3 ms·
> There's a 3-hour period here that's extremely uncomfortable. Three hours during fog of war with conflicting and unreliable reports when nobody really knows a
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> There's a 3-hour period here that's extremely uncomfortable.
Three hours during fog of war with conflicting and unreliable reports when nobody really knows anything.
This is, incidentally, the problem with politicizing everything. You have politicians claiming they're about to be murdered, despite not even being in the same building. Then a President from the other party has to be concerned he's being goaded into sending national guard that he controls into the capitol in order to bolster a coup narrative. Which is what would have happened if he did that.
But now the executive not sending the military into the legislature is condemned all the same.
- tw04 6y ago> Three hours during fog of war with conflicting and unreliable reports when nobody really knows anything. Nobody knew anything? The capital breach was literally being live-streamed. We knew exactly what was happening. If you didn’t know what was happening it’s because you chose to intentionally ignore what was happening.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoBeing livestreamed by a hundred different people. How do you watch three hundred hours of video in three hours? What if the subset you watch at random isn't half as bad as what the media will stitch together a month later?
- tw04 6y agoAssuming you bothered to look at any tech site or remotely reputable news sight, it was quite easy. There were literally hundreds of thousands of people watching video simultaneously and posting the important stuff to twitter, reddit, HERE, cnn, fox, pick your major network of choice that wasn't RT or OANN or insert far-right "news" network. I'm not sure what country you're from, but here in America there was no amount of "stitching together" that would make me believe storming the capital in order to prevent the peaceful transition of power was anything other than sedition. By definition.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Assuming you bothered to look at any tech site or remotely reputable news sight, it was quite easy. Third hand reports and context-free edits from opinionated partisans prior to adversarial examination. This is not a source of reliable information. > I'm not sure what country you're from, but here in America there was no amount of "stitching together" that would make me believe storming the capital in order to prevent the peaceful transition of power was anything other than sedition. By definition. Sedition basically means crime against the government. Throwing a shoe at George W. Bush is sedition. So that's a motte and bailey word. It implies an attempt to overthrow the government but with a word that also still applies to breaking a window in the capitol building. Then if the coup narrative disintegrates they can fall back on no, no, it was still technically sedition. Insurrection. But that's cheating your way out of the hard question, which is what actually happened. It's convenient if all you want is othering the perpetrators to justify tribal warfare, but tribal warfare is bad. And the problem with the coup narrative is that it's incoherent. There is no logical sequence of events where storming the capitol leads to an undemocratic transition of power. It doesn't work that way. That road doesn't go there. And for the same reason it makes no sense for Trump to have ordered or desired that. So then what the heck was it? A riot. Not a plan, despite whatever social media posts people try to retcon into a unified motive or an organizational structure. Undirected anger. Pissed off jackasses who smashed. Which is illegal. They're in jail. You don't do it that way. But a riot is a sign that something is wrong, and Donald Trump was more symptom than cause. When your choices are the establishment or Donald Trump and like half the country chooses Donald Trump, what does that say about the establishment? There is a deeper lesson here than orange man bad.
- dragontamer 6y agoIts 2:30pm. Nansi Pelosi under her authority as the ultimate leader of the DC Capitol Police, is on the telephone asking for help. She tells you that the Capitol Police are overrun and that Senator's and House Member's lives are in danger. She's asking that you deploy the DC National Guard. What do you do? I start the clock at Nansi Pelosi's telephone call to the DoD for a reason. That's when shit got real and the DoD got eye-witness and high-authority pleas for help. Even if they somehow weren't looking at the news at the time, Nansi Pelosi's phone call is a turning point in the entire situation.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoNancy Pelosi is a politician. Politicians have no credibility. The default assumption is that everything they say, especially anything they know is being recorded, is hyperbole for political advantage. Something about the boy who cried wolf.
- dragontamer 6y agoThe Capitol Police Chief, House Sergent at Arms, and Senate Sergent at Arms are also there, providing details about what and where things were actually breached. They were needed for more tactical purposes (how many men to send? Where to send the men? Where to expect support first?). But if you don't trust Pelosi, there's plenty of Police there who had more detailed information. There was no issue in intelligence during the 12:30 to 5pm period. Everyone knew what was going on. The only question was why did decisions take so long to be made?
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> The Capitol Police Chief, House Sergent at Arms, and Senate Sergent at Arms are also there, providing details about what and where things were actually breached. But now you're making the opposite point -- that Pelosi's request was redundant because the same information was available to the executive who may have come to a different conclusion, e.g. because they hadn't breached any room where legislators were. Or because he was going to try other tactics first that were less likely to lead to a firefight, like asking them to leave the building, which he did. (Twitter then took down the video of him making the request to leave, which I might not have believed if I hadn't seen it happen.)