4 ms·
> Look, Trump was a jackass, but this isn't factual at all. Why didn't Trump offer military support at 2:30pm, when the Capitol was breached? There's a 3-hour
by dragontamer 6y ago
> Look, Trump was a jackass, but this isn't factual at all.
Why didn't Trump offer military support at 2:30pm, when the Capitol was breached?
There's a 3-hour period here that's extremely uncomfortable. Wrestle with that 3-hour period between 2pm and 5pm, and come to your own conclusions. But facts be facts.
In contrast: Once the DoD refused to support Pelosi, she called the Governor of Maryland to send in the Maryland National Guard. Governor Hogan refused: because that is tantamount to invasion unless they had DoD approval. Governor Hogan sent the troops in as soon as DoD approval was granted at 5pm.
We know what the holdup was. These discussions are public and documented and timestamped.
-------------
The one group in charge of defense: the Department of Defense (who is in charge of securing territories of the USA), watched on the sidelines between 12pm and 5pm before deciding to help. That's the facts. Maybe waiting was the right choice at 12pm or 1pm (when the hope was that the protesters would go away), but by 2:30pm, shots were fired and blood was spilled.
And don't be naive. We all know that both Proud Boys and Oath Keepers explicitly try to recruit military members into their group. That whole "Defend your Oath after you leave the military" thing plays pretty strongly with military members.
- ganoushoreilly 6y agoBecause he doesn't have the authority to. Just like he couldn't just send in troops during the riots. It had to be National Guard, authorized by the governors. EDIT: I'd also like to point out to anyone reading that OP consistently edits and amends their original post after responses are made, which changes the narrative and or representation of information.
- dragontamer 6y ago> It had to be National Guard, authorized by the governors. Who is in charge of the DC National Guard? Who has no governor? Spoiler alert: DoD / Trump. Seriously, look at the org-chart.
- ganoushoreilly 6y agoNO in fact the President ultimately controls the D.C. National Guard, to writ the presidents office Delegates the task for Request to the D.C. Mayor.. Whom did have National guard out before doing basic stuff on the street managing flow of traffic. It was a miss management of the D.C. Guard, and a failure to activate any other Guard Units ahead of time (because everyone said they didn't want them). So maybe you're looking at the wrong org chart.
- dragontamer 6y agohttps://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/why-dcs-mayor-should-have-authority-over-dc-national-guard https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/why-... > Of these, only the D.C. National Guard (DCNG) is never under local control. Instead, under § 49-409 of the D.C. Code—which was enacted by Congress and predates the creation of D.C.’s local government—the president is at all times the DCNG’s commander-in-chief. DC Mayor has no authority for the DC National Guard. None at all. DC is a territory, it doesn't have the same rights as other locations. Its completely subservient to the President / Congress. > It was a miss management of the D.C. Guard Absolutely. Trump should have sent in the DC Guard at 2:30pm.
- ganoushoreilly 6y agoThe mayor said no, they followed her request. You're really out to find a boogie man in just one person aren't you?
- dragontamer 6y agoThe Mayor has no say in the DC National Guard. The Mayor is almost completely irrelevant to this discussion. The Mayor isn't even in charge of security at the Capitol Building. DC Capitol Police are in charge of that, and they were absolutely asking for help / backup by 2:30pm. Literally Nansi Pelosi (ultimate authority of the DC Capitol Police) was on the phone asking for help at that time. > You're really out to find a boogie man in just one person aren't you? Just the boogieman who delayed help between the hours of 12:30 and 5pm on January 6th. And yes, I do believe we all should be interested in that timeframe.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tw04 6y agoYou understand DC is a territory and not a state. It has no Governor and the President controls deployment of the national guard there. Right? https://www.infobloom.com/does-washington-dc-have-a-governor-senators-and-representatives.htm https://www.infobloom.com/does-washington-dc-have-a-governor... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/District_of_Columbia_National_Guard https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/District_of_Columbia_Nationa...
- ganoushoreilly 6y agoYes, and I addressed it in my comment below. D.C. Itself has a small Contingency of Guard personnel. The majority of troops in D.C. were augmented from nearby states like VA, MD, etc. all of which required additional authorizations from their states to mobilize. I also assume it's understood that active duty and reserves could not be mobilized, there for the complete nature of it relied on support from state Guard Units.
