9 ms·
Parler users furious that site sent violent posts to FBI ahead of Capitol riot
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoThe deplatforming of Trump was Parler’s big break. The coordinated effort to remove Parler from the internet (which we know from this post was based on false accusations), as enough to sap the steam and steal the moment. A clear lesson for free-speech alternative platforms in the future. When our technical overseers decide it’s time for you to go, they’ll show you the door quickly. A strong counter argument to “Just start your own twitter!”
- krapp 6y ago>(which we know from this post was based on false accusations) How do we know that? Nothing in the article makes any such claim, much less provides evidence to substantiate it, and neither does the Wall Street Journal article it links to[0]. If anything, quotes from Parler users referring to being "ratted out" as well as reactions to this very article from sites elsewhere (which can be found with a simple Google search,) suggest the accusations were accurate. [0]https://www.wsj.com/articles/parler-says-it-informed-fbi-of-violent-content-before-capitol-riot-11616702400 https://www.wsj.com/articles/parler-says-it-informed-fbi-of-...
- unloco 6y agopeople just don't understand what free speech really means. If you make terroristic threats, you're going to get in trouble. It's analogous to incognito mode. People completely misunderstand its purpose. They think it means they are sneaking around the internet protected with no consequences for their actions. In reality, "the internet" logs everything you're doing, only your personal browser doesnt. lol
- krapp 6y agoThey probably didn't care because they assumed they would all be pardoned after Trump took over.
- jliptzin 6y agoIn that scenario there wouldn’t even be a need for him to issue pardons
- dragontamer 6y agoTrump was still President for a few weeks after January 6th. A lot of the capital invaders thought that Trump would pardon them, win or lose. You can see it from their court cases.
- jliptzin 6y agoBy “take over” the grandparent post means Trump would have become our dictator for life, no pardon would be issued because they would never be charged with a crime.
- CharlesW 6y agoFor the naysayers, a "trump pardon capitol rioters" search will illustrate that this is exactly what many (most?) capitol rioters assumed.
- luxuryballs 6y agoI’m not convinced they even thought that far ahead, most people were just following the crowd. What is suspicious is the people who lead the way, some even carrying zip tie handcuffs. If they thought ahead enough to bring those, what were they even thinking? It’s suspicious because it makes no sense at all, yet is a perfect prop for the cameras. Then the letter of specific orders from the DC mayor to explicitly not request any security assistance, and the Capitol police that let people right in, all despite that we now know they knew months in advance of what was possible. Then, after the “smoke cleared” the Senate resumes, and with perfectly written speeches referencing the invasion, and with the proceedings and Congressional debate on election integrity being conveniently shifted to 1-2 in the morning, when few were watching. If anybody in the Senate was truly intending on contesting any result, the Capitol invasion wouldn’t have changed their mind, if anything it should have strengthened their resolve to do audits once they saw how much distrust there actually was. Instead they did the opposite and it was a bi-partisan effort. Meanwhile Twitter deleted the President’s calls for peace and condemnation of law breakers, suspended his account, and started mass suspending other accounts, while the media spun the tale that Trump had incited the crowd to violence, even using photos of people climbing walls and balconies to claim they were infiltrating when really it was just the easiest way to get up to where their friends were hanging out because the crowd was too dense to find a way around and use stairs. So much is wrong with how things were portrayed that it’s at best a major deception of opportunity, and at worst, which after seeing the blatant lies during the impeachment trial, was just a big media operation to smear Trump on the way out and further spin the narrative to keep him or other outsiders from attempting to get involved in DC politics ever again. Later in the Senate that evening Mitt Romney said something I’ll never forget: “an audit won’t satisfy the people, only telling them the truth will” despite the fact that even he didn’t know the truth because both parties agreed that they did not want to set the precedent to actually look under the hood, even though audits in a mere 4 counties would have settled the matter. From then until now the great purge has continued, with any questioning of election integrity or election officials being called dangerous for democracy, when in reality I can’t think of something more dangerous for democracy than not being able to question and probe at election integrity. They continue to this day to reinforce the narrative that public trust in the election system is election integrity rather than the actual integrity of the election system itself! And because of the intense hatred for Trump drummed up by the media for the past half decade, people are energetically supporting this idea. People who believe they care about democracy more than anything, duped into thinking that caring about it means dogmatically avoiding any kind of scrutiny or accountability. It’s one of the most terrifying social phenomenon I’ve witnessed in my entire life.
- zpeti 6y agoSo if the FBI knew about the threat, why weren't more precautions in place against rioting?
