6 ms·
One issue - real estate prices going up is not 'economic gain', its a drain on productive population. Nothing is actually produced in the real economy Imagine
by ClumsyPilot 6y ago
One issue - real estate prices going up is not 'economic gain', its a drain on productive population. Nothing is actually produced in the real economy
Imagine we talked about anything else like that: 'bread is getting more expensive by the minute in Germany" - thats not a sign of doing well.
We all pay for this real estate not just in rent, every time we get a coffee a good chunk of that price is paying someone else's rent. In wages.
Just because you are a homeowner does not mean its in your interest for realestate to go up, any more than if you own a fridge it would be in your interest for fridge prices to go up. Anyone who ever plans to trade up to a bigger home, has kids that will need to buy a house, or needs local economy to function does not benefit net from house prices going up. The only time you profit is if you are a massive landowner or real estate business.
Its literally blood-sucking leech
The economy is doing well when neccessities of life such as housing, food, etc. Are as cheap as possible and then you do not spend 90% of your effort and income just to keep wolf from the door.
This disconnect between how we thing about housing and other goods is like a collective madness of oursociety
- db48x 6y agoThis is not quite true. The price of real estate is a function of demand. If more people want to acquire the same property (whether to live there, or to work there, or to grow something there), then the price of the property will go up. This is a good thing because over time it ensures that properties are used for the most desiriable and profitable purposes.
- freeone3000 6y agoThis is not a good thing, because people need to live somewhere, and this is likely not the most profitable thing to do with a given piece of land.
- db48x 6y agoOn the contrary. Businesses need employees, and if there are fewer people living in an area then the cost of the employees goes up and the profitability of the businesses go down.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoHow does that in any way prove that housing is the most profitable thing to do with that land? Starbucks in London is staffed with poor sods who travel for 2 hours from outside the city to take their shift for hardly above minimum wage.
- exporectomy 6y agoMinimum wage is a distortion of the market. Without that, this Starbucks would have to pay a higher wage than a Starbucks in a cheap-housing area. For jobs that pay above minimum wage, that's what already happens.
- freeone3000 6y agoYou're saying that minimum wage is somehow providing a ceiling? This is nonsense. It's a distortion in that if Starbucks was allowed to, Starbucks would pay less, not more. If they had to pay more to attract employees, they would pay more -- nothing's stopping them from doing that today. The fact that they're paying minimum wage means that the clearing price for Starbucks labor is at or below the floor already!
- db48x 6y agoIf the minimum wage were lower, then the Starbucks could open a store 2 hours away from the city. The employees there would earn less than the employees in the city, but they wouldn’t have to commute two hours each way either. As it is, the customer base in that location outside the city cannot support the minimum wage that Starbucks is required to pay. (Not to mention all of the other costs that Starbucks has; wages are not the only factor that keeps them out of small towns and villages. Starbucks is really a luxury product compared to an inexpensive coffee machine.)
- freeone3000 6y agoYes, but that would mean the employees that work at this out-of-the-way location would be paid less than the city centre, not that those in the centre would get paid more. The issue is that even in the city centre, the labor clearing cost isn't high enough to afford for its employees to live in the city centre. If its employees were paid less, they would have to live in even more undesirable locations -- and there is a floor on how bad living conditions can be, so a rural Starbucks' labor clearing cost would be below what would be required to live anywhere.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoThe price of food is a function of demand and supply. If there is a famine, price of food goes up. This is a good thing because it ensures that food is used by the most productive and profitable citizens, right? We have more empty houses than homeless people. Efficient market my ass. Currently the most profitable use of land in London is building luxury apartments that are bough by Saudi and Russian billionaires who never live there or even let them out. They wait for their price to go up even more. During covid 700,000 people left London, but real estate prices grew.
- db48x 6y ago> The price of food is a function of demand and supply. If there is a famine, price of food goes up. This is a good thing because it ensures that food is used by the most productive and profitable citizens, right? Increasing food prices cause more food to be grown and food to be shipped over longer distances, lessening the impact of a famine. It also causes people to spend less on luxury foods that cost more per calorie. > We have more empty houses than homeless people. Efficient market my ass. Have you bought an unused home and given it to someone homeless lately? There are many that are quite inexpensive out there. On the whole, I agree that our current housing and property market is not as efficient as it could be. One reason for this are our building codes; they raise the cost of housing making truly inexpensive homes illegal. There is definitely a lot of benefits to living in a properly–built house, but that is always going to be more expensive than a shack you built yourself on land you claimed from the wilderness at the edge of a growing population. When governments eliminate that possibility, they cause people to go homeless. I suspect that you will want to “fix” this by having the government step in and buy a house for everyone who wants one. The bureaucracy expands to meet the needs of the expanding bureaucracy.
