11 ms·
Shitty Software Kills People
- darkerside 6y agoIt's actually incredible how quickly effective software has become an expected function of a proper government. States, cities, and counties are now handling vehicle registration, education, utilities and more over the internet. The paperless future (at least in urban and suburban US) is truly here.
- bombcar 6y agoThere’s a danger here - the edges and the unserved. Charities have sprung up to help people apply for jobs now that they’re all online - can’t apply online if you don’t even have a phone let alone internet access. Online processes and APIs are great but we have to have backups and failsafes.
- fastball 6y agoNot really though. Libraries have internet access and are free to use. The failsafe is "find ways to give everyone internet access", which I think we've already done. Libraries, public wifi APs, cheap 4G, dirt cheap internet capable devices, etc.
- bombcar 6y agoCompanies can get away with serving 90% of the market or less, but places like the DMV and other government divisions have to serve 100% of the people - including those who even when presented with a library computer are unable to utilize it effectively. Foisting support costs off to libraries is another example of the tragedy of the commons.
- fastball 6y agoWhat about people who don't know how to read? Are they served by all government services? No idea how you think this is a tragedy of the commons situation. It is definitely better to digitize everything and serve the 0.1% (certainly not anywhere close to 10%) with additional support that helps them use the digital service, rather than having non-digital fallbacks for significantly more expense.
- kfarr 6y agoYeah I agree libraries are actually the perfect solution for this, not a tragedy. I'm impressed recently with the relevance of libraries doing things exactly like this -- helping the masses access knowledge -- despite the shift away from print.
- jfk13 6y agoDoes every remote rural hamlet have a library? How far is it reasonable to expect someone to travel in order to access this solution?
- fastball 6y agoIf you're so rural you can't access a library, how were you using a pre-internet service in the first place? Internet services becomes more of a win if you're remote, not less so, espescially with things like Starlink coming online.
- kevingadd 6y agoMail service and telephone service are effectively universal, so a job application via the mail or the phone is within reach of basically everyone. Having a handset and a phone line is also much cheaper than owning even a second-hand smartphone (at least a decent cellular plan with data isn't very expensive anymore). A deaf person could handle applying by phone via a relay service (though these days they probably can't because relay services are abused by malicious parties and everyone hangs up on them). Paper applications were probably very tough for blind people though, I'm not sure what the solution was... the internet is likely better there, if you're lucky and the job application website is actually accessible. I lived in a very rural area for about 50% of my childhood - we had no fire department, we relied on a well for water, our town's official population was in the hundreds, etc. If we wanted to get on the internet we had to do it at around 38400 and random packets would get corrupted because the lines were old and low-quality (I wrote my own parity tool in VB6 so that I could download a file 3-4 times and produce a not-corrupted version). Despite that, if I wanted to call someone up on the phone to speak with them or send a letter, that was just as easy and effective as it was when I lived in the suburbs. When we eventually managed to get slow DSL years later it was INCREDIBLY expensive because in rural areas if you're lucky enough to have service at all the monopolist who offers it knows they can charge as much as they want.
- aimor 6y agoAs a part of the pandemic libraries in my area are closed. This failsafe has also failed. I think you’re right that there should be a variety of redundant options to better cover people.
- hedora 6y agoAround here, libraries lend out 4g access points and chrome books, fwiw.
- hansvm 6y ago> if you don’t even have a phone If you don't have a sufficiently expensive phone. In an effort to prevent easily creating cheap fake accounts (presumably -- I don't actually know), phone numbers associated with low-end android devices are routinely banned from social media platforms, online banks, and any number of other organizations.
- easton 6y agoHow can a phone number be associated with a certain type of device? AT&T doesn’t seem to know what kind of phone I have.
- bombcar 6y agoI know that republic wireless’s “voip” number can’t be texted by some services.
- hansvm 6y agoI doubt it's directly associated with a certain type of device but rather a certain carrier or block of numbers associated with cheap devices (e.g., tracfones). Regardless of the mechanism, the effect is real.
- bellyfullofbac 6y agoOr sufficiently new. Your phone from 5 years ago only has Android 5? "This banking app needs Android 6 as a minimum". Flash a "homebrew" Android 6 ROM? "This device does not meet the security requirements.". Frakk off!
- kspacewalk2 6y ago>phone numbers associated with low-end android devices are routinely banned from social media platforms, online banks, and any number of other organizations. Any references where I can read more about this?