- dragontamer 6y agoBecause the DoD under Trump refused to provide support until 5pm. EDIT: Remember: DC is a TERRITORY, not a state. Which means its security comes under the command of the *President*, who wasn't exactly keen on stopping the riot. EDIT2: Remember the timeline: 12:30pm was around when the fence-line was breached. Capitol was breached by 2:30. DoD approving and sending support around 5pm is way late by any metric. Its clear that the executive branch was dragging their feet on the issue. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_2021_storming_of_the_United_States_Capitol#Wednesday,_January_6 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_2021_storming_... > 5:08 p.m.: Army senior leaders relay to Major General Walker the Secretary of Defense's permission to deploy the DCNG to the Capitol.[55]
- redis_mlc 6y agoNo, Pelosi was in charge of Capitol security: "Pelosi does have authority over the sergeant at arms’ office, but Irving rejected the request without consulting House leadership, according to multiple reports published in mid-January. Hammill also denied that Pelosi’s office was ever made aware of requests for the National Guard on Jan. 6. A spokesman for Irving has said that Irving did not consult with Pelosi." https://www.fresnobee.com/news/california/article249315725.html https://www.fresnobee.com/news/california/article249315725.h...
- ganoushoreilly 6y agoLook, Trump was a jackass, but this isn't factual at all. Both the National Guard and various individuals (Sergeant at arms, Capital Police Chief) asked for and or offered help. Each side was met with denial "due to optics". On the capital side the CPC asked the SAM numerous times and the SAM was ordered to not make the request (though the SAM himself wanted too). Who is in charge of the sam? Nancy Pelosi as Speaker of the House. Both Political parties are full of old lying cronies that are doing nothing but stoking the fires of discord by lying and blaming the other party. The Capital Riots were a failure from all parties involved and no where has anyone asserted Trump refused to provide support. EDIT: https://www.npr.org/2021/01/11/955548910/ex-capitol-police-chief-rebuffs-claims-national-guard-was-never-called-during-ri https://www.npr.org/2021/01/11/955548910/ex-capitol-police-c...
- 0goel0 6y ago> One user wrote: "To confirm, you are calling for an investigation into big tech collusion while you are colluding with the FBI against your platform members?" Another user wrote: "This is NOT an example of a free speech platform. Parler is a fraud." There it is. What these users want is not free speech, but rather no consequences.
- wussboy 6y agoYour last sentence really clarifies much of the thinking I’ve been doing over the last few years. When people say they want free speech what they usually mean is that they want consequence-free speech. edit: I am not talking about the strict legal definition of free speech. I agree it's important that the government cannot punish people for the things they say. What I'm saying is that people want to be free of all consequence for the things they say. They want to shout the n-word at a large black man and not get punched. They want to advocate for paedophilia on Twitter and not get fired from their job. They want to be a jerk and not be ostracized by friends and family.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoThat is literally what free speech is. The ability to express a political opinion without punishment or retaliation. Because punishment or retaliation is censorship. If you disagree with someone you prove them wrong in public instead of trying to get them fired or silenced. That's free speech. Now, planning an act of violence is not expressing a political opinion. The people who think they don't go to jail for that are idiots. But that's the users, not the company, and if you want to shut down Parler for that then why is Facebook still there?
- Digory 6y agoYes, university tenure is also a demand for “consequence—free speech.” I guess academic freedom was a bad idea.
- trident5000 6y agoI think big tech has egg on their face for quite some time from this one. I dont care about Parler but it was clearly a political ban to appease the new party in power. Theres a lot of evidence coordination took place on Facebook and Twitter to a higher extent, and it would be absurd to say this type of stuff is not on those platforms in general. People are not going to forget this from an anti-trust perspective and how much power these companies really have to ban competition and have total control over markets.
- Causality1 6y agoYep. Parler was and is a cesspit but all evidence indicates Facebook, not Parler, was the central platform for the insurrection. Parler was just the highlights reel.
- brundolf 6y ago> it was clearly a political ban to appease the new party in power I don't see it that way at all. I think these companies' PR is just constantly hanging off of whatever 51% of the country wants to see them do. When the riot happened, public opinion on Parler getting limited/kicked off the internet tipped from just under 50% to just over 50%, and every major corporation to whom it was relevant was watching. It doesn't matter whether more planning happened on Facebook, because that's not the way the public felt about it. I think it's really that simple. Of course it's still a problem that a handful of companies have so much power and reach. Tyranny of the majority is a thing [1]. But I see no need to invoke conspiracy. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyranny_of_the_majority https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyranny_of_the_majority
- darksaints 6y agoSeems all the right wing psychopaths are chomping at the bit to move to Trump's new platform. I really hope Trump chooses Accenture to build it.
- freebuju 6y agoNot supporting Parler's ideals or anything but if HN leaked my ip address to the FBeye (and the FBeye later informed me of this) I'd be equally pissed. I'd be doubly pissed off if HN snitched on themselves about this disclosure. Anyway, probably not the best idea to join mainstream social media and call for mass violence or some other insane BS. Especially not on any of the American owned ones. These are just honeypots in disguise for the government.
- seoaeu 6y agoI'm struggling to think of any situation in which someone would actually want to be reported to the FBI. Doesn't mean that reporting them isn't the right thing to do.