- dragontamer 6y agoHogan mobilized the Maryland National Guard very early, and awaited authorization from DC National Guard. https://www.militarytimes.com/news/your-military/2021/01/08/maryland-governor-describes-delayed-permission-to-send-national-guard/ https://www.militarytimes.com/news/your-military/2021/01/08/... > The District of Columbia submitted a direct request for help, Hogan said, and he immediately mobilized state police and the National Guard. However, Hogan said the state was repeatedly denied approval. > Hogan said he was in the middle of a videoconference with the Japanese ambassador to the United States when his chief of staff came in to tell him that “the U.S. Capitol was under attack.” Hogan said he immediately excused himself from the videoconference and convened an emergency meeting to mobilize state troopers and the National Guard. --------------- > “He was yelling across the room to Schumer who, and they were back and forth saying, ‘We do have the authorization,’ and I’m saying: ‘I’m telling you, we do not have the authorization.’” ------------ Said approval would not come until 5pm, when the Secretary of Defense Miller finally authorized the DC National Guard (which then proceeded to authorized Maryland National Guard).
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> There's a 3-hour period here that's extremely uncomfortable. Three hours during fog of war with conflicting and unreliable reports when nobody really knows anything. This is, incidentally, the problem with politicizing everything. You have politicians claiming they're about to be murdered, despite not even being in the same building. Then a President from the other party has to be concerned he's being goaded into sending national guard that he controls into the capitol in order to bolster a coup narrative. Which is what would have happened if he did that. But now the executive not sending the military into the legislature is condemned all the same.
- tw04 6y ago> Three hours during fog of war with conflicting and unreliable reports when nobody really knows anything. Nobody knew anything? The capital breach was literally being live-streamed. We knew exactly what was happening. If you didn’t know what was happening it’s because you chose to intentionally ignore what was happening.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoBeing livestreamed by a hundred different people. How do you watch three hundred hours of video in three hours? What if the subset you watch at random isn't half as bad as what the media will stitch together a month later?
- tw04 6y agoAssuming you bothered to look at any tech site or remotely reputable news sight, it was quite easy. There were literally hundreds of thousands of people watching video simultaneously and posting the important stuff to twitter, reddit, HERE, cnn, fox, pick your major network of choice that wasn't RT or OANN or insert far-right "news" network. I'm not sure what country you're from, but here in America there was no amount of "stitching together" that would make me believe storming the capital in order to prevent the peaceful transition of power was anything other than sedition. By definition.
- EricE 6y ago>Why didn't Trump offer military support at 2:30pm, when the Capitol was breached? As others said because he doesn't have the authority to? Why did Nancy Pelosi deny requests for the national guard ahead of time? Funny how those questions are never asked. And to be clear I have no love lost for either party. They are for themselves and all left/right/liberal/conservative does for them is keep us arguing amongst ourselves and not paying attention to the way both establishment oligarchies line their pockets at our expense. If you think either political party sincerely has your best interest at heart you are a damn fool. Ignorance truly is bliss.
- dragontamer 6y agohttps://code.dccouncil.us/dc/council/code/sections/49-409.html https://code.dccouncil.us/dc/council/code/sections/49-409.ht... Read the law. Now that we have the law here, I ask you who the commander and chief of the DC National Guard is.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> > >Why didn't Trump offer military support at 2:30pm, when the Capitol was breached? > As others said because he doesn't have the authority to? This is false. Not only does he have the authority to offer such support to local authority anywhere in the US in response to an insurgency against local authority (10 USC § 251), but he’s also, because D.C. is a federal district that lacks command of its own national guard, the applicable local authority with regard to D.C. (D.C. Code § 49-409), and, on top of that, even if D.C. were a state he would still have paramount authority to decide on military intervention independent of any local decision because he has unilateral authority and duty to determine the need to use military force anywhere in the US in response to an insurrection, and to act unilaterally on such determination, under the Insurrection Act (see 10 USC §§ 253, 254.) > Why did Nancy Pelosi deny requests for the national guard ahead of time? Nancy Pelosi has no operational authority over any portion of the military, including the D.C. or any other National Guard.