5 ms·
Failing to raise the debt ceiling is not a US default. The US receives more than enough income to cover its debt service, which also has priority. Equating fail
by jerf 15y ago
Failing to raise the debt ceiling is not a US default. The US receives more than enough income to cover its debt service, which also has priority. Equating failure to raise the debt ceiling with a default is a political ploy that nobody seems particularly in a hurry to debunk as both sides thinks it serves their purpose; if we're really unlucky they'll turn it into a default for political points. What we don't have is enough income to also do everything else we want to do.
Some level of "default" via inflation I would agree with, though; it isn't "technically" default but it's certainly a way of unilaterally decreasing the amount of wealth the payoff of the debt entails and that certainly has many of the relevant characteristics of a default.
- timr 15y ago"Failing to raise the debt ceiling is not a US default. The US receives more than enough income to cover its debt service, which also has priority." That's a Republican party talking point, not a fact. Everyone knows that debt service has priority. They also know that it's non-trivial to just stop paying for other services, and that even if it were easy to do, it would be seen as a serious lapse of judgment by our creditors. You don't have to default to get hammered by rising interest rates on your debt; you merely have to look irresponsible enough to be a bad risk.
- jerf 15y agoPer my other reply, the word "default" means something, and I think we should resist the temptation offered by politicians to turn it into the semantic equivalent of a synonym for "bad... financial... thingy..." and then rush to apply it haphazardly to everything faintly resembling someone not receiving money they think they have a claim to. It may certainly be the case that our creditors would not take kindly to us ramming into the debt ceiling and hard-cutting off services. But if you fall into the "default/not-default" "bad thingy.../not bad thingy..." semantic trap, you're not looking at the real situation. Our creditors may not take kindly to us simply raising the debt ceiling indefinitely, either. Resist the false dilemma the politicians are trying to offer us by collapsing the domain of discourse like that; there's much more than just "raise it" and "not raise it".
- anamax 15y ago> They also know that it's non-trivial to just stop paying for other services, and that even if it were easy to do, it would be seen as a serious lapse of judgment by our creditors. Huh? (Hint: it's poor form to disparage something as a Repub talking point and then recite a Dem talking point without providing any support. The fact that we're dueling with talking points doesn't make both of them false - evidence does.) Every creditor I've encountered says "don't pay them/buy food/go on vacation/buy a new car, pay me". Why would US' creditors be any different? Put it another way - do you really think "we're going to keep spending way beyond our revenues" is something that the US creditors view as a good thing? (It's not like we're spending on things that will produce future tax revenue.) The "debt ceiling" is a self-imposed line of credit. How does increasing it make the US a better credit risk? I ask because the lenders that I've dealt with looked at available credit and refused to loan if there was too much. Why? Because you might borrow and then be unable to repay their loans. Again - why would US creditors be any different?
- MaysonL 15y agoGiven that lenders seem extremely willing[1], one might say almost desparate, to lend to the US government, there doesn't seem to be any fear by our creditors that we won't repay. [1]Current 10-year T-bill rates around 3% per year mean that not borrowing as much as possible now seems downright stupid.
- anamax 15y ago> Current 10-year T-bill rates around 3% per year mean The fed is buying most of them now. The fed can keep doing that "forever", but that doesn't mean that our trading partners will keep selling us stuff cheap. Yes, the US is doing better than many countries, but that's not the same as good. > not borrowing as much as possible now seems downright stupid. It depends on what you do with the money you borrow. Spending it on beer and skittles is different than investing it in something that will give a decent return, or even saving it as part of an interest rate prediction. And yes, I objected when Bush pushed through his $1T prescription drug monstrosity and other things. That said, the last yearly deficit with a Repub congress was about the same as the current monthly deficit. Starting from Bush's hole, it seems silly to dig faster.
- MaysonL 15y agoYou go ahead and tell that to the Social Security recipients whose money doesn't show up, or Pentagon contractors whose bills don't get paid, etc., etc.. Or people who get laid off in the second dip, after a few hundred thousand government workers get furloughed.
- jerf 15y agoTell them what? That the word "default" is not the correct word to apply to their situation, but instead they've been something closer to "laid off"? (I say "closer to" because historically they end up getting paid anyhow, just later; a hardship, yes, but "tell all the actively unemployed how much of a hardship that is".) They won't care, but I don't think it's for the reason you think. I do not see how the fact that some people aren't going to be paid on time or possible at all requires us to apply the term "default" in a haphazard, nonstandard way. You don't "default" on a paycheck. It isn't a good thing, but it's something else.
- MaysonL 15y agoTell them they haven't been screwed by the Congressnuts who caused the failure to pay, whatever in hell you want to call it.