7 ms·
> However, CCP’s resistance to a proper thorough study of the origins of COVID is IMO not exactly appropriate. It is, in fact, highly suspect. I’m not at all p
by Aeolun 6y ago
> However, CCP’s resistance to a proper thorough study of the origins of COVID is IMO not exactly appropriate.
It is, in fact, highly suspect. I’m not at all positive that it indeed leaked from a lab in Wuhan, but the fact they won’t let an independent investigation anywhere near it makes me lean more strongly towards that as a possibility.
The description of the last investigation into the origins of the virus felt more like a ‘guided tour’.
- agumonkey 6y agoIt can be pride over shame of incompetence maybe ? the wuhan labs are said to be lacking in standard safety biohazard practices.. so investigating may reveal that.
- marcus_holmes 6y agoYou gotta remember the culture, and that everything in China is political. You can't just say "oops" and learn the lessons. Any investigations will have the goal not of finding the truth, but of minimising damage to the political powers that control it.
- refenestrator 6y agoThat's not a cultural thing, it's a universal human/organizational thing.
- acdha 6y agoIt’s certainly widespread but the cultural component is important to how strong the reaction is. China certainly isn’t alone in having it but the political stakes are a powerful amplifier.
- refenestrator 6y agoThe cultural component is just flavor. Who suffered consequences for getting Iraq wrong, or the financial crisis? Fortune passes everywhere.
- acdha 6y agoOkay, think about that one a bit: in the U.S., power shifted peacefully and a bunch of Republicans left the Bush administration to the private sector and academia because we have a strong tradition of not pursuing political opponents. That is not true of China’s system and not having separate power hierarchies means that you can’t just say, pull a Katrina, and fail upwards into a well-paid private job with no impact on your family. Nobody’s kids are being banned from going to Yale because their dad was publicly shown as incompetent or dishonest. The more that isn’t true, the more it’s unsurprising to see people have the instinct to reach for political damage control when the problem is still raging.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- WildParser 6y agoI don't know about China, but the whole science around COVID seems to have a really strong cultural component that before was totally unfamiliar to me. When looking at some German Epidemiologist blog I found something like: "Next thing on the list is to proof that government measures worked" I would have expected something like: "I'm looking at data - and want to find out what helps"
- agumonkey 6y agoyeah I agree that political context acts as an amplifier.. every country have it's own flavor but China like USSR is still fond of secrecy and murder..
- ergocoder 6y agoEvery time when there's a question about China's bad behaviour, someone will point out that it happens everywhere. Yes, but in a vastly different degree, China goes to an extreme of making it political and look good. In US, most leaks don't look good. Sure, US tries to make some problems look good, but they don't try very hard (or there's more balance in how an issue is investigated with multiple different parties).
- tweetle_beetle 6y agoThat is true, but the difference is the lack of accountability, which is cultural/societal/political - there are virtually no external forces to counter a potentially dishonest official narrative. A one party state means that there is no pressure from political opponents (political battles inside the party will never trump the party itself). And there is no pressure from journalists - China has the worst score for press freedom [1] (bar Eritreaa, Turkmenistan and North Korea) with a downward trend over the last decade. If there's no one to hold your feet to the fire, there's little incentive to self-incriminate. [1] https://rsf.org/en/china https://rsf.org/en/china
- refenestrator 6y agoIn theory that might be true, and it's the way they teach it in American civics class. In practice, Xi went on an 'anti-corruption campaign' that purged all his political enemies from power as his first initiative. The exact opposite of what your theory predicts, and actually a stronger cyclical purge than our typical repubs->dems->repubs one.
- tweetle_beetle 6y agoThe campaign was a unique event in decades of party history and the Wikipedia page for the campaign lists 4 different theories for political motives. I'm not sure you can view it as a sign of a culture of healthy accountability. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-corruption_campaign_under_Xi_Jinping#Political_motives https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-corruption_campaign_under...
- refenestrator 6y agoThe point remains that they have politics. It's not some lockstep monolith. As far as which culture has more healthy accountability.. plenty of corruption to go around on all sides, the comparison would be pretty nuanced. I'd say that China has a lot more low-level corruption, as a bigger % of their economy, what with large swaths of the country being pretty third-world, but also more accountability for senior people who fuck up badly. They executed a baby food exec who poisoned kids, while nobody saw a day in jail for poisoning the city of Flint. Rick Snyder probably has a nice lobbyist job. Or, look at Covid -- the mayor of Wuhan and governor of Hubei were sacked over their poor initial handling. Is NY gonna elect a Republican over it? TX elect a Democrat? No way in either case. Maybe we have less accountability in some ways specifically due to the 2-party system's polarization. Arguably Trump lost over it, but the guy literally got covid, right before the election, after downplaying it for 6 months and still got the 2nd most votes in history.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> Any investigations will have the goal not of finding the truth, but of minimising damage to the political powers that control it. This seems sufficient to explain why China wouldn't be interested in a foreign investigation into their labs.