- klyrs 6y agoHave you considered maybe... not broadcasting evidence of a crime on a public forum? Or -- if it's not nominally "public" but it's still not e2ee -- you know that's a trust fall on unknown and possibly unwilling co-conspirators, right? It's okay to be pissed, those are your feelings, but this is basic opsec, people. For crap's sake
- freebuju 6y agothe word opsec is a foreign concept for the average Joe. A good 95% of the audience who throng such places. Doesn't matter who gave out my ip or metadata. I'd be pissed anyway. Even if my data wasn't leaked, what ever happened to the f#ck the pōlice code within our society... Someone sitting down and thinking how they can make the FBI's work of hunting down civilians like them easier. Something seriously wrong with these new generation of netizens.
- klyrs 6y ago> the word opsec is a foreign concept for the average Joe. A good 95% of the audience who throng such places. Clearly. Who'd have thought that publicly conspiring to overthrow the government would have negative consequences? Not those schmucks, I guess. > Something seriously wrong with these new generation of netizens. Well, we've got politicians on both sides clamoring to "fix" section 230. This wasn't just any old netizens, it was Parler. Sounds like they realized that their necks were seriously on the line because of their users' extremely ill-advised behavior, and snitched in hope of leniency.
- chroem- 6y agoIt's a very odd paradigm that we have in the US right now. To commemorate MLK Jr. Day, the CTO of the large company at which I work, sent out an email advocating for more political violence to promote racial justice issues, along with some circa-1960's quotes on the need for political violence. And this came only a couple weeks after the CTO spent a great deal of time decrying the capitol riot. EDIT: It was done through adding emphasis to certain portions of Dr. King's "Letter From Birmingham Jail". In bold font: > who is more devoted to "order" than to justice; who prefers a negative peace which is the absence of tension to a positive peace
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ganoushoreilly 6y agoIt's hypocrisy all around. Let us kill racism by splitting people up into groups. Lets relegate people to certain groups based on some sort of factor, hmm, maybe skin color? Yeah that's cool because that's not racist. It's the same as the lack of admittance that the Capital Riot and a Year of riots around the US were all horrible. One did billions in damage to the US for months, the other a few broken windows and doors. Yet we're supposed to be mad that one group did something stupid, but respect the other because, they had an emotional right to it. How about everyone that participated in rioting regardless of the cause, are morons that should be held accountable.
- steve_adams_86 6y agoThe rioting that occurred for BLM is quite different from the insurrection. Black people in the USA have faced various degrees of oppression at individual and systemic levels for generations. There’s not just residue of that left in the country, but real substance still present from day to day. It’s a real problem. I don’t support everything that happened during those riots, but I recognize the desire and the need to address and resolve that problem. Donald Trump lost the election and tried to undermine the American democracy, incited violence, and caused a riot by lying to his supporters. Innocent people died, the social cohesion of America was seriously degraded, and it was all for virtually nothing. I don’t support that. That group did do something stupid. But I think it’s important to have compassion for them, because they were lied to (and this was allowed for years) and they, like BLM protestors, probably believed they were doing important work. If trump wasn’t lying to them, they would have been attempting to save democracy. The insurrection would have gone down in history as an important, brave moment. But that’s not what was happening. It’ll be remembered as something so much worse. Just like BLM, bad rioters show up. That’s not necessarily a reflection of the cause. I try not to condemn a protest based on the damage that was done by bad actors. They’re always present. They’re sometimes placed by authorities to encourage people outside of the protest to demand that it ends and remove any support, patience, or tolerance. I see a clear case for battling systemic racism, but none at all for battling for Trump’s illegitimate second term.
- EricE 6y agoWait, I thought Parlor was booted because they were turning a blind eye. Which is it?
- EricE 6y ago"riot" - the vast majority of people walking between ropes, nothing burned, destroyed or set on fire. Months upon months of blocks and blocks of businesses literally burned to the ground but those are "mostly peaceful protests". Give me a break. You had the President of Iran posting actual violent rhetoric and the Chinese bragging about forced sterilization the very day Amazon booted Parlor. The inconsistency is beyond glaring. Unless you choose not to notice it because it wouldn't be politically expedient :p
- Terretta 6y agoOne should ignore reporters or descriptions, look at video and form one’s own opinions. Destruction at 1m30s, walking between ropes at 3m30s: https://www.cnbc.com/video/2021/01/11/the-capitol-siege-an-hour-by-hour-breakdown-of-how-the-day-unfolded.html https://www.cnbc.com/video/2021/01/11/the-capitol-siege-an-h... Lack of peacefulness: https://news.sky.com/story/us-capitol-riots-new-video-reveals-the-chaos-of-trump-supporters-invasion-12191161 https://news.sky.com/story/us-capitol-riots-new-video-reveal... Not so much walking between ropes: https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/capitol-police-officer-howard-liebengood-51-dies-days-after-riot-remembered-as-selfless-kind/ar-BB1cDkcc https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/capitol-police-offic... // Purposely not linking to the hour long documentary/body-cam style collection of video, I’ve been told it’s very hard to take by folks who haven’t lived through violent unrest or been in extreme personal threat situations.