5 ms·
Free as in Climbing: Open Data Project Threatened by Bogus Copyright Claims
- kevin_b_er 6y agoWe are now in an era where copyright laws do not promote the progress of the science and the arts. They merely serve as protectionism from competition and criticism.
- ta988 6y agoAnd patents do the same. Especially software patents. As we are producing faster we should also reduce drastically the lifetime and coverage of copyrights and patents.
- breck 6y ago> we should also reduce drastically the lifetime and coverage of copyrights and patents. Agreed. And when you do the math you realize the ideal length === 0.
- Judgmentality 6y ago> And when you do the math you realize the ideal length === 0. Do you honestly believe this? I agree the patent system is broken, but I'm not convinced we should completely abolish it. I am speaking broadly though and not just for software. For software I could see patents as long as a few years making sense, and shorter would be fine. 18 months seems about right as a benchmark to me. A much simpler solution to the patent system is you have to pay exponentially more to keep it as time goes on. This would also solve copyright issues, specifically for Disney and other megacorporations. I realize there is no magic bullet to this, but I actually think the patent system has merit and is worth fixing rather than demolishing.
- musingsole 6y agoI'm very exhausted with trying to treat ideas as property. I'll accept it got us here and appreciate it for that, but it's a broken model that requires massive orchestration to keep in reality. I want something different (and better...though that's the hard part).
- breck 6y ago> Do you honestly believe this? There's nothing I honestly believe in more. #ImaginaryPropertyLaws are a *total* sham. The dramatic expansions [0] in 1976 and 1998 have proven it beyond a reasonable doubt with nothing to show for it except massively increasing inequality [a]. The news? Hasn't improved at all, arguably gotten worse. Pick up a NYTimes from 1871 and compare it to one from today [1]. Today's have color photos, other than that, worse compared to 150 years ago. Scientific papers? Terrible. Look at the reproducibility crisis. Now Elsevier and Wiley and American Chemical Society are suing India to prevent poor kids from accessing SciHub. [2] Medicine? Watson, Crick and Franklin did their famous work in 1953. The healthspan in the USA is *decreasing* [3]. That opioid crisis? Ultimately attributable to USPTO [4]. War on cancer? Started in 1970 and we've gotten our *ass kicked* [5]. The only positive developments have been the massive grunt work public domain research projects funded by US and global taxpayers. Space travel and electric cars? Completely fcking plateaud until Elon Musk came out and said fck patents and kicked everyone's ass [6]. How about computing? Absolutely dominated by TCP/IP, the web, Linux, Git; all public domain or libre software. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Term_Extension_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Term_Extension_Act [a] https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/dgJmaIkwy4Xb9CACHYp_J4j18TI=/1400x1050/filters:format(png)/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/11839467/Screen_Shot_2018_07_29_at_10.27.09_AM.png https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/dgJmaIkwy4Xb9CACHYp_J4j18TI=... [1] https://www.amazon.com/York-Times-Complete-Front-Pages/dp/0762466596 https://www.amazon.com/York-Times-Complete-Front-Pages/dp/07... [2] https://torrentfreak.com/sci-hub-libgen-face-isp-blocking-in-india-after-publishers-file-high-court-complaint-201227/ https://torrentfreak.com/sci-hub-libgen-face-isp-blocking-in... [3] https://apps.who.int/gho/data/view.main.HALEXv https://apps.who.int/gho/data/view.main.HALEXv [4] https://longbets.org/855/ https://longbets.org/855/ [5] https://www.cancer.gov/about-nci/overview/history/national-cancer-act-1971 https://www.cancer.gov/about-nci/overview/history/national-c... [6] https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20150217/06182930052/elon-musk-clarifies-that-teslas-patents-really-are-free-investor-absolutely-freaks-out.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20150217/06182930052/elon-...
- varispeed 6y agoIf only patents covered genuine inventions. If you look at what's getting approved these days, I don't think anyone competent is working in the patent office.
