10 ms·
My dad used to joke that if you wanted sneakers that were not made by child labor, your best bet was whichever manufacturer last got into trouble for it because
by aidenn0 6y ago
My dad used to joke that if you wanted sneakers that were not made by child labor, your best bet was whichever manufacturer last got into trouble for it because of all the extra scrutiny.
That this level of fatalism about immoral acts exists is a failure of society as a whole. I suspect that all of those who got rich either knowingly or being willfully ignorant about emissions cheating walked away completely unpunished. Maybe less rich than if they hadn't gotten caught, but still richer than if they hadn't cheated in the first place.
- agumonkey 6y agowe decouple too much, every company is trying to survive the market and will always cut corners even though in the end no one ever asked for children to make shoes.. it was just global fear, frustration and risk that made everybody put pressure in the wrong direction.
- 310260 6y agoHow do you mean "survive the market"? Survive as in answer to shareholders with higher profits or succumb to consumer demand for cheaper shoes? In reality it's the former and the latter is stoked through other means.
- failwhaleshark 6y agoI heard old Nike Jordans are unwearable because the soles crumble with age. Is that the case?
- lumost 6y agoit's almost impossible to effectively regulate externalities in a global economy. Local regulators are not inclined to care about products sold overseas and all products compete with the lowest common regulatory framework. All it takes for child labor to enter into the supply chain is one bad regulator and a couple levels of outsourcing. The final "complete" product becomes nearly impossible to audit.
- andrepd 6y ago> it's almost impossible to effectively regulate externalities in a global economy. It really is not. Take the EU, for instance. They have the biggest internal market in the world. They can effectively dictate many things unilaterally that companies have to comply with under pain of being locked out of a multi-trillion dollar market (and indeed they do, with things such as health and safety standards, etc.). There's nothing stopping then from properly pricing externalities of pollution for instance, or of mandating that clothes companies pass a workplace standards audit irrespective of where their factories are located. This isn't done because of lack of will.
- DFHippie 6y agoPerfection in this, as in all things, may be impossible, but here's a good faith effort to audit supply chains: https://www.verite.org/ https://www.verite.org/
- aidenn0 6y agoEven non-global economies end up diffusing the blame for poor labor practices. So many big-box stores end up in a wage-theft situation just because the upper-management sets benchmarks that are only achievable through wage-theft and then they are shocked[1] to find out that the individual store managers are committing wage theft. 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SjbPi00k_ME https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SjbPi00k_ME
- swills 6y agoFair and I mostly agree, but there are exceptions. New Balance for example makes a lot of it's shoes in the US.
- reid 6y agoYes. My last 5 sneakers were New Balance Made in USA. I believe New Balance is the last brand of USA made sneakers, so I support them whenever I can. Not all of what New Balance makes is domestic but they do have the Made in USA line available. Would love to have more options but thankfully these are quite good.
- aidenn0 6y agoMan I wish I could wear NB, but the toe-box tapers too quickly causing my big toe to rub on the side. Before I found shoes that actually fit, I wore various shoes (including NB) 1.5 sizes larger than my actual size.
- greeneggs 6y agoInstead of posting uninformed speculation, you can just Google it… > In 2017, the U.S.-based VW executive Oliver Schmidt, who oversaw emissions issues, was sentenced to seven years in prison and fined $400,000, the maximum possible under a plea deal the German national made with prosecutors after admitting to charges of conspiring to mislead U.S regulators and violate clean-air laws. The US has charged nine people, and Germany at least five, though they aren't moving quickly with the prosecutions. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-volkswagen-emissions/u-s-judge-approves-transfer-of-jailed-former-vw-executive-to-germany-idUSKCN24H367 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-volkswagen-emissions/u-s-...
- soperj 6y agoand what about the ones at literally every other company that produces diesels?
- MrApathy 6y agoMy own admittedly uninformed understanding is that there was cheating all around, but VW was by far the most flagrant. BMW and Mercedes diesels required DEF (diesel exhaust fluid), whereas VW did not. Marketing and/or executive leadership (again, as per my understanding) pushed the notion that the additive would make diesels appear to be less attractive and who wants to add a second liquid beyond fuel every few hundred miles? But weren't they all cheating? The diesels with DEF were still above the legal limits, albeit to a lesser degree than the VW's who didn't even bother with DEF because, I guess, if you're going to cheat anyway... How incorrect is my understanding?
- davedx 6y agoOur VW Sharan required DEV.
- hinkley 6y agoHow about 'rolling coal'?
- 6y ago
- alasdair_ 6y agoI always found it odd that Americans have no problem with child labor at home, so long as it’s confined to movies and entertainment. We even have special laws just to make it legal when every other form of child labor is outlawed. It’s absolutely not the same as a sweatshop, but hollywood has a long track record of ruining children’s lives for profit.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 6y agoIt might be an unusually American take, but I do think child labor is a bit easier to justify when the child is compensated with a tremendous amount of money. (When compared to the sweatshops you mentioned). From my understanding, the "special laws" put hard caps on the amount of hours that a child can work in a week, and establishes a bunch of other protections like making sure they get adequate schooling, etc. In a film with a child in a lead role, the entire movie production schedule often revolves around this hard hours limit. Perhaps a larger tragedy is children working in family businesses. Poor, legal immigrant families often put their children to work at the family restaurant, and this is legal for any number of hours.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ceilingcorner 6y agoThere are over three hundred million people the US. A sizable portion of them dislikes Hollywood.
- freeopinion 6y agoYet, as a whole they will spend over $2 billion in a single weekend at cinemas.
- Dirlewanger 6y agoThe mainstream corporate media machine doesn't cover it because they're complicit in it. You have shit like what happened to Cory Feldman on the View: that hag Barbara Walters saying "you're trying to ruin an entire industry!" when he tries to expose the horrors he and others went through.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- titzer 6y ago> Maybe less rich than if they hadn't gotten caught, but still richer than if they hadn't cheated in the first place. Which is exactly the calculation that their lawyers and executives made, more or less. You're right that it's a failure of society as a whole. A failure to make bad actors pay for negative externalities.