7 ms·
“The best minds of my generation are thinking how to make people click ads”
- Bluestein 6y ago"There is a meme going around that too many programmers are wasting their careers working on meaningless software: they spend all their time trying to get people to click on ads, they aren’t tackling the important stuff, and they aren’t solving the biggest problems of today. It’s as if all programmers should drop what they are doing and instead try to cure cancer, end world hunger, and generally save the world. I’m going to call bullshit. First of all, don’t knock ads—or, to be more accurate, don’t not knock making money. The most well intentioned company in the world can’t accomplish any of its lofty goals if it has no money, and for many companies, ads are the best way to earn that money."
- roflc0ptic 6y agoI spent like 8 months working for a company that specialized in home HVAC contracting advertisement. I'm not going to say the best minds of our generation were working on this particular problem, but still. What a fucking waste of human life. Think about this market. People need air conditioning services. They're going to get air conditioning services. The only real question is which service operators get their business. It's zero sum. Every cent spent on marketing is valuable to individual businesses, costs other businesses. Marketing and adtech are necessary as part of an arms race, but it's net loss for the world. You're just spending money on market conflict. That company has produced nothing of value: they only attempt to divert flows of money from some people to other people, entirely independent of merit or value provided.
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoSo the only businesses that should exist are the ones that already do? Like, marketing and ads have problems, but specifically Google and Facebook have helped millions of small businesses actually make a living. We ban marketing and all that goes away (well actually it just gets recycled into other approaches).
- he_is_legend 6y agoOr: gain market share by building a better product, or offering better service, or something else actually useful to the end user. Simply out-advertising your rivals using borrowed money while offering exactly the same product works to nobodys benefit.
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoHow does one discover said companies providing a better service? As an example, would Tesla be as successful without the massive PR efforts of Elon Musk? Is that marketing or something else?
- brnt 6y agoOTOH, don't reduce the ethics of the situation to "makes money? it's OK!" either.
- dr-detroit 6y agoMoney doesnt make things ethically happen it makes things actually happen
- de6u99er 6y agoThe real joke is, that advertisement costs are ultimately paid by the consumer.
- Bluestein 6y agoOn the downvotes, (and flagging, while at it ... ... might I bring attention to "rule" 42a.1 ... - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26590231 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26590231 ... as elucidated by @tomrod? :) Not as much on account of deserving upvotes, but at least on account of not deserving the flak.-
- Bluestein 6y ago"The best minds of my generation are thinking about how to make people click ads. That sucks." Jeff Hammerbacher
- EdwardDiego 6y agoIt was always disheartening putting my intellect to work to trying to figure out why popunders weren't working for us following the latest release of browser X, when they were still clearly working for porn sites. ...then we looked at how the porn sites were doing it, and were horrified (admittedly, with a tinge of professional respect for them having solved it), and once more, pleaded with our business managers to just give up on popunders, it's leading to devs leaving and/or developing drinking problems.
- ramphastidae 6y agoDon’t listen to this stuff. At least these companies pay fair wages. After decades of avoiding FAANGs because of misplaced idealism from quotes like this I realize that it’s no more noble to be underpaid, under appreciated and overworked at a “moral” company than to be treated with dignity at a FAANG (with dignity at this point being simply defined as a 40 hour work week and enough money for one person to buy a home in the HCOL city where the job is located, which 90% of tech jobs still don’t provide).
- dr-detroit 6y agoI got 99 problems but living in the elite regions of the country aint one. You could always skip 1 night at the bar and purchase a neighborhood of mansions in my state.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- busterarm 6y ago> At least these companies pay fair wages. All companies pay you the smallest amount that they think will keep you from leaving. Average wages being high at FAANGs is mostly a function of employees of said companies desiring a high wage and having other opportunities. If you're making less, it's either because you're not good at negotiating/selling your skills or you don't actually have better opportunities. You can work on either or both of these things. (or you're actually happy with less and working on a mission to change the world. Good on you if so.) I have not worked at a FAANG and have not had problems finding fair pay and a sensible work-life balance. I have a house that's fully paid off (and I'm single, never married) in a second-tier city's suburb and about to purchase my first rental property and I've never hit the startup equity lottery. I don't even live at the first house; I put up a relative there. I rent an apartment in NY. Still under 40, started this career in my 30s. And yes, for a very long time, my job was making people click on ads. The pay was quite good.
