13 ms·
Equivalent of 97% of Scotland’s 2020 electricity consumption was from renewables
- qwerty456127 6y agoHow much do they pay? I've heard electricity is quite expensive in the UK so surviving a winter can be hard.
- Svip 6y agoHere is a comparison for European countries: https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php/Electricity_price_statistics https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- VBprogrammer 6y agoFor the most part electricity isn't used for heating in the UK, generally gas central heating is preferred. There are obviously some exceptions, houses built in the 70s with electric ceiling heating (this is as bad is it sounds) or electric storage heaters.
- IAmEveryone 6y agoElectric heating in a country like Scotland is simply unconscionable. There is natural gas infrastructure. And where it’s not, even oil is better than electricity.
- VBprogrammer 6y agoUnconscionable is a strong word. Ground source heat pumps powered by renewablely generated electricity is pretty close to an ideal scenario. Resistance heating from electricity generated by gas is pretty bad though.
- Dylanfm 6y agoThese days many new builds are using air source or ground source heat pumps. And existing dwellings are beginning to be retrofitted for them. I don't have numbers, but I expect that it will soon be the norm for new builds for places without gas infrastructure. Especially with any new legislation around heating for new builds (e.g. https://www.gov.scot/news/new-build-homes-to-be-more-energy-efficient/ https://www.gov.scot/news/new-build-homes-to-be-more-energy-...).
- ClumsyPilot 6y ago"surviving a winter" Yeah many are just growing a layer of fat and hybernating. Hence the obecity rates
- edent 6y agoI'm the UK. I pay 14.97p/kWh (which includes tax). The average UK household uses about 3,800 kWh per year.
- Glench 6y agoA few people in this thread are talking about electric heating being awful. And yeah, I think traditional electric resistance heating is expensive and not very high quality, but modern electric heat pumps are one of the most efficient forms of space heating we have, they can be run in reverse to cool houses too, and they increase comfort a lot — many systems allow you to have room-by-room control of the temperature. Plus they're used everywhere in Asia already. Here's an example of someone's experience installing and using a "mini-split" heat pump for their house: https://www.sustainablelafayette.org/single-post/home-electrification-part-4-selecting-and-installing-a-heat-pump-heating-cooling-system https://www.sustainablelafayette.org/single-post/home-electr...
- doikor 6y agoYeah heat pumps are the answer to places like Scotland. As a bonus you get air conditioning. They do have some problems with extreme cold (not really an issue in Scotland or most of Europe for that matter) but even in such a case should still be used together with plain resistance heating. But that kind of cold has very few people living there anyway (think -30c or colder)
- Glench 6y agoI've been wondering about this! I keep hearing that air-source heat pumps aren't great in pretty cold areas. Do you have any links or references on this? I live in the Northeast US and wanted to see what the options were and what people's experiences have been.
- doikor 6y agoBasically the Coefficient of performance (COP or SCOP for seasonal version) just keeps going down with the temperature (under 1 means resistance heating is better) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coefficient_of_performance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coefficient_of_performance Models made for cold climate work to around -30c. Wikipedia has okish writeup about their functionality in cold climates https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_source_heat_pump#In_cold_climates https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_source_heat_pump#In_cold_c... Don't really have any good sources in English for this (most reading I have done on this is in Finnish) For example here are some excerpts from a report done by VTT (the Finnish governments research center) https://www.scanoffice.fi/vttn-testiraportit-ilmalampopumppuvertailu/ https://www.scanoffice.fi/vttn-testiraportit-ilmalampopumppu... If you scroll down you can find some pics "lämpökerroin" is COP and "ulkoilman lämpötila" is outside temperature. From that you can see that the combo of Mitsubishi Electric MSZ-LN25VGW + MUZ-LN25VGHZ still holds a COP of 2 at -30c. On the models not made for such climate/cheap ones you can see it drop to 1 (or below)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- neom 6y ago"Not only do renewables reduce the impact of our electricity use on the climate, they are also generating jobs and income for communities around the country." I wish everyone thought that way, all I hear in Canada is "oh the jobs, oh the jobs, what will happen to the jobs...???"