- sudosysgen 6y ago>Increasing food prices cause more food to be grown and food to be shipped over longer distances, lessening the impact of a famine. It also causes people to spend less on luxury foods that cost more per calorie. Yes, this doesn't work with land.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoThe price of houses is determined by the ease (or difficulty) of acquiring debt. Not much more than that. If you want to know what the average price of a home will be in an area, simply find the average maximum mortgage that a financial institution will provide for the average income in the area. Interest rates go down, housing prices go up. What people are buying is not a house, but a loan. The cheaper the loan, the more they buy.
- db48x 6y agoThat is also true! However, in a hypothetical world where loans didn’t exist, then the effects of demand would still exist. There would be a lot of other problems in that hypothetical would though; loans are a very important tool for economic growth because in their purest form they allow someone with money to put it to good use while sharing the profits with the person they loaned it to. I think the real problem isn’t the loans but rather the government putting their thumb on the scales.
- electrograv 6y agoWhat you describe would be a healthy form of lending (lending out money you otherwise have sitting around, so it can be put to good use). Unfortunately, this is not actually how our global financial systems work. I think most people would be shocked to learn that when a bank lends out money, they are actually “cloning” their money many times over: each dollar from their reserves actually gets loaned out multiple times over, to multiple people (such that e.g. 100 people all have claim to the same 1 “real” dollar that exists, although it’s not actually tracked that way). But because almost nobody uses physical cash any more in large quantities, no actual cash needs to be printed to cover this. Then, if/when the loan is later repaid (which again is not a physical transaction, but occurs as numbers being updated in balance sheets), the repaid “clones” get “erased” from circulation, and only the real original reserves remain [1]. The banks keep the (greatly multiplied) interest paid though as profit. You (as a mere peasant) are not allowed to clone your money and lend/invest it out, but banks are (in fact, this is essentially what makes a bank a bank), and it’s called “fractional reserve banking”. Some argue that this is very unfair, and argue that this is actually the root cause of a lot of financial problems and wealth inequality in the world. For example, this system inflates prices (usually starting with investment assets like land, stocks, etc. but can later trickle down and in very delayed way start to inflate food prices etc. too), due to this expansion of the money supply (commonly called “money printing” even though no actual printing needs to occur) being funneled through financial institutions and into various investment assets and derivatives. [1] Note that in practice, the total amount of outstanding debt tends to increase over time, because old debt just ends up getting replaced/refinanced with newer debt of even larger size (e.g. due to decreasing interest rates). This creates a system where the global economy is essentially “addicted” to perpetually increasing amounts of debt. The official stance though is that central banks should be able to unwind this debt when we are in good economic health, but this is debated; for example, I don’t know of any case in modern history where overall money supply has actually been decreased without markets immediately panicking and starting to crash (after which the central banks always quickly give in and reverse course, usually re-inflating the money supply far more than even before).
- ipnon 6y agoThis is an important distinction that you correctly point out. We may imagine the current housing related issues endemic to California may worsen given homeowners will have even more incentive than currently to impede housing development.
- aqme28 6y agoYou're absolutely right, but it doesn't negate OPs point. They should have said that the value of houses in smog-ridden areas will go up, which is independent of their price.
- darkerside 6y agoI always thought inflation was a dangerous potential side effect of a booking economy, and that deflation was much more dangerous. If the baker can't sell their bread unless they charge pennies for it, it's probably a sign that people can't buy much of anything else either. IANAE
- mac01021 6y ago> IANAE I'm not sure professional economists are either...