- hklgny 6y agoI mean the guy scraped their site and created a competitor. If I add content to a site, I’m for sure not transitioning ownership to them, but I’m also not giving everyone else in the world permission to take it and use it anywhere they want.
- spacemanmatt 6y agoLegal precedent suggests you are probably granting the public access to take it and use it any way they want. Via https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HiQ_Labs_v._LinkedIn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HiQ_Labs_v._LinkedIn > Ultimately, the Ninth Circuit's affirmation of the district court's grant of the preliminary injunction prohibited LinkedIn from denying hiQ access to publicly available data on public LinkedIn users' profiles.
- MereInterest 6y agoAlso, a dataset itself is not a creative work and is not entitled to copyright protections. The particular presentation of a dataset may be, but not the dataset itself. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feist_Publications,_Inc.,_v._Rural_Telephone_Service_Co https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feist_Publications,_Inc.,_v._R....
- hklgny 6y agoFascinating, thanks to you both for the links. I’m wondering why companies like Yelp and the realtor association have been so effective at maintaining data ownership if this is the case.
- pessimizer 6y agoMassive efforts using obfuscation, spurious lawsuits, lobbying, and buying up competitors. Only speaking about the NAR, but as a past insider. The NAR only exists because of lobbying to create laws at the state and local that institutionalize themselves as the only legitimate real estate agents, or over-specify the qualifications for being a real estate agent until they are only satisfiable by being a member of the NAR. If all fails, access to MLSes prevents any rebellions below a certain size - the vast majority of Realtors® make no money, and losing MLS access is not an option. In order to create your own MLS, you'd have to pull an Aaron Swartz and get away with it before being cut off (which is probably the main reason why MLSes are a federation rather than a single system), or slightly more realistically get a bunch of no-money making Realtors® on your side and pull an Alexandra Elbakyan with their credentials. The problem with the latter would be that the listings turn over a lot more often than scholarly papers, and you'd have to deal with de-listing.
- mhuffman 6y agoYeah, I don't know if you have been watching Disney's moves for the last few decades, but we have been at that place for a while now!
- bilalq 6y agoWoah, MountainProject is a owned by REI. I wouldn't have expected this from them.
- scrose 6y agoI was just skimming through things, but it looks like MP and REI might have parted ways last year: https://rockandice.com/climbing-news/mountain-project-and-rei-split-new-mp-partnership-to-be-announced-soon/ https://rockandice.com/climbing-news/mountain-project-and-re...
- wtallis 6y agoMountain Project's About page includes this bit: > In 2015, REI acquired Mountain Project to solidify the future of this amazing resource for the climbing community. Every line of code was redone from ground zero and traffic skyrocketed. In 2020, REI returned Mountain Project to its founders. And the site footer links to Adventure Projects, Inc. It looks like REI hasn't been involved since May 2020, and Adventure Projects was acquired by onX in December 2020.
- glong64 6y agoIt's a pity that the EFF has lost its credibility last week by participating in a witch hunt against RMS.
- browningstreet 6y agoNot sure 100% adherence to an individual's particular political positions is the way to measure the worth and value of an organization. I love and support the ACLU and disagree strongly with some of their positions.
- b215826 6y ago> Not sure 100% adherence to an individual's particular political positions is the way to measure the worth and value of an organization. No one is asking the EFF to agree with everything RMS says. However it's quite ironical that the EFF deviated from its stated goal of protecting free speech [1] on the Internet and joined the lynch mob trying to cancel RMS. This does cast the EFF in a negative light since now there's speech that the EFF likes and speech they don't. As long as there's such a dichotomy, it's hard to take an organization claiming to defend free speech seriously. [1] https://www.eff.org/issues/free-speech https://www.eff.org/issues/free-speech
- breck 6y agoI wasn't a fan of their approach to that issue, but still strongly support the EFF. I do wish they would take a more principled stand against #ImaginaryProperty, but someone recently explained to me, and I concur, that people should incorporate 10 or even 100 new non-profits to do that as #EFF has a big portfolio and shouldn't be expected to do everything. If anyone out there forms new orgs to work toward #IntellectualFreedom and #EndingIp, please drop me a line and let me know what you need!