- dominotw 6y agobut what the motivations of us scientists like Peter Daszak who were single handedly responsible for suppressing lab leak theory. It wasn't the ccp, it was Peter Daszak and co.
- ethbr0 6y agoOr, you know, we may just be talking about a paranoid autocracy with an obsession for controlling information? This is a government that bans talking about multiple periods of the country's history.
- bitreality 6y agoFor that very reason, we cannot accept their narrative at face value. We certainly don't have enough information to confidently eliminate the lab escape theory. The media has largely suggested that the lab escape theory has been disproved.
- ethbr0 6y agoIf you ask a liar a question, and they lie, then the strongest conclusion isn't that you asked the right question -- it's that they're a liar. China stonewalls pretty much every attempt by the international community to interfere with their internal control. So this is more "business as usual" than "Clouseau found the smoking gun."
- bitreality 6y agoThe smoking gun is that labs in Wuhan were studying different coronaviruses in bats at the time the virus emerged. One of those labs was right near the seafood market which had one of the first documented outbreaks. It's all circumstantial evidence of course, but that's really all you're going to get with a country like China. We can be damn well sure that they would never admit to the virus originating from a lab leak. To me, this is the clearest and most likely source of the outbreak.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- the-dude 6y agoCould you please define "right near" ? Are we talking about the lab ~10km away ?
- incompatible 6y agoI don't think that's quite accurate: https://thewest.com.au/news/health/who-team-visits-wuhan-research-lab-ng-s-2047939 https://thewest.com.au/news/health/who-team-visits-wuhan-res...
- zensavona 6y agoExcept that it was (allegedly) a whole load of BS https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=evHFsNSMTLM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=evHFsNSMTLM
- hungryhobo 6y agoYou have to keep in mind laowhy86 isn't exactly know to be impartial
- coupdejarnac 6y agoHow so? Be specific.
- bmn__ 6y agoI make no moral judgement about impartiality. Work out the implications yourself. I make no comment about the content of the video linked in GGP's post. That being said, the following is publicly known (but unverified by me) and quite apt to affect impartiality (whether under his control or not, whether consciously or not): 1. He was persecuted in China by the authorities and barely escaped with the posessions on his body. 2. He is currently under attack by brigades and agents of the persons he is critical of. The attacks follow standard psychological warfare patterns, including death threats to himself and the family. Additionally, some speculation from me: 3. He has no journalistic training, both his business partner and his peers in the wider YT/Patreon business don't have either, and to me it seems both content producer and audience have come to a shared understanding that the shows are primarily entertainment and should not be held to the same rigour of journalistic integrity one would expect from e.g. a traditional print periodical. Adv Media's income entirely depends on YT/Patreon, and employing sensationalism – which results in uneven amplification of the reported reality – brings in more money. I haven't seen a completely sober/dry video.
- KMag 6y agoI think many bureaucrats everywhere view the press as an annoyance, but in places where they're used be being able to push the press around, pushing the press around becomes standard operating procedure even when there's nothing in particular to hide. Also, without a free press, nobody is incentivized short-term to dig deeper if a cursory investigation doesn't turn anything up. The end result is predictable stonewalling if a cursory investigation came up with nothing, even if the officials are pretty sure they have nothing to hide. (Also, due to incentives, it's harder for officials to be certain they really have nothing to hide.) Having been in Hong Kong for just under a decade, I've seen several cases of bureaucrats making tone-deaf statements partly because they aren't used to dealing with a free(-ish) press. I have journalist friends, and I wish the relationship with the press were different, but bullying the press is less a sign of a cover-up when officials aren't used to dealing with a free press.
- Nasrudith 6y agoIf hypothetically a novel virus caused a global pandemic originated within the US they certainly would say the magic words "national security" and refuse to cooperate and take a hardline against whistleblowers if one of their government labs was suspected. The US Government has a pattern of slapping top secret on their mistakes because people getting rightfully mad at them would be "bad for national security". It is fucked up and not but governments are reflexively secretive so I don't think it says much about China. A superpower or nation-with-delusion-of-superpowerdom would refuse to disclose something like that regardless unless forced by internal political pressure - meaning there isn't anything to read in. They would likely rationalize resistance as "going transparent because enough of the world thinks this opens up rumormongering as a form of intelligence!".