- HPsquared 6y agoDebt is what makes deflation hazardous to people. A non-indebted baker may have to sell his bread for pennies, but the things he then needs to buy would also cost pennies so he'd end up in a similar position. However if the baker is paid in pennies, has cost-of-living in pennies, but owes the banker £1000000 for his bakery shop, this causes problems. Same with back taxes etc. On the other side, inflation is hazardous to creditors: the lender gets back less than they originally gave out (creditors also include those holding bank deposits)
- darkerside 6y agoIf you owe the bank $10,000 you have a problem. If you owe the bank $10,000,000 the bank has a problem. Seems like the creditors are potentially unhappy either way. Debt aside, I would maintain that if people can barely afford bread, they are likely not buying cars, washing machines, or other more expensive items. That seems like a recipe for a vicious cycle where society ends up regressing towards individualism and barter, with less economic strength.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- newyankee 6y agoHonestly i do not see why the 10x mentality being applied to things like EVs and other stuff can not be applied to houses/cities. Build a highly vertical and optimized city from scratch with its own energy & water sources and attract people and businesses. If you can undercut existing cities by a factor of 3 or more i am sure new people will come. Some incentive to avoid typical real estate inflation where investors jump in first needs to be put in for a successful experiment with goals that are beyond monetary concerns.
- beckman466 6y ago> Build a highly vertical and optimized city from scratch Are you aware that continuing to build tall buildings murders the planet, and thus humanity? [1] [2] Does your proposal include any sort of mitigation for the environmental impacts of building tall buildings and using cement (as revealed by researchers in the articles below), or is this Silicon Valley "technological solutionism" [3] together with a belief in "The Californian Ideology" (both of which posit that any problem can be solved with a technological innovation, instead of by actually addressing the underlying socio-economic of the previous solutionist strategy), by someone who has unfortunately fallen victim to the fallacy of transferable expertise? [1] https://theguardian.com/cities/2019/feb/25/concrete-the-most-destructive-material-on-earth https://theguardian.com/cities/2019/feb/25/concrete-the-most... [2] https://theguardian.com/artanddesign/2020/jul/11/skyscrapers-wasteful-damaging-outmoded-time-to-stop-tall-buildings https://theguardian.com/artanddesign/2020/jul/11/skyscrapers... [3] https://technofilosofie.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/Course_One_Interview-Solutionism.pdf https://technofilosofie.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/Cours...
- kilotaras 6y agoThe words "per capita" or "per apartment" are not in the article. I completely buy that skyscraper have higher fixed costs then lower buildings. It can be true that the optimal height from energy expenditure per capita would be 5, 8 or 12 stories. Or it can be false and sckyscrapers are the best energy investment per square feet of living space created. Your links don't provide any evidence either way.
- oceanplexian 6y agoReal estate prices going up is a "net gain" because it promotes new construction. Those new constructions were built out of thin air (Well, perhaps some raw materials and labor), but regardless new value is being created when real estate prices increase.
- beckman466 6y ago> We all pay for this real estate not just in rent, every time we get a coffee a good chunk of that price is paying someone else's rent. In wages. Beautifully put. This is a point I don't see often enough. Why should a system allow one person to own two homes and then rent one of them out and use it to pay off mortgages for both. Housing is a human right. Vienna is a beautiful example of this: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2017/dec/12/vienna-housing-policy-uk-rent-controls https://www.theguardian.com/society/2017/dec/12/vienna-housi...
- stjohnswarts 6y agoBecause we don't live in an autocracy. There is plenty land to build new houses if you're so inclined. Someone is still living in the second house.
- userulluipeste 6y agoThis is beautiful only if you're not affected by unpleasant consequences. These may be (1) reduced number of available rent-able spaces (i.e. less offer on the market) due to the capped/reduced profit which cause a decrease in the number of listed properties (it's not worth renting), which rises the demand for the remaining available listings, then (2) little to no opportunity whatsoever for new renters to access desirable locations, as those are already occupied. A system involving rent controls may be easy to sell because it's a solution designed to satisfy existing tenants on the expense of prospective tenants. That doesn't make it a more fair system than one that operates on free market. Then if that's not enough, we have to be aware that when the market laws aren't the one that rule, other things are. For example, in the communist setting housing were provided "fairly" to anyone, so that the desirable locations had in them apparently all kinds of people. Only that many times the selection were far from random and you could bet value (in various forms) had to be exchanged under table. So Vienna? I wouldn't be surprised if on a closer look I'd find something gaming the system at some level. Let's say, (hypothetically) that some club rents out properties to its members, and whereas rents are regulated, club membership fees aren't.
- beckman466 6y ago
- SergeAx 6y agoHigher real estate price doesn't necessary mean higher rent. Why it is not in my interest if I can resell my fridge with upside after several years of using it?