- jstanley 6y agoIf you think it's unreasonable for people to blanket-denounce RMS based on the content of 1 or 2 of his opinions, then you might want to consider whether or not it is reasonable to blanket-denounce the EFF based on 1 or 2 of theirs.
- ryannevius 6y agoI've been using Mountain Project for over a decade now. The site made a turn for the worse when it was acquired by REI, and then improved again when REI decided it wasn't worth it for them and handed ownership back over to the founder. onX has now owned Mountain Project since January, so this is likely originating with them.
- dan-robertson 6y agoIt seems to happen quite often that online communities spring up when one person happens to start a forum or wiki (and/or write a custom website) around their hobby. Usually it becomes popular by being first/better/through random chance. But then these online communities grow while the site is still owned and run by whoever founded it and it seems not great to have basically a random unelected dictator running it. There can be other problems too, e.g. popular websites can be expensive to run, especially if you have a lot of images. It often seems to play out in one of a few ways: - the owner continues running the site benevolently and never gets bored or dies. Maybe the site runs ads or has a donate button for funding the site. - some company offers the owner a large amount of money for the site. The owner is happy to get paid and not need to manage the site anymore. The company will try to extract that money out of the community through unpleasant commercialisation while not caring much about the community itself. Likely includes a redesign and potentially deleting a load of old content because it doesn’t fit the new database schema. Needless to say the original community might not like this but the owning company will probably be trying to bring in more new visitors and won’t care. - some very relevant company buys the site. E.g. a car manufacturer buying a forum of owners of their cars. This is similar to the above but the company will likely care more about the community and less about monetisation. However moderation may change and posts critical of the new owners may mysteriously disappear. - some similar company (eg a magazine about the same topic) buys the community. This would probably be somewhere between the two above. The magazine wants to turn a profit but they hopefully care about the community too. - some company or charity already representing some of the community acquires the site. For example in this case it could be a big national climbing or mountaineering club. How well this goes probably depends a lot on the company. E.g. if they are also selling guidebooks, they might not like it if the community risks reducing their sales. If the club just run eg huts or offer a life insurance policy or safety training or instructor certification it might be different. And maybe the club will care about their own members more than the acquired community. - the owner helps set up some small foundation to control the site. This feels like it could go well and likely to have the interests of the site aligned with those of its users. But funding the site could still be a challenge. And the board in control is likely to be made up of the kind of people who want positions on boards, which might not lead to the best results. Perhaps one model of funding involves having relevant companies (eg gear manufacturers who want to encourage people to go climbing and therefore want to buy gear) pay to sponsor the site and in return get someone to sit on the board though this feels like it has some risks too. I quite like the last (and first) option but it doesn’t seem like a natural path from starting a site to setting up a foundation whereas it seems quite easy to accept an offer from some company who want to buy your website.
- pabs3 6y agoI wonder if any of the OpenBeta/etc data is in OpenStreetMap.
- steve_gh 6y agoAs a UKian, I'm not sure that the intellectual property landscape is the same over here as it is in the USA. I don't know much about MountainProject (beyond going to their website). But I am a rock climber and Alpinist, and I contribute to a UK equivelent of MountainProject, UK Climbing, as moderator for a couple of crags - I basically act as an editor to ensure user-supplied information is correct. While UKClimbing is owned and run by a commercial entity [Rockfax], there is a huge community and a lot of goodwill. I have to say that from what I have read, openBeta appears not to be acting fairly. As far as I am aware, they have scraped the MountainProject website, and are now presenting the data without any attribution. Did they even ask MountainProect whether it would be OK to use their data? For me, I contribute to a community, and I am happy and glad that people find what I do useful. But I'd be well p*ssed off if some internet random started scraping the data without asking, and without engaging with the community.