6 ms·
I think the problem is that you do not need 100% of your budget every year, but getting it back when you do need it is much harder than keeping it in the first
by Aeolun 6y ago
I think the problem is that you do not need 100% of your budget every year, but getting it back when you do need it is much harder than keeping it in the first place.
Definite case of misaligned incentives.
- pishpash 6y agoIf only there was a way to get things only when you need, like trading.
- crdrost 6y agoYep! The problem happens when you divide the safety buffer up in the first place. Safety buffers demand to be shared, when one part does not use all of its safety margin you want to transfer that to another system. Another surprising place where this happens is project scheduling. We budget time for each individual step of a project based on our guess of a 90% or 95% success rate, then our "old-timers' experience" kicks in and we double or triple our time for all the steps together, then our boss adds 50% before giving the estimate to their boss, which sounds gratuitous but it is to protect you because their boss looks at how grotesquely long the estimate is and barks out a cut of 20%, so the overall effect of those two is (3/2) × (4/5), so your boss still netted you a 20% buffer while making the skip-level feel very productive and important. Say the 50%-confidence-to-95%-confidence gives you 30% more time as safety buffer, and you only double the estimate, and the work that you missed in your initial assessment, while it's not gonna be say half the project, maybe generously it's a third of the project or so. So the project actually takes time 1.5 measured properly, you have together budgeted 1.3 × 2 × 1.2 = 3.12 time. The total project deadline is more than half composed of safety buffer. And we still consistently overrun~! But if Alice needs to work on some step after Bob, and Bob finishes early, when does Alice start on it? Usually not when Bob finishes. Alice has been told that Bob has until X deadline to complete, and has scheduled herself with other tasks until X. Bob says "I got done early!" and Alice says "that's great, I'm still working on other things but I will pick my tasks up right on time." Bob's safety buffer gets wasted. This does not always cause any impact to the deadline, but it does for the important steps. Of course, if you are a web developer you already know this intuitively because you work on servers, and you don't run your servers (Alice, for example) at 100% load, because if you do then you can't respond to new requests (Bob's completion event) with low latency. It's worth thinking about, in an efficient workplace, how much are you not working so that you have excess capacity to operate efficiently?
- ianmcgowan 6y agoIf you haven't already, check out the oft-referenced book "The Principles of Product Development Flow". Based on this comment you'd really like it. http://www.startuplessonslearned.com/2009/07/principles-of-product-development-flow.html http://www.startuplessonslearned.com/2009/07/principles-of-p...
- marcus_holmes 6y agoHave you ever thought of just accepting that you can't predict how long a project will take to complete? It's a revelation. You get to have some hard conversations with other managers. But in the end everyone finds it easier to deal with "it'll be ready when it's ready" rather than endless missed deadlines and overruns.
- Aeolun 6y agoIn my experience people vastly prefer their fantasies to reality.
- VSerge 6y agoIn my experience people demand fantasies, and will fight tooth and nail any encroachment on them by the reality that things never happen as they are planned. Although when I say this, I am thinking of one year and above kind of estimates. When people who are experts on the topic evaluate the work needed over a period of say 3 months, even in something as notoriously hard to plan as video game production, it can hold. This entails being willing to adjust scope and resources though, when planning, in order to ensure the objectives are likely to be met.
- rntksi 6y agoThis never worked in 15+ years I've been working. The people who did try that went out the door very soon once management realised some other person could tell them a date and they could plan their business around that date even though that date half of the time got missed anyhow.
- herbcso 6y agoI've never understood this about budgeting. So you allocate. A budget. These are fund YOU ARE PLANNING TO SPEND! So, OK, you DON'T spend them this year. Why the fuck don't you get to SAVE THAT MONEY!? No, instead you are punished for now spending it all and you cannot create a realistic budget for next year - why the hell not!? Sorry, but this frustrates the hell out of me! What am I missing here? What arcane bit of finance lore leads us down this path? Am I just hopelessly naive? Is acing money such a bad thing!? I just don't get it...
- hunter2_ 6y agoJust brainstorming, but maybe the irony is that your scenario somehow has even worse incentives? For example, building up that rollover number would gamify thriftiness greatly exceeding the typical "oops didn't spend it all," and think about the consequences of when you DIY something you're not the best at instead of hiring the pros.
- devnonymous 6y agoIt is about opportunity costs. The budget you did not spend could have been spent elsewhere in the meantime and since it didn't get invested elsewhere, it's not a savings, that's a net loss, because of course anything less than 100% utilisation of 100% of "resources", 100% of the time is a loss .. Or some such.
- littlestymaar 6y agoThat's probably because of this kind of reasoning that people just throw away money threw windows, because “gotta get rid of it all”.
- ianmcgowan 6y agoIf you don't reduce your budget next year, what does "save that money" mean to a department in a company? If this year I have 105% of last year's budget (because they always go up), what am I supposed to do with the 20% surplus from last year? Most companies wouldn't even have a place in your cost center to track a surplus, it's such a foreign concept. Zero based budgeting is one answer to the moral hazards of either over or under-estimating your budget on purpose. If each year you start with a blank spreadsheet and then add (with justification) expenses for the year, it avoids some of the pitfalls. Not a panacea however. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-based_budgeting#Advantages https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-based_budgeting#Advantage...
- hadsed 6y agoSeems it's the yearly cycle not matching up to the longer cycle of certain needs that's a problem.
- bottled_poe 6y agoWhy aren’t there rolling budgets over multiple years with annual reviews on spend?
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoBecause nobody in government has any incentive to do something that risks shrinking the size of the pie.
- EricE 6y agoDing Ding Ding! They aren't misaligned, they are flat-out perverse incentives.