28 ms·
The uninvited Internet of things
- duncan-donuts 6y agoI used to be really into protecting my privacy online. These days I’ve mostly just accepted there’s pretty much nothing I can do short of disconnecting entirely. I’m not even sure why a smart faucet would be appealing to any consumer. I feel like I’ve just accepted that we lost. I don’t see how we’ll ever get rid of mass surveillance. If we couldn’t get rid of the patriot act after Snowden’s whistleblowing, and we can get consumer privacy/protection now I’m not sure how we’ll ever get it. Maybe I’m just burnt out and cynical, but I don’t see why the government or corporations have any incentive to let people do anything without them knowing about it.
- sep_field 6y agoSocialism is the way.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- betwixthewires 6y agoWe haven't lost. But we are losing. I have reasonable privacy online. None of my devices connect to google, except if I explicitly do so, which I do from time to time for a reason or other. None of my devices are even capable of connecting to Facebook owned domains, I have them DNS blocked. JS off by default for all sites, no social media (except this site and one more that I run myself). I don't own a TV or any smart appliance whatsoever. No google assistant, siri, Alexa. None of that. I buy things on Amazon. They know where I live and what I buy from them. They cannot show me ads because I let nobody show me ads. All in all some people probably get some info about me, but the info collected on me is probably along the lines of what they were capable of getting in 2005. And good luck stitching it all together. You can do a lot short of disconnecting. But you have to disconnect from the strip mall "internet". You can't wait on laws, because you're right, they have no incentive. You're the only one that does, so you have to do something about it, in your own life, for yourself.
- sodality2 6y agoYou say reasonable, but that's more than 95% of what "privacy advocates" do and I'd say that's a serious level of privacy. I do most of the things you do as well, so I'm not calling you a radical, but that's not really reasonable; that's way more than most people, even "privacy conscious" ones.
- betwixthewires 6y agoYeah, I know, but once you have it set up it isn't any more work. And it is a serious level of privacy (and it isn't the entire extent of my setup either) but if some alphabet soup agency wanted to find me they probably could. It's really just to protect me from data collectors and ad agencies and stuff online. When a lot of people say "it is just too hard" what they mean to say is "I want to use services that track me." For most people, only turning on JS for web apps and not using malware as a service is all it really takes.
- simion314 6y ago>None of my devices are even capable of connecting to Facebook owned domains, I have them DNS blocked. Can't malicious application work around your DNS block? Is there a way to be 100% sure say all Facebook/Google is blocked? I am not a networking guy so maybe the future is to whitelist IPs/domains for each device and application.
- chopin 6y agoYou could hardcode IP-addresses. Or use DoH for DNS resolution.
- betwixthewires 6y agoI'm not sure about this actually. I would assume that an application could connect to a DNS server directly and request an IP for a specific domain and then navigate directly. I don't believe I have any applications on any devices that do that, but it is possible.
- denismi 6y ago> I’m not even sure why a smart faucet would be appealing to any consumer Very quickly off the top of my head I could imagine: - measuring out the appropriate volume for the teapot and delivering at the ideal brewing temperature for the particular tea - knowing that one family member likes drinking water ice-cold while another prefers near-room-temperature - recognising that it's about to pour onto hands and reducing the temperature to below scalding - choosing from various sources (tap, filtered, recycled storm-water) depending on use-case, to optimise supply costs, filtration costs, environmental impact etc. It's annoying (from a privacy and security perspective) how 'smart'-ening even the most innocuous things can be quite appealing to the end-user, and how nasty (again, from a privacy and security perspective) the implementations that make it to market end up being.
- notriddle 6y agoI’d be happy about typing the liquid volume into a keypad and just having that much water come out.
- betwixthewires 6y agoDid they stop making measuring cups or something?
- notriddle 6y agoOf course not. They also didn't stop making discrete timers, but I still appreciate having one built into a microwave oven.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dhosek 6y agoI'd be happy with our hands-free faucet in the kitchen being able to adjust the temperature without going under the sink to twist a fiddly knob where the water is connected.
- 6y ago
- ehnto 6y agoI am by no means a luddite, and hope to enjoy the fruits of civilization and society for as long as it will let me. But I have started picking up a bunch of skills in order to maintain and build anew, devices and tools that will no doubt become unnecessarily bloated in the future. I already have some rudimentary electronics skill, so it's mostly been metalworking, such as welding and machining. I have a 3D printer as well, I'm not against PLA for replacement plastic parts and not against using technology I have full control over as a means to my ends. Don't need to buy a smart faucet if I can build my own very ordinary faucet.