- hansvm 6y agoMostly just personal experience. I think the common denominator is actually pre-paid vs post-paid plans, but it winds up having a similar effect because cheaper phones usually come with a pre-paid SIM and because pre-paid plans are usually much cheaper for spartan usage. Here are a few anecdotes from around the web. - https://www.paypal-community.com/t5/About-Settings/Tracfone-users-excluded-from-using-Paypal/td-p/1364866 https://www.paypal-community.com/t5/About-Settings/Tracfone-... - https://www.paypal-community.com/t5/About-Settings/Paypal-doesn-t-recognize-my-phone-number/td-p/1159932 https://www.paypal-community.com/t5/About-Settings/Paypal-do... - https://www.reddit.com/r/TracFone/comments/g42vl9/phone_number_registration_in_my_name/ https://www.reddit.com/r/TracFone/comments/g42vl9/phone_numb... - https://help.id.me/hc/en-us/articles/360017839774-Why-can-t-my-phone-number-be-verified- https://help.id.me/hc/en-us/articles/360017839774-Why-can-t-...
- steelframe 6y ago> Online processes and APIs are great but we have to have backups and failsafes. At my company everyone has gone API-crazy. There's one activity in a team I used to be on that used to require a human review of a configuration change. It's something that developers on the team do just a few times a year. Someone got the idea that this should be fully automated, because I guess it would look good on their performance review if they built a new service? What we had at the start was a description of what you were trying to do and how you could do it, but it included a manual review of a change request. It was simple, understandable, and required very little human attention. What we ended up with was an API for a microservice with its methods half-documented and no "big picture" description of what API calls you were supposed to make in which sequence to get the job done. API calls would fail with obscure misspelled error messages, and you'd have to guess what you did wrong in the JSON file you were submitting. And then of course it ended up not working half the time, and you'd have to open support tickets or ping the entire dev team in chat to ask why you weren't getting the results you expected when using the API. Of course the initial response tended to be, "Did you read the documentation?" And the user would have to respond, "Yes. Here is what I did after trying to decipher the so-called documentation, and here's why. Here are the results I need. I'm not getting them. How can I figure out why?" At which point two or three very annoyed developers would ask for details on exactly which API calls were made with which parameters, and they'd poke into logs and whatever, before they figured out yet another untested corner case and manually fix the database entries while saying, "Well don't do that next time." Sure, if you've got to scale to thousands of requests a week or something, building an API with a microservice might make sense. But there's a point of diminishing returns in trying to automate absolutely everything behind APIs. Some very low QPS things really should have a human in the loop by default.
- EamonnMR 6y agoWhat scares me is the obsession with supporting old desktop browsers and ignoring the majority of people who are using phones and might not have access to a desktop.
- 127 6y agoSome inertia is probably good considering how much Google tries to turn the Internet into the Googlenet.
- young_unixer 6y agoI'm scared about the opposite: governments releasing only Android and iOS apps and no web version for their services. At least the web is an open standard.
- jfk13 6y agoIt's not just governments: one of the (major) banks I deal with supports many types of account -- such as mortgages -- only via their apps, not on the web. I think that's appalling.
- Master_Odin 6y agoSimilar thing happened to me with Itau in Brazil in that their website was barely functional (with the last month I was a customer I couldn't even login in) and had to do everything over the cellphone app. Super annoying as I wasn't a native speaker of the language and desperately wanted to use my computer for ease of use with translation software.
- postalrat 6y agoShitty cheeseburgers also kill people.
- IshKebab 6y agoIs it? I remember wishing in the early 00s that you could do more government tasks online but it was still all "send this form through the post". It took a long time for the UK government to digitise things. Mercifully when they finally did they did a good job.
- incrudible 6y agoBureaucracy kills people. Software can only do so much when some regulation mandates that a document needs to be printed, signed and brought on premise.
- bombcar 6y agoMultiple options are the answer - not some modern web app. I’m sure we can find people who have died simply because they can’t navigate a webpage or an app. As techies we assume having an app for something is the way to go - but there are many who do not have access and being able to fill out a printed form and submit it by hand is a better solution for them.
- EamonnMR 6y agoAgree strongly with multiple options. Especially because if Web Form becomes the only option, it'll still be the only option in 25 years when everything else is via brain interface.
- madsbuch 6y agoThis is very dependent on jurisdiction. I haven't had a piece of governmental paper in my hands in my adult life (just over a decade). However, in Denmark we are very dependent on a working public IT infrastructure. After all, we are one of the countries that registers the most about their citizens.
- gumby 6y ago> Bureaucracy kills people. Well, sure. But bureaucracy saves people too, and probably the balance is overwhelmingly to the second. It’s just hard to see things when they work like road safety regulations, food safety regulations, building codes and the like. And when things work, few people complain about them; those who do may be ones who suffer a local inconvenience or lose cost-free access to a negative externality.
