would rapidly make them prone to regulation or outright bans.
- adventured 6y agoFacebook is a rather extraordinarily bad example to hold up. They lost money for a short amount of time for a VC backed company - about 4 1/2 years. Asana by contrast is 13 years into losing money. Here is Facebook's early financial history (2004, 2005, 2006 all showed losses): 2007 | $153m sales | -$138m net income 2008 | $272m sales | -$56m net income 2009 | $777m sales | $229m net income 2010 | $1.97b sales | $606m net income 2011 | $3.71b sales | $1b net income By the time Facebook was 13 years old it was running at ~$16 billion profit.
- nl 6y agoSure. My point was exactly this really. Both Twitter and FB were founded at roughly the same time and went public at roughly the same time. One was a huge success, one wasn't. Asana hadn't been a big success, but Trello was. There is some luck involved here, but the VC game is about trying to find the outsized returns, not avoiding losses.
- unishark 6y agoI used to joke that I make more money selling cars than GM does. Also consider all the secondary effects as hopeless companies pay for B2B services from other companies in the chain. I think the value of ads and tracking is vastly inflated as a result of this bubble.
- nicbou 6y agoYes but GM does make money. They're not selling cars at a loss. Their moat isn't VC-subsidised cars.
- unishark 6y agoWell their moat was a government bailout. A decade or so ago they were losing billions, meaning thousands per car, given that they sell a few million cars.
- nicbou 6y agoThat's a good point. Ah the things you can do when you hold the economies of entire cities hostage.
- mywittyname 6y agoGM is still different. Automobile manufacturing is incredibly capital-intensive and it is incredibly difficult to weather reductions in demand. They still have to pay for the factories and equipment, regardless of of how many people are buying cars. They have to keep suppliers going during lean times because they can't manufacture every part they use. And they also have separation agreements with both dealerships and most workers, making it costly to reduce production capacity. It's trivial to send an auto manufacture into a financial tailspin. Frankly, it's amazing that so many manufactures have survived for this long.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]