6 ms·
Call centre staff to be monitored via webcam for home-working ‘infractions’
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nilsb 6y agoIn line with their company name they should call them telescreens. On a more serious note, that kind of work environment attracts people who don't give a sh** about the company's goals. Highly motivated people just don't need supervision on that level.
- Clewza313 6y agoEverybody involved knows these are dead-end jobs. Turnover of over 100% per year is common, and it turns into a self-fulfilling prophecy of everybody being treated like disposable peons.
- Hydraulix989 6y agoHow can turnover exceed 100%? The entire staff are replaced multiple times in a year?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- CamTin 6y agoYes, exactly.
- coldtea 6y ago>attracts people who don't give a sh* about the company's goals Whereas otherwise someone would apply to follow their dream career at a call center? Of course they do, it's dead-end jobs, paying shit, that only people pressured to make ends meet ever apply to. That's with monitoring or not. And that's what makes monitoring both worse and applicable: because many of those people can't just quit...
- vkou 6y agoHighly motivated people generally don't apply to these jobs, and those that do don't stay for very long. Motivation is not what their employers are optimizing for, # of tickets solved / hour and # of upsells sold per day is.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoWorking in a call center is the most dehumanizing and abusive white-collar job that's still legal in the West. The company goals are to extract maximum number of billable hours from their clients at minimum costs. People are expected to burn out after few months and leave. It's a job that's taken only by either young and naïve, or when your only other alternatives are illegal and/or... icky.
- Clewza313 6y agoFWIW, this isn't really any different from what goes on in regular call centers. I've visited some in the Philippines, and breaks are minutely regulated, personal phones are not allowed, bringing food or drinks to your desk is strictly forbidden, and the tables are laid out in tight ranks so they can easily be supervised by roaming supervisors. It's all about the KPIs, and there's a constant battle between the agents trying to game theirs upward and management trying to squeeze more work out of people, while simultaneously trying to hit their own targets and extract more billable hours from the client.
- tmpz22 6y agoSome restrictions are sensible - for example call centers which routinely collect credit card information must reduce the surface area by which an employee can extract data from the facility. Same for content moderation gigs where the content also cannot be extracted. Yes they should pay more and treat there employees better but don’t act like the average consumer does not support many of these provisions.
- gnu8 6y ago> reduce the surface area by which an employee can extract data from the facility Is that what they must do? A software engineer at a FAANG could exfiltrate 1000x more data with their skills and their privileged access. I think they should be treated like call center employees.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoBut the FAANG employee has a lot more to lose. By getting fired, they could be loosing $200,000+ at a minimum. A call center employee typically makes maybe $30,000 per year, if that.
- BoorishBears 6y agoThis would be a great anecdote if companies handling sensitive data weren't using contractors that get paid about as much as those call center workers... At which point malice isn't even required to start losing private info to breaches
- Reason077 6y ago10:28 INFRACTION: Bathroom break exceeds allowance 11:32 INFRACTION: Reduced level of attention/engagement detected 11:40 INFRACTION: Unauthorised nose picking
- airhead969 6y ago12:01 INFRACTION: Excessive respiratory activity 12:04 INFRACTION: Unapproved hydration 12:11 INFRACTION: Disallowed leg shaking 12:18 INFRACTION: Forbidden exasperation/FML alert
- geocrasher 6y ago12:43 INFRACTION: Excessive clicking of the right mouse button 12:44 INFRACTION: Unauthorized single digit gesturing 12:45 SECURITY VIOLATION: USB Webcam offline 12:46 SECURITY VIOLATION: Company property disconnected 12:48 SECURITY VIOLATION: Improper disposition of company property 12:52 Are you still there? Target Lost. 12:53 Sleep mode activated.
- heybrendan 6y ago1 year later... "Teleperformance experiences significant attrition due to hostile surveillance of WFH personnel; struggles to hire replacements."
- Guthur 6y agoI wouldn't be so sure, I imagine the physical call centre wasn't really much different.
- _underfl0w_ 6y agoWhile this is correct, surveillance in the physical call center wasn't physically taking place in these people's homes, which IMHO is the critical difference.
- Guthur 6y agoSure, because the call center was your workplace. Now your home is your work place and the rules have changed. And to be clear I don't particularly believe this methodology is ultimately good for anyone; either the consumer, call center staff, or the company who's call support has been outsourced.
- johnchristopher 6y agoUnlikely I believe. Call centres may be essential but people working there are cogs easy to swap.
- Hroble 6y agoUnfortunately call center employees don't usually have a choice, no one works in a call center because they like the job.
- tolbish 6y agoI suppose that is one way to get the remote-first evangelists to desire being back in the office again.
- nicolas_t 6y agoWow, that's one of the books in term of double-speak: "the webcam system was intended “to respond to the overwhelming concerns of isolation, lack of team engagement and support, not seeing anyone from one day to the next, raised by those who are at home”." Sometimes, I'm really impressed at PR firms ability to think that the rest of the world is idiotic and will take their statement at face value. It's a pity that call centers are treated as dead end job and that we have companies pushing for those conditions because a good CS experience does completely change customer satisfaction and is worth cultivating. The race to the bottom with call centers is a very myopic way of treating one's customers.
- MattGaiser 6y agoA customer reaching a call centre is basically a "everything else failed" moment, a moment that is very expensive as 1 on 1 human help costs a lot of money. If you are going to invest, you invest in making sure people don't need to call.
