7 ms·
Open source sits alongside Free Software. Free Software as defined by the FSF is software that respects the users freedom. Freedom to use, copy, modify... They
by phkahler 6y ago
Open source sits alongside Free Software. Free Software as defined by the FSF is software that respects the users freedom. Freedom to use, copy, modify... They do say you can charge for it, but never claim it's a good business strategy.
Consulting. Services. Education. Those seem like words that might let you make money. You can attach "open source" to those words but it obviously doesnt stand on it's own as a business model.
- varispeed 6y agoThe big problem is that there is no distinction between an individual user, SME or a big corporation. The create grounds for exploitation of software developers, social divide and other unintended consequences. The promotion of open source by big corporations is cheaper in the long run that spending money on R&D, salaries, taxes as there is always going to be a good enough project for such corporation to appropriate and make money off of, without having to pay anything to contributors.
- bartread 6y ago> Consulting. Services. Education. Those seem like words that might let you make money. And that's cool but to a very great degree these often boil down to an exchange of time for money (unless by services you mean SaaS which is really just a product business with a different revenue model). You can make a living but you're on a treadmill that you can't ever really afford to get off of, and it doesn't really scale other than by adding more people. I mean it's OK, don't get me wrong - it's certainly better than a kick in the balls - and you can make a decent living from it. But I don't find it particularly appealing: I'd much rather be involved in creating products that you can sell over and over again. And, if what you've created is of value to others, why shouldn't you charge them a fee to use it? (Btw, I'd also add paid support to your list but, again, I wouldn't want to build a business heavily based around providing support because support can really wear you down - or at least it can really wear me down. It's absolutely necessary, but not something I find at all enjoyable.)
- jstanley 6y ago> And, if what you've created is of value to others, why shouldn't you charge them a fee to use it? You can, but you probably won't succeed if it's open source, because people can share it around freely without your consent.
- amelius 6y agoThere is a middle way: license your software so that big players with more than (say) $1M revenue will have to pay for the development of the software, while the small guy can use the free version. > because people can share it around freely without your consent. The nice thing about this approach is that big players like FAANG can't really get around it. But it doesn't matter since your software is probably already a bargain for them (all these big companies are essentially built on open source).
- mids_hn 6y agoAnother approach is a source-available license. The one I'm interested in would be one, where viewing, modifying, recompiling the source is allowed, but redistribution is allowed only to those who had bought the license from all owners of the source and it's modifications. It would produce a nice "waterfall" effect. It wouldn't be open-source nor free software, but most people don't really need limitless redistribution, and the source would be proof that said software isn't malicious.
- jiofih 6y agoAka commercial software. Nothing wrong with it indeed! Just don’t package it with a weird “open” license and pretend it’s OSS. You can dual license if needed and deal with the consequences.
- xiphias2 6y agoThe real treadmill is the current monetary system. Even if you make a product, but revenue doesn't grow at least 15-20% YoY (the rate of money printing last year), its value is shrinking over time.
- 6y ago