- einpoklum 6y ago> all I hear in Canada is "oh the job, oh the job, what will happen to the jobs...???" That's your corporate control of mainstream media, I would think. And not only is there lots of work in renewable energy, but we've just gone through a year in which many large economies simply "bankrolled" a large unemployed fraction of the population, and the sky didn't fall: Prices didn't shoot up, no runs on banks, nothing like that. So the Canadian state, had it so wished, could back the transition with some money-printing if push came to shove. ... if it were so inclined.
- neom 6y agoThe only mainstream media I consume is occasionally CBC. The sentiment I hear is from high school friends in Northwestern Ontario and folks I know out in Alberta and BC. In my personal opinion, we already have lots of crown corps in Canada, using them to put solar farms in Nunavut and offshore wind generation on the East and West coasts are just fine by me, faster we transition that way the better as far as I'm concerned.
- jariel 6y agoBecause Canada has a massive Oil sector, Scotland doesn't so much - and with a tinge of hypocrisy they want a bigger share of the revenue proceeds from North Sea Oil. Canada's economic influence in the world is fairly strongly tied to Oil to the point where over the last 30 years it's correlated with the buying power of the dollar, and certainly the economic veracity of most Alberta. It also fundamentally alters the surplus/deficit scenario - it's a 'major component' (though not nearly like Norway). iPhones and many foreign cars in Canada are about 25% more expensive than they were a few years ago for example. Environmental issues aside, there is a lot of downside - it's not just like all that industry can be shifted from one part of the economy to the other.
- lightgreen 6y agoUnlike most places in the world, Scotland is sparsely populated (5M) and mountainous, so they have an option of using hydro. Good for them, but let’s not jump to conclusion that their approach is for everyone. And yes, the article is only about electricity, not heating.
- danjac 6y agoOh dear. You do realize the Scots mostly don't live alone in little cabins in the mountains like in the movies, don't you? Most of the population lives in the (densely populated) Central Belt: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demography_of_Scotland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demography_of_Scotland
- lightgreen 6y agoPower lines are built from hydro power plants in the mountains to the cities. Obviously you know that so I don’t understand what you were trying to say.
- EdwardDiego 6y agoTBH, I'm confused about what you were trying to say. Unless you live in the coastal lowland countries of Europe, pretty much every country has some geography conducive to hydro. And what does the "sparse" (which implies thinly distributed, FYI, hence the person who replied to you specifying that it's actually quite dense in a localised area) population have to do with hydro or not?
- lightgreen 6y ago> TBH, I'm confused about what you were trying to say. Amount of hydro power capacity per capita in Scotland is much higher than say in Wales. > pretty much every country has some geography conducive to hydro This is simply not true. Availability of hydro in Switzerland is much better than for example in Lithuania.
- einpoklum 6y agoNot to belittle this achievement, but as one can note in the article itself this is the _electricity_ demand, not overall _energy_ demand. Electricity is under 25% of Scotland's energy demand (75% is just non-electric heating + transportation). Also, I think Scotland has it easier than other places due to the low(ish) population density, which makes wind-farming less problematic. And being on an island in windy seas.
- Aachen 6y agoStill, it's worth applauding. Though you're very right that the layman reader will see this as "we're almost there" whereas getting total electricity production to match demand on average is really only the first few percent of the work ahead.