- nicbou 6y agoI haven't given up, because the fight still pays off. I just don't treat it as an all-or-nothing struggle. Privacy is a side-effect of addressing other concerns. I use uBlock because the internet sucks without it. I delete old accounts to avoid data breeches. I avoid IoT because it's finicky and has a shorter lifespan. I compartmentalise my online life to keep the internet hate machine at bay. I don't use Facebook or LinkedIn because I don't enjoy it. I don't give my contact information because I don't want to be contacted. All those privacy-oriented actions have other tangible benefits. I see privacy like eating fruit and getting exercise. It's good hygiene, and even a half-assed effort is better than nothing.
- ByteJockey 6y agoFor what it's worth, the patriot act did expire last March. Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patriot_Act#Reauthorizations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patriot_Act#Reauthorizations
- coupdejarnac 6y agoSuppose I want to design an IoT device with security in mind. How would I best go about doing that? I've been looking for a good source for best practices, but most of what I've seen so far is hand-wavy or Amazon-centric.
- ryandrake 6y agoHere’s how I’d approach it: Step 1: Decide whether you actually need network connectivity for the main use case of whatever you are building. The answer will usually be no. Step 2: If the answer to step 1 was YES, then now decide if you need Internet access for the device’s main use case. The answer will almost always be no. Step 3: If the answer so both of the above was YES, finally decide if your device’s main use case requires you to build a server-side service, too. If the answer is NO, plan on investing a lot in security professionals. If the answer is YES (I’d be shocked), plan on spending an enormous amount on security professionals. Then listen to those professionals.
- coupdejarnac 6y agoI appreciate the input, but device and backend are nearly complete. I'm looking for concrete examples of how other people manage x509 certs.
- banana_giraffe 6y agoGenerally it involves some answer that doesn't wait till the device and backend are nearly complete. Security shouldn't be the last step of your equation. Snark aside, there are lots of white papers on x509 provision of devices, including IoT devices. Go read them.
- Igelau 6y agoBuilt the product. No idea about best practices. Didn't read the white papers. Security built at the last minute by asking strangers on the Internet. IoT security/privacy concerns in a nutshell.
- marshmallow_12 6y agothe solution must be mercilessly strict laws and enforcement. I won't elaborate on it. Some imagination will help.
- duncan-donuts 6y agoI agree with you but it’ll take a serious new wave of policy makers for it to happen.
- kubanczyk 6y agoThe current wave of policy makers (in EU) agreed on GDPR. IoT looks like a straightforward extension of that.
- kubanczyk 6y agoThank you. We need more messages like yours, short and sweet. "We need laws for $problem" is something that can succeed in a democracy. Beating the bush around one's pet peeves or detailing what one deems an optimal policy is fine, except it often waters down that basic message for 99% readers, when only 1% will be somehow informed/enlightened.
- brian-armstrong 6y agoThe radios will need some kind of receiver in order to send (handshaking with the cell network and the data server). You could probably expose it to very high EMF on the frequency in question, which can often permanently damage radio receivers. The might be the easiest way, no device opening required. Disclaimer: Poster is not responsible for any damage caused by this approach. Do not violate FCC laws. Always use a Faraday cage for experimental transmissions.
- fuckyouriotshit 6y agoA second (or fraction of a second, depending on how long it takes for the magnetron to get up to full power) in a microwave works wonders on radios that can't be disabled or removed. You don't want to give it any longer than that though because it might cause physical evidence of damage (arcing on PCBs, ICs with holes in them, etc.). Or so I've heard.
- pavel_lishin 6y agoIt's probably somewhat difficult to microwave a radio that cannot be removed without microwaving the rest of the device, no?
- fuckyouriotshit 6y agoYes, but that may not matter if the total duration is kept very low. Many IoT-type radios use the same 2.4Ghz band as domestic microwaves and will be destroyed in a fraction of a second as the radio's AFE (analogue front end) is hit by many many orders of magnitude more energy than they're designed to tolerate. I would wager that many devices that don't have other significant "energy-catching" features (antennas, radios, coils for NFC, etc.) would work just fine after experiencing a short stint in a microwave. I did actually test this once on a very old 3G modem/radio interface and I found that every part of the interface seemed to function just fine, except that it could no longer receive any radio signals (and may have been unable to transmit but I couldn't confirm this with a spectrum analyser). The modem otherwise operated just fine and would talk to the SIM, operate all its LEDs and even seemed to pass an internal self-test feature that it had, with the obvious exception that it could no longer find any radio towers. I obviously can't guarantee that your stuff won't blow up, so don't come blaming me when your device ends up being trashed by microwave energy going through unintended parts.
