7 ms·
Have they fixed the file chooser yet? Specifically, I want to be able to click around on directories to choose where to save a file, type the file name, then p
by hedora 6y ago
Have they fixed the file chooser yet?
Specifically, I want to be able to click around on directories to choose where to save a file, type the file name, then press enter. This should save the file, not filter the directory listing.
Also, I don’t want it to default to overwriting some file I saved last week.
- brian_herman 6y agoI also want them to just make it so I can right click and create a new empty file. Linux is file based right? If I right click on a opened folder I want to create a file.
- turbinerneiter 6y agoYou can do that, make a folder called Templates and put your templates in there. Or maybe I'm misunderstanding.
- brian_herman 6y agoI thought that was only on KDE...
- wayneftw 6y agoAgreed 100%. As soon as the dialog opens, I usually just want to start typing the file name to save and then press enter to save. The workaround is that I must remember to hit Alt+N to focus on the filename box before typing. Usually I forget though.
- superkuh 6y agoNo. I actually went to GNOME's IRC network the other day to talk to them about gtkfilechooser's multiple problems. Yours, and then the lack of text input for typing or pasting file paths. https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gtk/-/issues/938 https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gtk/-/issues/938 . They said they have no one assigned to gtkfilechooser bugs and none will be addressed. I was able to download the debian source for a couple gtk applications (ie, gedit/pluma) and apply community sourced patches to them to get back the text/file path entry box. But there's no way I am going to be able to fix Gtk itself. And fixing every application on my system by compiling from source and making new debian packages, well, I might as well linux from scratch.
- nerdponx 6y agoPurely out of curiosity, what else is the Gtk team currently working on? People have been complaining about the file chooser for years. I'd be willing to donate a good chunk of money just to support "basic UX" improvements to FOSS software and toolkits like Gtk. Should we start a "Fix the Gtk file chooser" Gofundme?
- ahartmetz 6y agoIt's more like decades, not years, by now. Seems worthwhile.
- turminal 6y ago> Purely out of curiosity, what else is the Gtk team currently working on? Probably redesigning the entire interface. "For your convenience".
- merb 6y agowhich they also do for years.
- TingPing 6y agoThe GTK team is like 3 people. GTK4 worked on improved cross-platform support, effecient gpu rendering, documentation, sandbox integration, etc. UI designers are probably limited and there is just a lot of drama about the filechooser so it's easy to find other things to work on.
- hda2 6y agoThe patches already exist. In fact, PopOs! already has this feature merged.
- superkuh 6y agoI searched PopOs! repos and I couldn't find where they maintained their Gtk-3.0 patches or code. It didn't look to me like they altered Gtk-3.0 itself at all and likely just altered individual applications.
- stockerta 6y agoProbably they will deprecate it soon, and gnome apps will randomly open a file for you. Just to be easier to use. A file picker dialog can confuse the user.
- hallarempt 6y agoWell, given that that's what macOS Big Sur has done, it's a dead cert. You no longer get a file picker dialog by default when saving, but a place where you can type a name and a label that says where saving will happen.
- gh-throw 6y agoWhere do you see that? I tried hitting cmd+s in Safari, Terminal, and Pages and got a normal macOS file-save dialog in all three cases. Looks more or less the same as it has for quite a while. I haven't touched anything related to file save settings (I probably should, as I'd like the arrow-down-to-browse-files to always be expanded, and I know there's a setting for that somewhere, just haven't bothered to yet).
- e_proxus 6y agoI think they complain about the fact that the file dialog is collapsed by default, going to some length to hide the browse functionality (Apple probably wants you to save everything in Documents and be done with it). The save dialog can be expanded by default by tweaking it though: https://github.com/mathiasbynens/dotfiles/blob/master/.macos#L52-L53 https://github.com/mathiasbynens/dotfiles/blob/master/.macos...
- dasweffar 6y agoI've lurked on HN for more than a decade but created an account to concur with this comment. Accidentally filtering for folders (who even wants this) instead of typing a filename is truly awful and affects me daily. I would bail on gnome for this issue alone if I didn't have to use it on a work machine. Does anyone know of an issue in their tracker with an official stance on it?
- hollerith 6y ago>I would bail on gnome for this issue alone if I didn't have to use it on a work machine. Both Google Chrome and Firefox use GTK's file picker (at least when "saving link as..." at least on Fedora 34 Prerelease) so what would you do for a web browser?
- yyyk 6y ago>what would you do for a web browser? If your environment has a xdg portal port (KDE does), you can use the relevant portal. Set GTK_USE_PORTAL=1 , and then firefox uses the native file picker.
- MarkyC4 6y agoProbably something like[1]: Because of the release of GNOME $next, and the lack of interest in maintainership of GNOME $prev, the gnome-core product is being closed. If you feel your bug is still of relevance to GNOME $next, please reopen it and refile it against a more appropriate component. Thanks... [1] adapted from: https://www.jwz.org/doc/cadt.html https://www.jwz.org/doc/cadt.html
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- christophilus 6y agoGnome is my daily driver, and overall I'm a fan. But this is one of the dumbest file pickers I've seen.
- amelius 6y agoAlso, the file chooser should show previews, like in Nautilus.