- readflaggedcomm 6y agoThe title is at variance with the body, which describes how paperwork is worse than shitty software.
- aaron695 6y agoShitty Software Saves Lives They even make this case Not software - "you have to download a bloody pdf. Then you have to print it. You fill it up with a pen...." BBC - "Excel: Why using Microsoft's tool caused Covid-19 results to be lost" But it worked. Excel is brilliant software with decades of work, it was the (Shitty) scripts that 'failed' ignoring BBC Excel headlines. Except they got the scripts running, made a mistake, fixed it and moved on pretty quick.
- Veen 6y agoI recently read the biography of Jeremy Heywood, who was the UK's Cabinet Secretary—essentially the leader of the civil service and the person in charge of making sure the government functions. Excel got several mentions, and the book gives the impression that our government, including the Treasury, more or less runs on spreadsheets.
- bombcar 6y agoThis is true of most if not all of the business world. It runs on spreadsheets, apps that imitate spreadsheets, or hand-built spreadsheet equivalents.
- p_l 6y agoIf that scares you... never look at how sausage is made in FMCG world. One of the major companies in that area essentially uses Excel as standard data format, that is exchanged by applications etc. Capo di tutti capi of the company (i.e. the CEO of the overall controlling entity of the whole multinational) might be woken up if, by the end of the month, a bunch of Excel/CSV files aren't exported from a certain database, feeding a bunch of downstream applications, which in turn will provide Excel files to employees. The less insane use of Excel there was as human interface, where Excel files were used both to query external services, but also as input files/forms that could be sent as attachment and "cosigned" by appropriate person.
- ghaff 6y agoThe other thing that happens with Excel is it starts out really being the right MVP for some task. But that task grows and grows over time and Excel keeps right on being used well past the point a database should have been implemented instead.
- raverbashing 6y agoIf it's a downloadable PDF and then you have to go to a queue I assume they'll have the forms on the location to fill it manually Yes it is stupid, but not everybody can download a PDF Remember when the NY state comptroller complained about how the process was complex? If there's one thing that GDPR should have put into people's head is not bothering with data you don't need. But nooo, everybody prefers to keep collecting the same data (either a form or advertisement data) then add another tick box. People's love for bureaucracy is something (And I also might add, people's love for complaining sometimes it's bigger than their want of solving the problems)
- ectopod 6y agoI was really impressed with the UK vaccine booking system. A text message from the doctor directed me to an online booking form. This was an incredibly simple html form-based thing. The first screen asks for your DOB (to check you're the right person). The second has a short list with about five appointments to choose from (a couple of different days, a few different times). Select one, click OK, done. A text message confirmed the appointment. It was simple and functional. It didn't even require javascript.
- ghaff 6y agoYou can't make a general statement about the system in the US, because many (all?) states have their own systems for mass vaccination sites, the big pharmacy chains have their systems, and presumably hospitals have their own systems. The Massachusetts system seems pretty good with easy pre-registration and choice of ways to be contacted when you're up for an appointment. Problem with some of the other systems is you pretty much have to keep checking. I've been tempted to write some code.
- pacifika 6y agoI just got a phone call and showed up
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y agoWorse - you may not know the software has this power over you. I remember a specially egregious case that one of the rental companies was guilty of: automated criminality The software in question automated the reporting of grand theft auto to authorities. The rental company used it to streamline reporting of rentals to police. The problem: false positives. The software would report drivers as criminals, when in fact cars had been exchanged midrental due to car failures etc, and the original car hadnt been returned under the normal workflow, which the software failed to account for. Then that police report would chase innocent people for literal years, coming up to unsuspecting customers during routine speeding stops. I always wonder whether contributor names to closed sourced software should always be transparent. Excellent engineers should be able to take credit on their work and there would be more skin in the game. Particularly for employers that get suspect resources from to solve for budget constrains artificially imposed by business managers with no stake in the product functionality, to critical software processes like SREs etc
- novok 6y agoIn that case although, you don't know which system or team is responsible for the 'cop reporting' part. I could be making a very innocent rental state tracking system, and then someone else just accesses the same table without my knowledge and makes a criminal reporting system after the fact. After a certain point, we recognize as a society that just because you make chairs, your not at fault if someone then takes a chair you made and then bashes someone on the head with a chair. It's the basher's fault, not yours.