- boring_twenties 6y agoThe article casually and dismissively mentions living inside a Faraday cage... but can we entertain this notion for a moment? If one is already building a new house from scratch, it would seem trivial to make the whole thing a Faraday cage while you're at it, no? Am I missing something? Retrofitting an existing house would be harder, but still doable if one is committed to the cause, like a couple thousand bucks tops? (Guessing here.) It doesn't seem that one would have to give up ANY actually desired functionality. Wired internet piercing the cage is not an issue, right? After that you can just have your own secured wifi inside. If one is okay with using VoIP for voice calls, the problem is now solved, yes? Add a second AP outside if you also need Wifi in the backyard or whatever.
- thatcat 6y agofaraday windows seem kinda weird though, I guess not any worse than a window with a screen. https://hollandshielding.com/High-performance-Faraday-cage-windows https://hollandshielding.com/High-performance-Faraday-cage-w...
- boring_twenties 6y agoI guess you would actually want a separate screen, so you could open your windows and still enjoy the protection of the Faraday cage. Still though, so far so good, I think?
- Shared404 6y agoIsn't the point of the screen that you leave it closed to keep bug's out? Or is that just in my bug-infested homeland?
- boring_twenties 6y agoRight, you would want to have a screen that stays closed at all times, even if the window is open. The windows pictured seem to have the cage wires inside the glass.
- ARandomerDude 6y agoSimple solution for the smart TV for now: don't connect it to your network. At this point I'm not aware of any TVs that come with cellular radios. That said, I recently returned a soundbar after discovering it couldn't be used without app-based onboarding. Ridiculous.
- mrweasel 6y agoTV are a perfect example as to way I believe the free market has failed. Normally you’d expect one or two TV makers to have noticed a growing concern regarding smart-tvs and started to cater to that part of the market. I understand that those of us who would pay a premium for a dumb TV are a minority, but it seems like there’s enough of us to justify at least a few models. The assumption that I would want to control everything from my phone is getting out of hand.
- neolog 6y agoYou can get a 'commercial display' but they're pretty expensive.
- mrweasel 6y agoYeah, I looked at those last time I replaced my TV. You also need to be able to locate a reseller who will sell to private individuals, which can be difficult in some location.
- danparsonson 6y agoI suspect the real problem there is that consumer devices are sold at or below cost and the data they send home makes up for the lost revenue.
- PeterisP 6y agoThe parent poster was explicitly mentioning those willing to pay a premium. If people aren't willing to pay a premium for a niche product, that's explicitly telling the market that this niche shouldn't exist as a separate niche and the cheaper mass-market solution will do just fine.
- SubiculumCode 6y agoWhy faraday your whole.house when you can just faraday your toaster. The designer toaster-day covering will make your kitchen the toast of the town.
- masswerk 6y agoThis suggests an entire new industry, Faradayed Internet of Things Shells (FIoTS): for any device, get your bespoke faraday shell casing from a wide array of third-party vendors…
- detaro 6y agoThese are already a thing for WLAN-routers for the electrosmog people. Which is of course the one place where they don't make sense, but would probably work for similarly-sized appliances.
- mixologic 6y agoDespite being a nerd from way back that had a 2400 baud modem in my c64, I have avoided IOT devices as long as possible, precisely for the reasons that the author describes (privacy, security, and failure to distinguish between service or object). However, sometimes it becomes unavoidable. After a recent diagnosis with sleep apnea, I got a cpap machine, which has a cellular network connection in it, which connects to a centralized service where the sleep technicians can tune the device to deliver the right pressure for my sleeping patterns. What it also did was allow my insurance company to know how much I was using the device, in order to decide whether it was going to pay for it or not. So, I really don't see how I could have avoided this IOT device and received treatment. On the other hand, no hacker is going to be able to compromise my network via this device, so maybe this truly is a better path forward for IOT devices?
- core-questions 6y ago> On the other hand, no hacker is going to be able to compromise my network via this device, so maybe this truly is a better path forward for IOT devices? But on the other hand, your network has already been compromised, in the sense that you have a connected device within your home that you cannot control at all, that connects to the internet as long as it has power and can do whatever it is programmed to do... Maybe for a sleep apnea machine this isn't catastrophic, but consider this Ubiquiti hack that's in the news; it wouldn't surprise me if the security situation around medical stuff isn't any better than with a networking company, after all. Me, I want to control what's connected in my house. At least a little.