- martinald 6y agoReally misleading article IMO. What this actually means is Scotland sometimes generated 200-300%+ of its demand from wind (and "exported" the rest), and sometimes low %age points and used other sources/imports. It makes it sound like Scotland is wind powered 97% of the time (only 3% more to go!), which is very different. There is an increasing crisis in the UK of negative electricity prices (typically when it is sunny, windy and lower demand in the summer). Last year had more time than ever in negative, and the UK has another 10-20GW of commited offshore wind in construction. Once this comes online, wind generation will often be over 100% of demand UK wide (right now it peaks over 50% regularly). There is approx 5GW of HVDC (with 1-2/GW a year more planned over the next while), but it won't be enough to export all of it outside the UK (and when it is windy here, it is likely to also be there, so they won't want it either). This is going to end up with very negative prices for a lot of the time. Considering ~15% of UK supply is made up with nuclear, this is a real problem. You can't stop start nuclear like you can with gas. So we are going to have to pay massive sums of money to wind producers to shut off production. And we are still going need masses of gas backup which is going to be used increasingly inefficiently to pick up the slack. This may spur innovation in storage, but we are talking enormous quantities required in a very short period of time.
- eldaisfish 6y agospot on. Every time this comes up, it's the same BS. The actual figure for the UK grid (there is no separate Scotland grid) is just over 40% of net electrical energy demand supplied by renewable sources. If Scotland was severed from the grid it would require fossil fuels and nuclear just like the rest of the UK. The 97% figure is arrived at by taking British renewable energy that happens to be in Scotland and subtracting that against Scottish energy use. This is in no way accurate and ignores time - there are many periods of time where Scotland's wind turbines aren't spinning and the region is drawing power from the rest of the UK grid.
- AdmiralGinge 6y agoThis is something that never seems to come up in discussions on Scottish independence interestingly enough. I guess it'd be like Ireland and Northern Ireland where both jurisdictions use a common electricity market, unless politicians on either side throw their toys out of the pram which is highly likely in my opinion.
- helsinkiandrew 6y agoThis is good news but I wonder if reduction in demand due to Covid is the biggest factor in this: In 2020, average daily demand is 24% lower after lockdown than before. Also Scotland exported 20.4 TWh (and imported 1.1TWh) of electricity was this renewable? or was the 'dirty' power being exported.
- kjakm 6y agoThey also make £0.5-1bn in annual revenue from North Sea oil. It's an achievement for sure but it's like the Marlboro Man boasting he's quit smoking while still selling cigarettes to everyone else.
- Aachen 6y agoI'm not sure how valid an argument that is. If the Scotts didn't sell it, consumers would just buy it elsewhere. As non-fossil picks up, the demand and profit will just go down. Perhaps it's actually better to have the Scotts pump it up and transport the products to UK houses than getting it from across the planet. And oil is more than something you burn: the plastic itself is actually a carbon store (less CO2 to go in the air), we just have a problem keeping it out of nature and the production process needs electrification iirc (maybe there are also GHG byproducts, I don't recall atm).
- smcl 6y agoI don’t understand the hate. Sure Scotland isn’t carbon neutral, but this is still an impressive figure.
- ThomPete 6y agoelectricity is less than 20% of any countrys energy needs and it doesent actually mean that 97% of the electricity consumption came from wind. So misleading and politicized.
- steeve 6y agoITT: folks who advocate energy/electricity storage but haven't actually run the numbers, and thus are a few orders of magnitude off
- ic0n0cl4st 6y agoSeems like a great reason to invest in kinetic energy storage like this pumped hydroelectric reservoir in Wales. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ffestiniog_Power_Station?wprov=sfti1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ffestiniog_Power_Station?wprov...
- runeks 6y agoThat depends. E.g. if it costs $100bn to build enough of these to store the power needed to go from 97% to 100% then it may just not be worth it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- legohead 6y agoThere's gotta be a better word than "renewable" when referring to wind and solar. Trees are also a renewable resource...
- qwerty456127 6y agoIn Europe, “biomass power,” as it’s technically called, is now counted and subsidized as zero-emissions renewable energy. As a result, European utilities now import tons of wood from U.S. forests every year—and Europe’s supposedly eco-friendly economy now generates more energy from burning wood than from wind and solar combined. https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2021/03/26/biomass-carbon-climate-politics-477620?utm_source=pocket-newtab-intl-en https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2021/03/26/biomass-ca...