- freebuju 6y agoJust from a debate that is almost similar in nature. One person posed a question: would you leave a high-paying job that is in a toxic workplace? Not so many were in the affirmative. Someone even added that they would rather stick with it and remedy this with therapy later on.
- Simulacra 6y agoI don't think I've ever deliberately clicked on an ad, in fact I work very hard to block them out and ignore them.
- bamboozled 6y agoIt's funny because unless there are some Jedi mind tricks going on which made me not realize my actions, I can honestly say the same. I've never deliberately clicked an ad in decades of using the Internet.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- zesterer 6y agoThis article completely misses the point of the original quote. The original quote is not 'they could be working in better fields', it's 'the entire structural incentives of capitalism are messed up'.
- b3kart 6y agoAnd yet here on HN it's the workers themselves who are often blamed for choosing to work for these soulless tech companies while they're free to go cure cancer at some startup.
- EamonnMR 6y agoFree? Hardly. Nobody is free to do anything medical. You need to comply with a whole suite of regulations put there for patient safety. I think that's part of the allure of adtech; nobody's telling you you need to get your CLIA certificate updated to cover every new A/B test. And if you screw up, nothing bad happens. Unless you're targeting people with Bad Stuff, I guess.
- orangeoxidation 6y agoThis. The OP is fighting a straw man. The argument opposed is a critic of the system, not a broad attack on individuals.
- pjc50 6y agoPeople really struggle to cope with structural vs individual issues. TBH, I'd expect programmers to be slightly better at understanding situations where each side of a communication is doing things that it things are correct - or necessarily defensive - while the other side thinks they are wrong. Architectural issues, where there is no specific wrong line of code to point to.
- Bluestein 6y ago> not 'they could be working in better fields', it's 'the entire structural incentives of capitalism are messed up'. Can't both be true, I sincerely wonder?
- luckycharms810 6y agoI think I expected to see more of this by now given the number of incredibly liberal folks who work in Adtech. Sorry to break it to you, you don't get to wash your hands clean of it's incredibly detrimental effects on people mental health, the state of mis-information, and the creation of tooling that manipulates the way people think. Ads made money before hyper-targeting, and will continue to make money long after. Most folks in Adtech are making an incredibly comfortable living - while ignoring the collective harm that is being done by the industry. No matter where you work, it's worth asking yourself a few questions. * What is the mission of my company ? * What is the revenue generating unit of my company ? * Are the two aligned ? * Am I comfortable with the answers to the above questions ?
- ryandvm 6y agoIf there's any lesson that sums up the way the world works, it is: people follow incentives If you want folks to work on the cure for cancer or ending world hunger or curtailing climate change, then you're going to have to pay them enough to do it. The reality is that people have families, people have futures to think about, people have material desires. You can chastise them for making personal choices that prioritize their needs, but as long as a climatologist makes 1/10th of the salary of a software engineer at Google, that's not going to change. Is happiness found in wealth? Not at all. But it's like fat and sugar, we are literally programmed to acquire resources. It was just that for most of human history, it wasn't actually possible to overdo it.
- voisin 6y ago> You can chastise them for making personal choices that prioritize their needs, but as long as a climatologist makes 1/10th of the salary of a software engineer at Google, that's not going to change. The issue is not that we aren’t willing to pay a climatologist 10x more. It is that companies like Google and Amazon and Facebook can lobby to continue to externalize costs and internalize profits that allow them to retain the ability to pay a software engineer 10x more than someone working for the common good. No one votes on this. It is entrenched in a broken system that is powered by money.
- c17r 6y agoWas this posted in reaction to the Ubiquiti ad discussion on https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26628198 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26628198?
- Bluestein 6y agoIn a way.- I found the Hammerbacher quote there, and it piqued my curiosity.
- beervirus 6y agoI’m fine with ads. The problem I have is that the best minds of my generation are thinking about how to spy on me.
- Bluestein 6y ago> the best minds of my generation are thinking about how to spy on me. That is, indeed, far worse. I guess the "spying" is kind of impliied in the banality of adtech the quote deals with ...
- andersource 6y agoThe title is missing the (IMO crucial) "and that's ok" from the original post.
- jrochkind1 6y agoDefinitely reveals the people who post lengthy commentary on the article without having clicked through it, eh?
- tziki 6y agoWhy did you cut out the "and that's ok" part from the title?
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoI believe that HN has limits on how long a headline can be. I agree that the omission changes the meaning.
