4 ms·
There is nothing wrong with an attempt of assassination of a fascist genocidal dictator. There is actually no other way of improving things. I don't see either
by sudosysgen 6y ago
There is nothing wrong with an attempt of assassination of a fascist genocidal dictator. There is actually no other way of improving things.
I don't see either why one should oppose a plaque for John Brown.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- waterhouse 6y agoSo, how many current world leaders would be on your "justifiable to assassinate" list? Kim Jong-un, perhaps? Should it be official U.S. policy to have the CIA working on trying to kill him? Kim Jong-un presumably thinks we're just as evil as we might think he is; should he feel justified in trying to assassinate the leaders of Western countries? How about Putin, people say he jails his political opponents and rigs his elections, does he count? Should there be a Cold War of Assassination going on?
- Synaesthesia 6y agoWhy not start with the leaders of the USA, Israel and the West for their notorious war crimes? At least North Korea hasn't invaded anyone for the last 60 years. As they said in the Nuremberg trials, aggression is the ultimate war crimes, a capital one.
- anoncake 6y agoTo kill the leaders of democracies would be genocide.
- throwaway210222 6y ago"USA, Israel and the West" What is the point of including the USA and Israel if you are going to append the West? Or was it too hard to list the individual perpetrators and just went for what felt good? [PS. Not a westerner]
- sudosysgen 6y agoKilling Kim Jong Un will not make anything better. Foreign state assasinations especially never work out. Homegrown assasinations of fascist leaders whose basis for power is a projection of strength and a cult of personality, with strong existing domestic oppositions? That's very different in outcome.
- filmfact 6y agoI didn’t realize Violet Gibson was Italian.
- toyg 6y agoShe had been living in Italy for 4 years at that point.
- filmfact 6y agoHardly home grown, also I’m 99% sure she had been in Italy for less than 2 years before her attack (November 1924 - April 1926). By that measure 9-11 was home grown!
- toyg 6y agoAccording to this [0] she had moved to Rome in 1922. Unlike 9-11ers, she didn’t move to the country explicitly to perform the action; she likely grew to dislike Mussolini by spending time in the country. By that metric, I’d call it home-grown. [0] https://m.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/life/features/profile-violet-gibson-the-irish-woman-who-shot-mussolini-34591366.html https://m.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/life/features/profile-viole...
- filmfact 6y agohttps://dib.cambridge.org/viewReadPage.do?articleId=a10139 https://dib.cambridge.org/viewReadPage.do?articleId=a10139 Says 1924, and that she was already toying with the idea of martyrdom.
- tomc1985 6y agoI mean sure, and they're certainly welcome to try. But the balance of world power, and all the things those powers do to ensure that power, almost certainly guarantees failure.
- filmfact 6y agoBut at the time she pulled the trigger, he was neither a dictator or genocidal. Perhaps violence is the right way to address all people who have politics we don’t agree with? Thomas Mair agrees with you.
- toyg 6y ago> at the time she pulled the trigger, he was neither a dictator or genocidal Historians typically mark the official beginning of Mussolini’s dictatorship in 1924, when, following the assassination of socialist MP Giacomo Matteotti by fascists and the subsequent clamour, he went to Parliament and basically told MPs to “shut up or else”. And let’s not forget that he had been appointed Prime Minister with a de-facto coup in 1922. As for “genocidal”, I’m not sure what parameters could be used. The infamous invasion of Ethiopia with chemical weapons had not happened yet, and obviously the Racial Laws were a long way away, but he had already begun the “pacification” of Libya (war started in 1923). Also, political violence against the opposition was already large-scale, as shown with Matteotti. By 1926 it was pretty clear he wasn’t a simple political leader for sure, and he had already spoken at length against representative democracy. Whether that deserved an assassination attempt, is debatable; but there is little question that by 1926 he could be defined as a violent dictator.
- sudosysgen 6y agoWhether political violence is warranted rests upon three factors. Firstly, one must consider if you are initiating political violence or simply reacting - which sadly is necessary. Mussolini obviously had instigated political violence much before. Then, one must consider efficacy - if it's going to be useless then why bother? Finally, one must consider the presence of altermatives. If you can at all avoid it, then political violence is not really justifiable. In this case, the three elements converged, and it's in those cases that political violence can be warranted if done for good. This isn't even controversial, people defend the violence of the US Founding Fathers which engaged in much more violence for much, much, much less.
- filmfact 6y agoI fundamentally disagree. On such a basis a white supremisist could justify murder against the ‘violent’ state in the absence of the possibilty of being elected. Presumably on that basis you see the killing of Jo Cox as justified?