6 ms·
It seems like we have the answer to "should you use a time machine to kill Hitler": no, HN will definitely quibble with you if you do that. I'm also reminded o
by pjc50 6y ago
It seems like we have the answer to "should you use a time machine to kill Hitler": no, HN will definitely quibble with you if you do that.
I'm also reminded of the term "premature anti-fascist", used against people who were against Fascism too early before WW2.
- filmfact 6y agoPerhaps HN is of the opinion that you shouldn’t mix politics and violence?
- Ar-Curunir 6y agoThen HN is, for the lack of a better word, foolish. Politics is violence. What do you think the military does? What do you think the prison system does does? What do you think the police do? These are all political institutions, and they are all violent; it’s just that the target of the violence is maybe easier for some to ignore (poor black and brown people)
- filmfact 6y agoCool. So rather than vote - shoot? Thomas Mair didn’t like the Jo Coxs politics so he took a shot too. I guess you’ll be setting up a kickstarter for a plaque for him too?
- n4r9 6y agoThe point seems to be that violence is inherent to politics, therefore does not on its own render an act unjustifiable; not that all violence for political purpose is justified.
- filmfact 6y agoOnly the kind that hurts people whose politics you don’t agree with is justified? Cool
- colinb 6y agoYou ask questions rather than state a position, so I'm not actually sure what your position is. Do you reject all violence? Under all circumstances? Some think that to be admirable. I think it's nonsense.
- filmfact 6y agoI reject putting up plaques to praise attempted murderers for the reason that it sets a bad example.
- n4r9 6y agoIt's just pointing out that all political power in this world is ultimately held through the direct or indirect threat of violence. It's not a moral judgement but a fact of the world. If my "politics" disagrees with those of the state, in that I don't believe people have a right to personal property, and that the police have no right to arrest me, then ultimately what will happen is violence against me by the state.
- filmfact 6y agoYou could also abide by the law while voting for a party that supported whatever minority viewpoint you held. Of course if you voiced unpopular opinions publicly you might get shot by someone who cites Violet Gibson or Thomas Mair as an inspiration. Or you know - we could not put up plaques to attempted murderers.
- n4r9 6y agoYes everyone could go around abiding the law all the time, and we could skip the Gordon riots, the suffragettes, the battle of Cable Street etc... . I'm glad that's not the world we live in and that people have the courage to follow through with their convictions against state oppression, with violence if need be.
- filmfact 6y ago
- toyg 6y agoThat’s an overgeneralization. It’s like saying that, because a car’s dashboard is made of plastic, the whole car is inherently plastic. The state has a monopoly on violence, as famously stated, but is not necessarily made of violence, nor should its governance and policy-creation mechanisms necessarily include violence. In fact, the main characteristic of modern democratic institutions is that they removed violence from most of the process.
- Ar-Curunir 6y agoNo, they only made violence hidden. Is incarceration nonviolent? What would happen if a prisoner decided to leave prison?
- torstenvl 6y agoThis seems a little sophistic. Yes, incarceration is not actually violent. It may be "violent" in some metaphorical sense, and some of the other inmates may be violent, but incarceration itself is not violent. I've had clients get incarcerated, and I've had clients facing potential capital sentences, and there is a world of difference.
- watwut 6y agoGenerally, my impression is that HN is not against such thing. Nevertheless, when we are talking about Mussolini or 1926, violence and politics were mixed. There was no such thing as politics without mix of violence, because the question of "who should we be violent against" was the major political question of the time. Moreover at that time, Mussoliny himself was source of a lot of that violence.
- zxcvbn4038 6y agoBefore using a time machine to kill Hitler you should brush up on your German, all of the potential successors were a lot more stable, the war might have ended very differently if Göring or Goebbels came to power. As the saying goes, Hitler was the best general the Allies had. If the US had entered the war a week later or if Germany did not declare war on the Soviet Union, the outcome would have likely have been in Germany’s favor.
- anoncake 6y agoVery unlikely. Germany had no chance of invading Britain as its navy was a joke. Without invading the Soviet Union, it would have run out of oil even faster than it historically did, crippling its ability to defend against bombing attacks. Without an Eastern Front, more troops may have been available to defend against a naval invasion. But eventually, Stalin would have likely opened the front himself. Even if not, a lot of troops would have been necessary to guard against a possible Soviet invasion anyway.