5 ms·
everything about this article applies to arguing on the internet. it's really painful to watch these guidelines violated over and over. I think the worst viol
by dekhn 6y ago
everything about this article applies to arguing on the internet. it's really painful to watch these guidelines violated over and over. I think the worst violation is to immediately accuse anybody who disagrees with you as 'gaslighting'.
- mistermann 6y agoAlso: gish galloping.
- etrabroline 6y agoFortunately academia is supposed to be immune from that because you can write academic papers in response to one another without a time limit as in oral debate.
- labatyd 6y agoYou forgot screaming "whataboutism" anytime you try to introduce a comparable example to a topic where they are clearly arguing in bad faith. That has been the single greatest weapon in destroying true discourse that I have seen.
- dekhn 6y agothat's a good point. In many debates, I have to reply to people saying "whataboutism actually makes sense in this context".
- etrabroline 6y agoI have never heard "whataboutism" outside of hackernews and I have never seen it accompanied with an actual argument of _why_ an analogy doesnt apply. Any use of analogy can apparently be dismissed with that one word like its a magic spell.
- dekhn 6y agoI see it all the time at work (at a FAAMG company). It's just as silly in that context, and as lacking in supporting evidence.