3 ms·
Green investing 'is definitely not going to work’, says ex-BlackRock executive
- dredmorbius 6y ago[F]or Fancy, who now runs the digital learning non-profit Rumie in Toronto, Canada, BlackRock’s move, and the ones it has inspired, contain a fundamental flaw: the climate crisis can never be solved by today’s free markets. “It’s not because they are evil, it’s because the system is built to extract profits,” he said. Investors have a fiduciary duty to maximise returns to their clients and as long as there is money to be made in activities that contribute to global warming, no amount of rhetoric about the need for sustainable investing will change that, he believes. My view increasingly has been that until accounting of natural capital --- both resources and sinks --- changes, market mechanisms cannot deliver sustainable reform. Virtually all existing progress has come about entirely by recognising natural capital accounting, though at times indirectly. Risk, insurance, social and political resistance, internalised externalities, assuming at least partial costs of imposed (and externalised) costs.
- hakfoo 6y agoWhat interests me is that the "we must maximize shareholder profits" meme has an implicit "today". Don't you have a spectrum of fiduciary duties? Your responsibility to the day-trader is to keep the stock price high today. Your responsibility to the pension fund is to keep the company in business and viable for the next 20+ years to maximize his return. When you factor in your duty to long-term investors, suddenly a lot of strategies become viable, if not mandatory. Spending the dollar in R&D today to yield 20 tomorrow, or to ensure you aren't lapped by the upstart competitor who did spend the dollar. How do long-term stockholders make sure that the business is acting in their interest, rather than bring overruled by the "waiting for Q2 results to sell" crowd?
- Twixes 6y agoMaybe if bonuses depended on long term performance. If the bonus is contingent on the nearest quarter only, greed overrides sustainability.
- dredmorbius 6y agoExcellent point, though net present value is well established in finance.
- euroderf 6y ago"Investors have a fiduciary duty to maximise returns to their clients" - I believe this is based on a 1980s Supreme Court case in which shareholders and/or stakeholders sought to have other goals made legitimate in balance with profit maximization, but the Supreme Court shot it down and made it explicit that profit maximization may be pursued to the exclusion of other stakeholder goals.
- leoedin 6y agoThis all goes back to the fact that fossil fuels are too cheap. Their cost doesn't reflect the lifetime cost of extraction + dealing with the carbon. Much like the hidden cost of nuclear is in dealing with the waste. The only viable solution I can see is a carbon tax at source. If we taxed fossil fuel extraction and carbon intensive imports from countries which didn't tax fossil fuels, we would create the market conditions needed for green technology.
- imtringued 6y agoYeah and then the CO2 price shoots up and suddenly all your green investments are deep in the black while your fossil fuel investments are deep in the red.