- bryanrasmussen 6y ago>you don't know which system or team is responsible for the 'cop reporting' part. you also don't know if they have any information given regarding possible workflow deviations, or if it was made when they had one workflow and workflow was changed without paying for changing the system. If that were the case it would be an example of shitty management gets people harassed by the police and potentially killed because getting harassed by the police at the wrong moment, or looking like the wrong person, in the wrong country can get you killed.
- grogenaut 6y agoI just spent 6 hours volunteering as an usher at a pharmacy doing about 1k vaccinations in a day. The number of people over 60 who didn't understand the difference between a text message and an email was around 30% (out of a sample size of 600 during my shift). About 10% of the people who showed didn't have smartphones or text, 4 people did everything only with phone calls. I wonder how many people who only did phone calls were NOT able to get vaccine slots? Working with my aging mother, modern UIs are very complicated. Ever changing gestures, hidden menus, differences between machines, passwords, multi-accounts, etc. Heck my mom can't figure out the volume buttons on her iphone so she holds face time to her ear to hear. Heck even the default apps are hard on her. iMessage keeps getting moved to the home page and SMS to the 2nd page. So she sees the blue bubble and uses that to message us, even tho we are sending SMS. She needs to use the green bubble from the second page. This is not to mention how bad all of these apps or websites are and the loss of a person to call to get clarification for anything not written on a website. 95% of my time yesterday was spent just answering nuances to the basic questions. For instance we were giving Moderna to the first dose people. Every time I announced that to the line, half of the 2nd dose people panicked and said "I need Pfizer". For me as a programmer, keeping it all in my head was easy, it's just a 8 branch 3 level deep if/else statement. For aging people with phones the information became inaccessible. Those with paper printouts of everything were able to just breeze through and paper doesn't reboot, loose battery, or forget, and you can easily hand paper to other people. The rate of vaccinations actually crushed the brand new system in place (which was there because the old system melted at 300 people a day). So paper was great. They just did all the data in put at the end of the day. I'm actually quite worried with our current hodgepodge of low quality software we're greatly isolating older people, or people who are not using tech heavily every day. And this is not just for crappy government software. I saw as many people unable to use their iphone and android basic software. With my mom, netflix, why does it even have a password she has to remember? Device authorization between her roku and a laptop is confounding, they're 2 totally different devices. It's basically impossible.
- bombcar 6y agoIt's a tale as old as time - and it's not just "old people" either. The number of young brilliant people who seem to have a mental block around computers is larger than you might think. I've had people call and ask why they can't login and when they share screen the webpage has a huge graphic telling them to approve the notification on their phone (TFA). They don't even read it. And it's not their fault! People have only a limited capacity for things. Imagine if your car changed how it worked every week or so when you sat down to drive - driving would be nearly impossible. https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2005/12/12 https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2005/12/12
- EamonnMR 6y agoIs this a software problem? > Then you have to print it. > You fill it up with a pen, trying to remember, find or recover information which you might or might not have access to (but that you know for a fact that it’s stored in multiple databases behind some firewall). Then go to a physical location with your little printed form, queue up, and hope for the best. Sounds more to me like an organizational inflexibility problem. Someone somewhere refused to change the definition of 'signed' and mandated that people print something. Someone decided that they couldn't autofill the form. Someone decided that submissions will only be accepted as physical forms. This is sort of my hobby horse since I worked at a company that interfaced with healthcare providers that insisted that we accept faxed documents.
- musicale 6y agoI think the "software" in question might actually be the operating procedures and policies of the bureaucracy. Bureaucratic operating procedures are often essentially malicious software that de-prioritizes the needs of ordinary citizens far below the priorities of the organization. An organization may pay some lip service to a mission of service to citizens, but usually the organization's actual, absolute top priorities are self-preservation and expanding its budget, staff, power, and influence. A secondary priority may be reducing fraud and punishing cheaters, even at the expense of honest citizens. Though sometimes (e.g. California unemployment insurance) you get perverse outcomes where fraudsters are richly rewarded at the expense of honest citizens.
- superjan 6y agoI honestly don’t see why a paper form is necessarily wrong. Paper records have worked for ages. You can make people e-sign something, but would a 70 year old understand that he did something equivalent to signing? Prefilling would have been nice to have, sure, but not doing that is not killing people.
- xnyan 6y ago>I honestly don’t see why a paper form is necessarily wrong Agree, but I also think the point the author is trying to make is correct but maybe unclear - The main goal is to get people the vaccine, period. Everything else that is being done is being done in support of that goal. Not everyone has direct access to a printer, should that be a reason someone should not get vaccinated? Paper ballots are great for elections, but there's no good reason paper is required to get someone Moderna/Pfizer/AZ/J&J et al.