- dukeyukey 6y agoI think they meant it connects via a cellular network rather than wifi, so even if it were compromised it couldn't do anything to devices on the internal network. So security breaches are limited to the one device, and doesn't provide an opening to other devices.
- wolfgang42 6y agoI got my machine from a local company that does the monitoring and configuration by mailing an SD card back and forth. I suspect my sleep patterns still end up in a database somewhere but at least it’s not real-time. The insurance company will also be a lot less antsy about monitoring if you buy the machine out-of-pocket, which brings up another issue with pervasive IOT: opting out is, if even possible, more expensive, making it potentially yet another modern method of class striation.
- olivermarks 6y agoAdd your car to the list of uninvited internet of things
- teddyh 6y agohttps://twitter.com/_jakegroves/status/1374872023596417024 https://twitter.com/_jakegroves/status/1374872023596417024 https://twitter.com/_jakegroves/status/1375002783103995904 https://twitter.com/_jakegroves/status/1375002783103995904
- switch007 6y agoThat's a "feature" - high beam assist sucks. IMO the root cause of all these stupid safety/assist features is people not paying attention: Lane keep: because you're on your phone Collision detection/auto brake: because you're on your phone High Beam Assist: because you're on your phone Adaptive Cruise Control: so you can be on your phone Auto Headlights: because turning on your headlights means putting down your phone/coffee cup. I've only ever been annoyed by Collision Detection/High Beam Assist/Lane Keep/Auto headlights. They do the wrong thing at the wrong time.
- olivermarks 6y agoDRM in a vehicle is not good for the owner on so many levels. The whole concept of owning a car outright and being allowed and able to maintain it if you choose has already been effectively ended by complexity, lack of shop manuals and legal 'don't remove the plastic engine cover or you'll void the warranty' restrictions was the first wave. Now we have cars transmitting gigabytes of information back and forth to the vendor and who knows who. IMO we should have consumer legislation protecting owners from this razor and blades model the vendors are trying to force through: you buy the car then we sell you endless 'features' and upgrades which will ultimately render the car inoperable unless you. Cars used to be cheap and repairable. Now they are expensive, have a short lifecycle and are becoming infested with endless digital do dads $£ upgrade.
- frongpik 6y agoOne semi-secret feature of IoT is that wooden walls are almost transparent to the microwave / wifi radiation, so it can be used to effectively see thru walls.
- m463 6y ago5G will not help, in fact the reverse. It gives low-cost wifi-like connectivity/relay ability to iot devices, so they can gather data without pesky "onboarding friction"
- sriku 6y agoI think X10 should really push their products with the privacy preservation agenda - https://www.x10.com https://www.x10.com Connected remote controllable devices are useful, but letting them access the net is intolerable. X10 is a decent compromise as long as they promise not to internet their devices.
- _carbyau_ 6y agoThe tinfoil hatters may be the real MVPs. I foresee origami practice with aluminium foil over known radio-containing parts in my future. Regarding Smart TV's, is there an OpenWRT-like project for TVs yet?
- thendrill 6y agoI have also been looking for "custom firmwares" or "roms" for TVs. Sadly to no fruitful success. As I understand it. Nobody bothers since there are som many different versions of TVs ( even same model different region) that hacking and developing new os would just never catch up. So instead people opt out of smart TVs and instead buy "digital signage screens" basically a dum TV....
- _carbyau_ 6y agoMaybe we need an Open LCD panel controller board. Install the firmware with specs as per TV panel. Swap out the control board altogether.
- Nextgrid 6y agoTVs are very similar to Android phones (in fact some of them do run Android) and so have the same challenges when it comes to creating and maintaining alternative firmware.
- thayne 6y agoI recently purchased a new wireless router and ran into this same issue. It is now surprisingly difficult to find a consumer-grade wifi router that doesn't phone home. And disconnecting your router from the internet isn't really an option...
- oever 6y agoYou can flash the router or use hostapd on a linux machine to make a wireless router. A router that analyses the packets and allow- or blocklists packets based on features would be useful.
- KozmoNau7 6y agoThat's not really consumer grade, though. Not something your average mom and dad can go buy at Best Buy and have working without external assistance. Flashed TP-Link routers, hostapd on a NUC-style PC, Mikrotik, even Ubiquiti Unifi are what I would consider way beyond general consumer level. The userfriendliness just isn't there.
- thayne 6y agobesides the fact that that requires a lot of technical expertise and voids the warrantee, from my experience hardware that is even compatible with open source firmware like openwrt is much harder to find and can be more expensive.
- phil_aut 6y agoI'm wondering if GDPR would cover this. Is buying the device already an act of consent to the collection of data?