- sparsely 6y agoI feel like the author is really missing the point of this criticism. It's probably fine on an individual basis to work for (most) adtech companies like google. What sucks is the overall system which incentivizes the creation of arguably dangerous products and behaviours, even if by chance some of that money spills over into being spent on better causes.
- disgruntledphd2 6y ago> incentivizes the creation of arguably dangerous products and behaviours Can you supply more information about this? Are you talking about the ads or the products themselves?
- analog31 6y agoA century ago, any reasonably intelligent and diligent person could join the business world as a "clerk," organizing and arranging information in support of business operations. There was a vast workforce of clerks. They probably made decent money. Nobody lamented the loss of the best minds of their generation.
- Bluestein 6y agoWas not Einsten himself once a patent office clerk? Then again, some argue, and I see that, that the very post put them in touch with the leading ideas of his time, and gave him a way to practice and improve his abstract thinking, having to practically picture all those mechanisms and contraptions ...
- brauhaus 6y agoThe article was not at all what I expected! I agree that it's hard to gauge the usefulness of applying the best minds to do banal work. After all that the work of making people click on ads is what allowed Google to benefit the world with stuff like Google Maps. But it also created a monopoly: for every Google Maps, there's a Waze left in its wake. What's truly disheartening about this mercenary culture is not that one can't predict the usefulness of making people click on ads, but that there are so many other tasks which are patently more useful - but whose sponsors have drastically smaller pockets than a FAANG. I'm not talking about lofty projects, like curing cancer and flying to Mars. I'm talking about banal stuff that, at some point of another, affects everyone's. Like trying to navigate a government's website.
- Bluestein 6y ago> there are so many other tasks which are patently more useful - but whose sponsors have drastically smaller pockets than a FAANG. A pity, actually.-
- prepend 6y agoIt’s funny how we seem to be going meta on ads, and I think it could be good to refocus attention on things that produce better value. Ads are powerful, but I think they maximize on value to the seller at the expense of the buyer. Many of the big problems we’ve had have a lot of responsibility on ads, I think: cigarettes, opioids, political action committees, mass consumerism in general, sugar/diabetes, pharmaceutical prices, etc etc. I think many of these crises are made possible or at least worse through ads that change people’s perception to move them toward more negative behavior. I think this is like the urban legend of hypnosis in that you can’t make people do what they don’t want to, but you can shift just a few percent and that still makes tons of money. Drinking cokes every day, eating fast food every day, “talking to your doctor about Foo drug,” the list goes on and on. People like doing this stuff so making them do more by showing ads is just a function of ad spend.
- freebuju 6y agoBlaming ads for people's choices isn't fair nor is it any accurate due to how simplistic this attribution is. Remove the ads of out the equation and people will still go for that Pepsi. That's what they want.
- prepend 6y agoI don’t think ads are solely to blame, but they influence behavior. Without ads people will still drink Pepsi, but with ads, they drink more.
- offtop5 6y agoThere's a quote, which I absolutely can't find the source for, it's something like geniuses are toiling away in factories. I think it's a bit arrogant to think you're some type of genius who if only you needn't work, would be able to solve all the world's problems. I'm more than fine with being a cog in the machine, with my dream being retirement at 40. After that I'll work on my music, and video games full time.
- II2II 6y ago> That is, they are building software for their own personal amusement or financial gain instead of working for the benefit of us all. Writing software for their own personal amusement or financial gain is perfectly acceptable. Advertising is perfectly acceptable. The part of that crosses the line is "thinking how to make people click ads" since it violates people's autonomy. It is used to rationalise crossing other ethical boundaries ranging from respecting people's desire for privacy to outright psychological manipulation.
- FiatLuxDave 6y agoTax ads. Put the money into important stuff. People shouldn't be faulted for taking a high paying job if that is where the opportunities are for them. But we do have a system which is generating outcomes most people aren't happy with. So the rules should change. Maybe just a little at a time. Our choices aren't only "Ban ads" or "Keep doing advertising the way we are doing it now". This isn't an A/B test. A small tax on advertising would be a good place to start.
- Bluestein 6y ago> A small tax on advertising would be a good place to start. That's a thought ...
- freediver 6y agoThis has actually been discussed by a nobel-prize winner in economics: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/06/opinion/tax-facebook-google.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/06/opinion/tax-facebook-goog... and some states are already following suit: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/12/technology/maryland-digital-ads-tax.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/12/technology/maryland-digit...
- sharemywin 6y agoHow many small niche businesses have been created around hyper targeted ads? I don't know why everyone wants to go back to a million ads for mortgages and feminine hygiene products.