- Alterlife 6y ago> making sure people don't need to call. Almost every IVR I have ever used makes me believe business invest in making sure people can't call or at least have a very hard time reaching a human.
- gogopuppygogo 6y agoAmazon makes it so easy to get help from a human that they call you...
- Zak 6y agoI'm reminded of a policy of the southeastern US grocery store chain Publix: if there's a pricing error, the item is free. It will probably come as no surprise that pricing errors are extremely rare there. When a company creates a significant incentive for itself to get an aspect of its business right, it will probably get that aspect right. I don't think I've ever wanted to call Amazon on the phone, and nearly every issue I can recall has had a satisfactory solution within their UI.
- indigodaddy 6y agoIf this is the only way a company can gauge individual performance then they are doing it wrong
- pjc50 6y agoOn this subject, the politics of the call center: https://www.harrowell.org.uk/blog/2012/01/21/the-politics-of-call-centres-part-two-sources-of-failure/ https://www.harrowell.org.uk/blog/2012/01/21/the-politics-of... / https://www.harrowell.org.uk/blog/2012/01/21/the-politics-of-call-centres-part-one/ https://www.harrowell.org.uk/blog/2012/01/21/the-politics-of... "Asymmetric legibility" is a good phrase for this.
- sumanthvepa 6y agoI run a small business in India, and it horrifies me as to how badly call center employees are treated. I use contractors all the time and I just set the goals and measure outcomes at intervals of a week. I’ve never found micromanaging a poor performer to improve performance and it definitely pisses off high performers. If your employee is not performing and doesn’t improve with coaching, then just move on and find someone else. Don’t make your employee miserable with this sort of surveillance.
- geocrasher 6y agoI could not agree more! If you can't trust an employee to do a good job, then why are they employed?
- mrweasel 6y agoOften they aren't, they are employed by the lowest biding subcontractor you could find. Perhaps because when they implement stuff like this and it surfaces in newspapers you can just fire that company or claim that you "had no idea that people where forced to work under such degrading conditions and the subcontract will receive a stern talking-to. The business logic behind the current call centre model is extremely flawed, it basically boils down to: We really don't want people to call, but sometimes they have to, how do we make that call as cheap as possible. Business seem completely blind to the fact that when customers call, then it's because something has gone wrong. This is when you need competent and happy people answering the phone. Instead that call is seen as a stand-alone expense, which needs to be kept as low as possible. In reality the call centre costs should be minimised by fixing the reason for the call. Thing to keep call costs down by hiring increasingly cheaper labour and trying to keep employees in check by implementing immoral business practises just results in increasingly unhappy customers.
- underwater 6y agoIt seems this kind of approach is popular in fields where no one actually wants to do the job. Being a telemarketer sounds is a shit job 99% of the time. The only company I know of who claims to use the trust and motivate approach to this kind of job is Zappos.
- donatj 6y agoIs there any actual advantage business advantage in being so draconian or is it just spiteful? Like my cushy programming job has made me soft but why not just measure performance by their actual performance? I can go to the bathroom or make a pot of coffee whenever I want, and I suspect the happiness that brings increases performance.
- foobar33333 6y agoTalking out of my ass here because I don't know either, but maybe in these kinds of jobs, happiness doesn't really increase performance. If your job is 90% just reading out the FAQs page to customers or handling the exact same problem 50 times a day, its probably more an automatic process that the longer you sit at your desk, the more calls you are able to process and when your job has such a large supply, the contracts go out to whoever is cheapest.
- _underfl0w_ 6y agoHaving worked in a call center myself at one point, I'd say the primary difference is the directly-customer-facing nature of that work. When a call comes in (and there are often a large number of simultaneous calls) someone has to be there at their desk to receive it - whereas with yours and my current gigs, the worst that'll happen is some production issue with a reasonable SLA.
- tobr 6y agoThis makes me think of Apple, who outsource a big chunk of their Apple Care support to Teleperformance. They are also famously trying to tout privacy as one of their core values. Of course neither Apple nor Teleperformance are going to comment on whether Apple Care support agents are exposed to these bullshit privacy violations, but it wouldn’t be too hard to figure out.
- jarym 6y agoRidiculous. If you are gonna have a webcam for this then why not make it automatically mark you as away if you step away from your desk rather than warn your supervisor that you did not click ‘break mode’ first. Stupid.
- tobr 6y agoYou really shouldn’t expect software employed in a call center to be designed to be easy or convenient for the people working there.
- anothernewdude 6y agoSurely there are more task focused performance metrics.
- nocture 6y agoPlenty of these systems have caught some focus the past year. A different question might be - why do developers not say no to work on this type of software?
- metters 6y agoThere always will be someone to deliver a product. Why are there engineers developing weapons systems even though they know human beings will be killed by their creation...? The salary is raised until someone is willing to do that job for the offered money.
- 29athrowaway 6y agoYou can record a footage of you at the desk and then loop it.
- edf13 6y agoSays it all when you read the companies response to this story... > adding that it was “extremely disappointing” the media had been alerted and that this was considered gross misconduct
- thinkingemote 6y agoRMS was right. Again.
- vkou 6y agoThis has zero to do with open source.
- underseacables 6y agoNo job is worth this level of discomfort and intrusion. I really hope employees quit in mass if this is implemented.
- mbrodersen 6y agoI see a business opportunity for somebody here: AI software to counter AI surveillance software.