4 ms·
The contrary position is public housing. If you desire non-market rate housing, it's the only solution. Because by definition, the market will always produce m
by brudgers 6y ago
The contrary position is public housing.
If you desire non-market rate housing, it's the only solution. Because by definition, the market will always produce market rate housing.
- mjevans 6y agoAlternately, engineer the conditions of the market to achieve the desired result... rather than engineering the conditions of the market to preserve what's already been built at the cost of future (now current) generations who have no where to call home and establish value or community.
- DubiousPusher 6y agoI mostly agree but I think it's important to have perspective that things like historicity or the quality of a neighborhood can be a public good. And a democratic population might choose to invest in such a public good. Obviously it would be better though if the coat of these public goods were being paid more directly by the public and not externalized onto those living most precariously.
- imtringued 6y agoYou can have that to a certain extend. When people are saying you should build more they don't mean modern style 10 story buildings next to a single family home. They mean a duplex or triplex that fits in with the rest of the neighborhood or a 2-3 story apartment with a nice facade that is in the spirit of the neighborhood.
- DubiousPusher 6y agoUh, I think it's both. Have you been to Houston TX? Housing is cheap there for a large city. They also happen to often have 10 story buildings right up next to single family homes.
- dublinben 6y agoHouston is only a "cheap" city if you look at housing costs but not transportation costs. The ridiculous sprawl of Houston increases transportation costs so much that it is actually less affordable than "expensive" cities like New York City.[0][1] This doesn't even take into account the externalities of the higher emissions that come from living in a car-dependent place. [0] https://htaindex.cnt.org/fact-sheets/?lat=29.7604267&lng=-95.3698028&focus=place&gid=25649#fs https://htaindex.cnt.org/fact-sheets/?lat=29.7604267&lng=-95... [1] https://htaindex.cnt.org/fact-sheets/?lat=40.7127753&lng=-74.0059728&focus=place&gid=16861#fs https://htaindex.cnt.org/fact-sheets/?lat=40.7127753&lng=-74...
- DubiousPusher 6y agoI'm not making the case that Houston is a good solution to the housing problem. My whole point is that Houston is evidence of what happens when you ignore most preferential factors and just build. I've enjoyed visiting there but the city is aesthetically unappealing, feels vacant of community and yes is a nightmare to traverse.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> the quality of a neighborhood can be a public good. And a democratic population might choose to invest in such a public good. This manifests as keeping poorer people out by restricting zoning to larger plots of land and detached single family homes, which also has a nice side effect of making cars a necessity. Everyone wants to live around others at or above their own socioeconomic level.
- DubiousPusher 6y agoI agree. But the solution is not to throw out all considerations and give developers their way. There must be a way to balance the interests of those who want a neighborhood to remain a nice place to live with open space, gardens and services while also preventing Nimbys from filibustering density.
- imtringued 6y agoThe article argues for a public housing model for trailer parks. Because of the pseudo ownership model where you don't own the land but still own a house sitting on the property that is expensive to move, the operator of the trailer park can just increase rates. It's exploitative compared to the rental market. You basically lose your housing investment unless you can find another trailer park and you can afford the moving fees. Renters can just move on to the next apartment.
- Spooky23 6y agoIt’s often nastier, because the trailer is often rent to own or mortgaged by the owner. It’s a depreciating asset, so these arrangements are often exploitive, and the more slumlordy types will find ways to get liens on the trailer.
- imgabe 6y agoPublic housing has most of the same problems - poorly maintained, high crime rate.
- throwmxncj 6y agoNot if done properly. https://www.newstatesman.com/spotlight/housing/2019/09/housing-basic-human-right-vienna-model-social-housing https://www.newstatesman.com/spotlight/housing/2019/09/housi...
- DubiousPusher 6y agoI'd like to think if funded properly, public housing would improve but I'm not confident. I grew to in a trailer in a trailer park and honestly, it was good for my family. We had 3 loud, boisterous, boys living together and we needed our own four walls. I think it's fair to say subsidizing this kind of private housing might be a bit selfish. After all, why does everyone in a park get a yard when people are just trying to find a studio or a rentable room just to work in the city? But I think that's the wrong question for two reasons. 1) The choice isn't usually between dense urban developments or trailer parks. I don't even think this type of land use comes into conflict all that much. Occasionally a park is shut down to build a shopping center but most parks are at the edge of cities. They are not usually blocking density. 2) It goes beyond market rate housing. Parks are often limited or banned. Perhaps encouraging parks is manipulating the market but so is what is happening now by law.
- captainmuon 6y agoPublic housing is one option. Or you have to counter the price hikes. Prices are rising in many parts of the world because people are investing more and more money in housing, as an alternative to stocks or other investments. The expected returns mainly come from the rise in value, and not from the rent income. So the companies holding the houses must get rid of the existing tenants and renovate the appartments to increase their market value. Basically, private investments currently don't create much housing, they destroy affordable housing. So you need to create incentives to maintain and expand the affordable segment.
- lmm 6y ago> The expected returns mainly come from the rise in value, and not from the rent income. So the companies holding the houses must get rid of the existing tenants and renovate the appartments to increase their market value. Nah. Housing rises in value even if you don't touch it. Demand is rising and supply isn't. The solution is to make it easier to build more.
- brudgers 6y agoThe market prefers higher priced housing over lower priced. When there is demand for higher price housing the market builds housing. When there is not demand for higher priced housing the market tends to wait out the down cycle. The market has no preference for building unprofitable housing. Bankers don’t have enthusiasm for loaning money to build it either. Finally housing is one of the less profitable real estate development types. That’s why commercial property often sits vacant...the long term ROI from sitting out low demand is better than conversion in the present.
- lmm 6y ago> The market prefers higher priced housing over lower priced. When there is demand for higher price housing the market builds housing. When there is not demand for higher priced housing the market tends to wait out the down cycle. It's not the market, developers don't building cheap housing because regulations generally make it illegal. > The market has no preference for building unprofitable housing. Bankers don’t have enthusiasm for loaning money to build it either. Sure, but profitable isn't the same thing as expensive. "Pile 'em high, sell 'em cheap" is a perfectly valid business model that bankers and businesspeople alike are happy to follow. But when the planning rules make it so expensive to build anything at all, building expensive housing is the only way to make a profit.