12 ms·
"tipping" culture strikes again! When the wage for certain service workers is too low, we try to subsidize it by tipping them. Now when the government doesn't p
by gruez 6y ago
"tipping" culture strikes again! When the wage for certain service workers is too low, we try to subsidize it by tipping them. Now when the government doesn't provide enough coronavirus relief for service workers, some of us keep them on the payroll as a kind of cornavirus relief.
- lambda_obrien 6y agoThat's a bad thing why? These people are just taking care of the people who take care of them and their kids. It seems logical to me.
- rubicon33 6y agoThe point is that in a politically and economically healthy society, they shouldn't have to.
- lambda_obrien 6y agoI think we know that America isn't healthy in any respect right now. Part of that is we don't think it's necessary to take care of each other.
- animal_spirits 6y agoWell, on one hand at least the money goes directly to the one in need and not through the government as a middle man. There's no department heads or managers of managers to pay in between this transaction.
- gruez 6y agoPros: no government "middle man" taking a "cut" (although I'd like to see how much % was used to administer the trump/biden checks, for instance) Cons: Totally arbitrary. Have a generous employer? Great! Stingy employer? Sucks for you. I'd also imagine that whether you'd get this kind of "relief" depends on your job, kind of like how waiters get tipped but fast food workers don't.
- dredmorbius 6y agoThis isn't tipping, but assured maintenance. We usually think of wages as payment for work produced, and generally, if the cost of producing a thing isn't exceeded by the value created, you won't pay that cost. But the true cost of labour is its upkeep, sustenance, that of its family, the training, risk, and uncertainty associated with the employment, as detailed 245 years ago by Adam Smith (Book 1, Chapter X, Wealth of Nations). And that means, in a time when work is impossible, paying a maintenance wage to ensure future productive capacity.
- chii 6y agoThat's exactly what unemployment benefits should be. It's an emergency measure, funded by taxation of society, to allow for those who would be affected by a calamity to weather the storm and emerge on the other side capable of resuming their productivity.
- dredmorbius 6y agoUnemployment insurance in the US is handled state-by-state, with commensurate variance. But virtually no states offer unemployment insurance as a routine basis for self-employed individuals, which would include individuals with small businesses, gig workers, or independent contractors, which largely describes housecleaning services workers. The US did pass emergency national legislation (the CARES Act) which allows (but does not AFAIU require) states to extend unemployment insurance to those workers. See: https://web.archive.org/web/20200617001228/https://money.usnews.com/money/personal-finance/family-finance/articles/unemployment-benefits-for-the-self-employed https://web.archive.org/web/20200617001228/https://money.usn... Mind: I agree with your point from an ought perspective, unfortunately the is is at odds here. For the US, this means individuals have to step in. My comment above only means to illustrate the economic rationale by which one might choose to do so. Unfortunately given market mechanics, most people will like decide not to. That's the cause of much of the economic disruption and dislocation of the past year, in the US and elsewhere.