5 ms·
> The cleanup costs of ONE uranium mine alone could buy Germany enough solar to replace 3 nuclear reactors. Germany needs nuclear for base load. The current al
by oblio 6y ago
> The cleanup costs of ONE uranium mine alone could buy Germany enough solar to replace 3 nuclear reactors.
Germany needs nuclear for base load. The current alternatives for base load are natural gas (meh, but maybe not horrible) and coal (horribly dirty, and Germany transitioned from nuclear to coal [!!!], making their energy mix dirtier than the French one, as France still uses a ton of nuclear power plants).
Solar can't be used for base load at the moment.
- j-pb 6y agoYeah but wind and solar on a european power grid can. A nuclear power plant that's finished in 10 years is not gonna provide you with the baseload to stop climate change. That's only possible with expanding the existing tech we have.
- kergonath 6y agoBut gas-fired power plants will? We won’t stop climate change, we’re decades late. What we need is everything we ca have, which includes solar and wind where appropriate, but also nuclear. The fact that people pretending to care about climate change are pushing for gas is absurd.
- tpmx 6y agoI was writing a comment on how hard/impossible it is to get politicians to understand the fundamentals of what makes an electric grid work - then I saw the other comments here and despaired. It's like all the people who didn't understand grade 7-9 physics conspired to make us all miserable.
- oblio 6y agoIs it grade 7-9 physics, though? I learned about power grid structure (base load, etc.) and such at the university. To the down voters: just because you learn about electricity in secondary school, it doesn't mean that the second or third level effects are obvious and that you immediately understand what their impact on a power grid is. But hey, maybe some people were super interested in power grids or just super gifted ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- tpmx 6y agoYou're not wrong, but I honestly think most don't really even understand the difference between power and energy. If you don't understand that, trying to explain base load is an uphill battle.
- Gwypaas 6y agoEither way, in almost every online discussion I see the term base load is used in the wrong context. Base load exists on the consumer side, as the minimum power the grid needs to operate during a cycle of X hours/days/weeks/years/whatever. It used to exist on the producer side since the cheapest power plants were also inflexible regarding ramping their power up and down coupled with high fixed costs and low marginal costs. Therefore, nuclear and coal was termed as base load providers, although it was purely an economical coupling leading to a term existing. Nowadays with renewables undercutting everything they are the new base load providers, but it also brings new challenges for adapting the grids and consumers to more variability in the supply. This is our current world were the high fixed, low marginal cost power plant is pushed out of the market, as we are currently seeing globally. This is unless they can find a way to get their prices below renewables, but that is getting more and more unlikely with the steam cycle itself soon adding more to the KW/h cost than an entire renewable operation.
- oblio 6y agoBase load exists on the consumer side and unless energy storage ramps up 1000-10000x across the world, I don't see how solar and wind could ever cover it until then. Human power usage patterns don't change that much because we don't change much. You need to be able to provide X energy at all times, no ifs and buts. Actually, there is one thing, we need super capable and reliable super long distance power grid connections, maybe there's some progress on this front? Because solar and wind absolutely are unreliable on a local front.
- Gwypaas 6y agoWith HVDC and UHVDC lines there are progress on the transmission front. The main question though is the economical race between geographically decoupling your renewable power supply versus storage, this is something we will see play out in the next 10-15 years. China recently finished a 3300 km UHVDC line from Xinjiang to the east coast with an expected loss of 1.5% per 1000 km.
- fulafel 6y agoBase load is just a made up convention though closely related to traditional fixed rate prices, and may become increasingly fictional in the future as demand adapts to more variable supply and dynamic pricing.
- tpmx 6y ago> Base load is just a made up convention. Seriously.
- fulafel 6y agoOk, bad wording. How about: It emerges from conventional fixed supply. In any case it's no law of nature. So not a concept that is necessarily relevant in the furure.
- oblio 6y agoBase load results from demand, not from supply. You positively, absolutely must provide a certain amount of power at all times. > In any case it's no law of nature. Yes it is. It's a law of human nature :-)
- fulafel 6y agoThe relationship of supply and demand in the grid is an equation, if they don't match you get blackouts or other funky things. When you have dynamic pricing, variable supply works out, as nobody is obligated to produce any fixed amount of power. Yeah,base load still exists as in the dictionary definition (floor of aggregate power supply and demand), but it ceases to be a fixed level that is a hard production quota.
- stale2002 6y ago> When you have dynamic pricing, variable supply works out, as nobody is obligated to produce any fixed amount of power. No, thats not really how it works out. Baseload should actually be called baseload demand. The idea of baseload demand, is that there is some minimum level of electricity, that will always be demanded, almost no matter how high prices go. Or, in other words, there is some about electricity demand is very inelastic. So no, you can't just increase electricity costs. Because then electricity costs will massively spike, and cause huge amounts of problems. You are massively underestimating the amount of problems and costs that it would put in people for demand to be as elastic as you want it to be. It would be way cheaper and better for everyone, if there was simply enough baseload supply to meet the baseload demand.