5 ms·
> having a trustworthy and secured backend. Ubiquiti had a secured backend - their screw-up was not doing MFA on their admin accounts. I would still like if th
by judge2020 6y ago
> having a trustworthy and secured backend.
Ubiquiti had a secured backend - their screw-up was not doing MFA on their admin accounts. I would still like if there was an option for a local-only control panel.
- red_phone 6y agoFor their UniFi line, at least, you don't have to use their cloud controller. You can self-host.
- cle 6y agoThis is what I do. I host a controller in AWS on an EC2 instance in my account. It works great.
- dijit 6y agoOut of interest, why wouldn't you host it on something like a raspberry pi? Having your local network depend on an external network makes my old school sysadmin bones tingle for some reason.
- gregmac 6y agoThe Ubiquiti controller is not needed for general operation, unless you're using a guest hotspot. Otherwise if it's offline you just lose ability to do configuration and it's data/stats logging.
- julianz 6y agoIt's also needed if you want to have any control over SSID's such as enabling/disabling on a schedule, bandwidth limiting and so on.
- thrixton 6y agoHah, that's a dream world where enabling/disabling SSID's ever worked properly. They have a good UI, good hardware but the software seems half baked. Originally with the switch to the "new settings", the schedules were switched between the AP's and the UDM, not sure about a dedicated cloud controller. Great product, poor QA I think.
- cle 6y agoLaziness? I can just set it up with a couple of clicks and pay almost nothing (it runs on a t2).
- lostlogin 6y agoIs that true on the UDM-Pro? I couldn’t see an option on setup. I might try block it from internet and see what happens.
- notwedtm 6y agoYes, this is true. You can access the Unifi controller on the local internal IP.
- MobileVet 6y agoYep, I have my controller running on a Synology 720+ NAS that has zero ‘wide area network’ access. Everything is local to my home. I am deeply saddened by Ubiquiti’s fall from grace... they were so good.
- DividableMiddle 6y agoCan you go into more detail about your setup? I have 920+ and am in the market for a new router (controller? Still learning the terminology).
- hedora 6y agoThe cloud controller is a (surprisingly heavyweight) service that manages a network of unifi devices. It can run on a raspberry pi, or an x86 container / vm. If I wanted to run it all the time, I’d try putting it in a docker container on my synology. Instead, I have an sd card for my raspberry pi that has nothing but the controller installed. The main downsides to this are that it is easy to lose the sd card, and that the controller gathers bandwidth/usage/wifi connection reliability stats, but only when it is running. I don’t get those unless I boot up the RPi to diagnose some network issue (this has never been an issue in practice). One advantage of the RPi setup over a synology container is that it has both a ethernet jack and a wifi adaptor. This is surprisingly helpful when bootstrapping complicated mesh topologies.
- MobileVet 6y agoYep, I put it in a Docker container on the Synology. Fairly straight forward. I followed a guide like this: https://lazyadmin.nl/home-network/unifi-controller-on-a-synology-nas-with-docker/ https://lazyadmin.nl/home-network/unifi-controller-on-a-syno...
- katbyte 6y agoI have a UDMpro which self-hosts a controller, thou personally if i knew it couldn't be joined to another controller i'd have gotten something else so i could throw it in docker (which runs on a NUC with the storage off a synology)
- asix66 6y agoYes. I run the controller on a raspberry pi 4. Local only. I too am disappointed in UniFi’s direction. I used to recommend them. I don’t now.
- katbyte 6y agoWhat do you use/recommend now?
- asix66 6y agoGosh. I wish I knew. This thread is rife with alternatives, so other's guess is as good as mine. The unifi wifis I have running are still good and work extremely well. So my suggestion is to keep using them, but only if you host the controller software on your own hardware (I'm using RPi 4 as stated) and only if you avoid their cloud solution(s). (This IMO). I am still looking for alternatives when the time comes to replace mine. Which I'll be forced to replace once/if they completely nerf the self hosted on self hardware options.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- azernik 6y agoIf admin login is using weak credentials, it is by definition not a secure backend. Password/credential management and mandatory MFA are ALWAYS part of security due diligence for suppliers.
- uniformlyrandom 6y agoExcept if it is awscli creds, then of course there is no MFA.
- LgWoodenBadger 6y agoWhat do you mean? Awscli supports key tokens from your 2fa device if your access keys are configured to require it
- LilBytes 6y agoThis has been a concern for me for a while, but it's possible to use aws cli with mfa by throwing an IdP in front of it. The work flow we used was AWS Vault -> Okta -> short lived AWS creds.
- Quiark 6y agoExactly, no workflow for terraform or CLI if you have U2F (Yubikey) 2FA.
- Hnrobert42 6y agoI really want to like U2F, but it’s use cases seem so limited.
- darkr 6y agoIf you use federated auth, then you can do whatever you want; 10 UDF keys and a video of a special dance if you so desire
- BillinghamJ 6y agoThat's not true. You can use AWS SSO with the CLI/SDKs (therefore including stuff like Terraform) with webauthn. It briefly pops you out to a browser to authenticate and caches a short lived token locally
- katbyte 6y agoI run a local controller with no remote access for unifi - i would never use any networking hardware that needed a cloud controller/connection for breaches exactly like this.
- StreamBright 6y agoI never onboard anybody without MFA. Turning it off is a firing offense.
- krageon 6y ago> their screw-up was not doing MFA So you're saying it was both not trustworthy and not adequately secured?
- cyberlab 6y ago> their screw-up was not doing MFA on their admin accounts MFA is not a silver bullet. You can still login with stolen cookies and 'replay' the session without signing in.
- nijave 6y agoStill lots of pitfalls with just MFA. Text/email being the worst and TOTP being somewhat better but not great. A lot of password vaults support storing the TOTP secret so they can generate time based codes which seems reasonable when the vault is 2-3 factor protected (some do IP heuristics, passwords, tokens, PINs, etc). Unfortunately if someone gets access to the vault in it's unencrypted state you're in for a world of hurt. From a couple years back, https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/04/how-hacking-team-got-hacked-phineas-phisher/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/04/how-h... (the hackers got remote access to a sysadmins desktop then waited til he mounted TrueCrypt and stole the entire contents) Even with hardware tokens, if someone gets access to your machine while you're using it they can wait til you authenticate then use the creds proxying requests through your machine so they look legit
- turfyman 6y agoSame here. I don’t need remote access to manage my network. I work from home and spend a majority of my time there.