- Nextgrid 6y agoThe GDPR is not being enforced seriously. There are plenty of violations already out there (including from big companies such as Google or Facebook) and nothing serious is being done about it.
- mdpopescu 6y agoHuh. Would it be possible for someone to hijack the SIM card in such a device and use it to get free calls all over the world, including long-distance? Would that be illegal? Would anyone care? :)
- thendrill 6y agoUsually eSIM cards are data only.
- mdpopescu 6y agoEh, unlimited data plans might still be valuable to someone.
- tzs 6y agoYes, yes, and yes. There was a case in the news a few years or so ago where someone did that with the SIM that was in their electric meter, which was used once a day by the electric company to send a report of cumulative usage. What they did not count on was that many cellular carriers have data plans specifically for devices like that electric meter that just need to send a very small amount of data every hour or day or so. Those plans have a very small monthly fixed fee, a small data allowance, and astronomical overage fees. Typical data allowances for the cheapest plans are maybe 50 KB, which is plenty for sending "<meter-id> <timestamp> <cumulative kWh> <checksum>" once a day. The person used the SIM for their calls and data, including downloading a bunch of movies. They ended up incurring around $150k overage charges. The electric company cared very much, and the person ended up with a short jail sentence.
- chovybizzass 6y agogood luck driving a modern vehicle w/o any of that.
- bumbledraven 6y ago> One of those possibilities [of the widespread connectivity to IoT devices] is certainly connectivity that is now completely outside of the control of the "owner" of these devices... By putting a cellular modem and SIM directly in a device... it will be able to report home whether the "owner" wants it to or not. The vendor will retain control and will be able to, for example, disable the device at will. This an aspect of the increasing separation between “owner[ship]” and control that was predicted by James Burnham in his 1941 book The Managerial Revolution. (https://www.oxfordreference.com/view/10.1093/oi/authority.20110803100129835 https://www.oxfordreference.com/view/10.1093/oi/authority.20...)
- matheusmoreira 6y agoIt has transcended corporations and is now permeating all of society. Our devices are or will be managed by corporations and governments. As users of these devices, this management naturally extends to our entire lives. I hope at some point it becomes too oppressive for people to tolerate... Only way to see any real change.
- bsenftner 6y agoHaving worked as a code developing MBA consultant in the IoT space, I have banned any IoT and any WIFI requiring devices in my home. The security practices in IoT are simply nonexistent and often completely absent. I use ethernet at home, and have no issues at all with a complete lack of any "smart (snitch) devices". Horror of horrors, I have to walk up to a screen, operate the mouse, physically select things and make them go. My voice is so jealous.
- aceazzameen 6y agoI'd like to do this, but currently in a rental and have to use WiFi. I do use an Android smart TV and have a security camera outside. But both those devices are connected to a separate WiFi/router on a separate subnet. Hopefully my PC is safe from Android/IoT if they get hacked. Of course, anything can happen on the PC too! But at least I can monitor it better. Once the kids get older, all that goes out the window. They'll become the security hole. Haha.
- rauhl 6y agoA decent-quality MP3 is 96 kbps; that means that it would take a little over 30 terabytes to store an entire lifetime’s worth of audio, or under 4 terabytes to store a decade’s worth (assuming I got the math right). At today’s prices that’s less than $500 to store a lifetime’s worth of audio, less than $50 to store a decade’s. Does anyone doubt that an unethical company could make well over $5/year from storing and analysing every second of audio spoken within earshot of its devices?
- detaro 6y agoDepends, how unethical do you want to get? (e.g. do you include "blackmail" in the options to monetize audio?)
- rossdavidh 6y agoSo, it would seem that we have an opportunity for a niche appliance maker: the "dumb appliance" market. I think the issue is that most of the purchases are determined by price and features (that I want), rather than an absence of features I don't want. But you could probably build a decent amount of brand loyalty with a "dumb appliance" selling point. However, because you would have no data to sell, you would have to actually sell the item itself for a price that would be sufficient to make a profit.
- matthewfelgate 6y agoThanks for sharing. Because I'm so engrossed in the IoT world I never really thought of the ability to opt out of connected devices. Especially if devices use cellular (hard to opt out) instead of Wifi (Easier to opt out). I disagree with the author because I think there are legitimate reasons for devices to connect to networks. For example Tesla cars can get better over time. TVs can do updates to fix bugs and new functionality. But the down side is the opportunity of spying and monitoring the user. For example what happens if your Washing Machine stopped working because a bad manufacturer decided to stop it over cellular?