3 ms·
"There is a meme going around that too many programmers are wasting their careers working on meaningless software: they spend all their time trying to get peopl
by Bluestein 6y ago
"There is a meme going around that too many programmers are wasting their careers working on meaningless software: they spend all their time trying to get people to click on ads, they aren’t tackling the important stuff, and they aren’t solving the biggest problems of today. It’s as if all programmers should drop what they are doing and instead try to cure cancer, end world hunger, and generally save the world.
I’m going to call bullshit.
First of all, don’t knock ads—or, to be more accurate, don’t not knock making money. The most well intentioned company in the world can’t accomplish any of its lofty goals if it has no money, and for many companies, ads are the best way to earn that money."
- roflc0ptic 6y agoI spent like 8 months working for a company that specialized in home HVAC contracting advertisement. I'm not going to say the best minds of our generation were working on this particular problem, but still. What a fucking waste of human life. Think about this market. People need air conditioning services. They're going to get air conditioning services. The only real question is which service operators get their business. It's zero sum. Every cent spent on marketing is valuable to individual businesses, costs other businesses. Marketing and adtech are necessary as part of an arms race, but it's net loss for the world. You're just spending money on market conflict. That company has produced nothing of value: they only attempt to divert flows of money from some people to other people, entirely independent of merit or value provided.
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoSo the only businesses that should exist are the ones that already do? Like, marketing and ads have problems, but specifically Google and Facebook have helped millions of small businesses actually make a living. We ban marketing and all that goes away (well actually it just gets recycled into other approaches).
- he_is_legend 6y agoOr: gain market share by building a better product, or offering better service, or something else actually useful to the end user. Simply out-advertising your rivals using borrowed money while offering exactly the same product works to nobodys benefit.
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoHow does one discover said companies providing a better service? As an example, would Tesla be as successful without the massive PR efforts of Elon Musk? Is that marketing or something else?
- brnt 6y agoOTOH, don't reduce the ethics of the situation to "makes money? it's OK!" either.
- dr-detroit 6y agoMoney doesnt make things ethically happen it makes things actually happen
- de6u99er 6y agoThe real joke is, that advertisement costs are ultimately paid by the consumer.
- Bluestein 6y agoOn the downvotes, (and flagging, while at it ... ... might I bring attention to "rule" 42a.1 ... - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26590231 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26590231 ... as elucidated by @tomrod? :) Not as much on account of deserving upvotes, but at least on account of not deserving the flak.-