- qrbLPHiKpiux 6y agoThe title should be People KILL People because people write code.
- ironmagma 6y agoIt’s really a distributed phenomenon. Crappy engineering managers kill people through their crappy managing. And same with moral-less CEOs. To some extent, the engineers have the blame because they agree to write the code. But ultimately the problem exists with.. the managers? the board? the CEO? the customers who enable them all? It’s all of the above. This is why it’s on all of us to have a moral system and enforce it.
- c-cube 6y agoSounds like "guns don't kill people"
- bsaul 6y agocovid crisis is really a wake up call for a lot of people in many countries regarding the efficiency of their administration in moments of crisis. I've very often told myself during the past months, witnessing (my) french government : we're really fortunate nobody is declaring war to us, because we would be run over in a few days, judging by the time it take for any administration to get things done properly.
- periheli0n 6y agoIf it’s any consolation—the situation is not much better in Germany.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- yellowapple 6y agoI had this same thought while trying to schedule my COVID vaccine. Here in Nevada, we're eligible if we're 16+ years old and have underlying conditions (and apparently obesity is an underlying condition, so I can finally say that me being a fatass has some benefits), but only through a few grocery store chains. Experience went something like this: 1. Go to the Smith's website 1.1. Endure some fucking chatbot to determine eligibility 1.2. Finally pick a date/time for the first dose 1.3. No options for the second dose, so I can't continue. No vaccine for me. How the fuck am I able to pick a first date and not a second? Shouldn't it be the other way around? Why even give me the option for a first date if no second dates are available? Why are you even making me pick a second date when y'all are doing the one-shot vaccines anyway? 2. Try Walgreens' website 2.1. No vaccines anywhere, so no vaccine for me. Cool. At least it was a quick response. 3. Try Walmart's website 3.1. Create an account, because reasons 3.2. Choose a store 3.3. There are inexplicably two options for "16+ with underlying conditions", and both have to be checked for me to be eligible. Alright, whatever. 3.4. Find out the chosen store doesn't have any vaccines anyway. If it doesn't have any vaccines, then why the fuck was it an option, Walmart? 3.5. GOTO 3.2 4. Try Safeway's website 4.1. Redirects to Albertson's for some reason, and no vaccines. Cool, thanks for the quick answer. 5. Try Sam's Club 5.1. Sign up for a "guest" account 5.2. Go through yet another chatbot for the basic eligibility questions 5.3. Go through a half-baked web form with a lot more medical questions. 5.3. Pick the first open timeslot. 5.4. Success! This experience has (re)taught me that if this is what it takes for people to get vaccinated, then shitty web design will - not might, not could, will - result in actual loss of life. There's no way I'd expect my grandparents to have been able to work through this (luckily they started with Sam's, and as byzantine as it was, at least it worked). Like, it's 2021. How fucking hard is it in 2021 to put up a simple web form without multiple megabytes of broken JS driving it? How hard is it to setup appointment scheduling? How hard is it to track inventory of a SKU? These things have been done electronically for decades now, and we still can't get it right?
- sershe 6y agoAnother way in which this is true... given the installed base, how many lifetimes' worth of man-hours are lost every year when Outlook, Evernote, Eclipse, ... decide to block the UI thread to make a network request?
- atum47 6y agoI've been saying that for years. If a bridge or a building built by a civil engineer fails, they are held responsible. How come when a major (easy preventable) accident happens with software, software engineers are free to walk? Government own software fails on regular basis, exposing data from everyone or with even worse consequences.
- AzzieElbab 6y agoHealth care IT is a very special kind of hell. Avoid at all costs
- ohuf 6y agoShitty Infrastructure kills people eventually.
- srg0 6y agoPaperwork issues certainly exist, and can always be improved, and paperless procedures are important, but I disagee with the author that this particular process kills people. Paperwork is not a bottleneck of the Italian vaccination program (and many other EU vaccination efforts). AstraZeneca not honouring their obligations to EU while prioritizing UK, is actually killing people. There are tens of millions of doses many countries counted on, which are not delivered. That's what's killing people, not the inconvenience of filling a paper form.
- SergeAx 6y agoMeanwhile Italy has a law [0] that obliges public administrations to open source public-funded software on a special portal [1] and examine that portal for reusing of already-built software before commissioning a new one. [0] https://docs.italia.it/italia/developers-italia/gl-acquisition-and-reuse-software-for-pa-docs/en/stabile/index.html https://docs.italia.it/italia/developers-italia/gl-acquisiti... [1] https://developers.italia.it/en/ https://developers.italia.it/en/