4 ms·
Be careful! The fedivedse is filled with lots of crazies: for example, I got dozens of death threats when I built an AP search engine/index. I like decentraliz
by sneak 6y ago
Be careful! The fedivedse is filled with lots of crazies: for example, I got dozens of death threats when I built an AP search engine/index.
I like decentralized systems but the community is fraught with risk. Hopefully that changes as it becomes less niche.
- jitix 6y agoMaybe we should have something akin to spam filters for decentralized social networks. I personally stopped using mastodon for these reasons.
- sneak 6y agoI agree, I think published feeds that list items or accounts to block (as an advisory) that anyone can subscribe to is the future of social media moderation. Right now it's just instance admins deciding unilaterally for their users, which is terrible.
- grishka 6y agoIt's not terrible because you can choose your instance. Policies should be a big factor in that choice. If no instances suit you, you could as well host your own.
- sneak 6y agoI do host my own. The admin of one of the most popular instances (17k users) has blocked my instance, preventing those 17k from seeing me, following me, or DMing me. (It also prevents me or any other user of my instance from following any of those 17k users.) This is, quite frankly, a bullshit model that enables censorship. An instance admin shouldn't be allowed by the protocol to decide who you are allowed to read or follow. It's just as bullshit when gmail automatically spam-folders anyone sending mail to gmail users who isn't part of the deliverability cartel. Most gmail users are oblivious to the fact that an ad company is managing their eyeballs and attention so completely.
- adenozine 6y agoSounds like you run a single user instance? Why should any instance be entitled to another instance's users' attention, against the will of the admin? That doesn't make any sense, perhaps you could clarify your position here. It seems like you're saying instance administrators shouldn't have much control over what their users see on the fediverse. That sorta defeats the purpose of it, at least the way I use it. If I have to let someone else decide for my users, that's hardly decentralized. I block single user instances as well, because they're usually a waste of time, but if someone reaches out and makes a case for a whitelist entry, I consider it. That's how it's supposed to be, and that aligns with the guarantees about content quality that I've offered to users. Again, I'd love to hear a more detailed description of your policy ideas, I don't think I understand.
- sneak 6y ago> Why should any instance be entitled to another instance's users' attention, against the will of the admin? Because those users want to read and follow users on that other instance? The instance admin has no right to dictate what the users on that server shouldn't be allowed to read or follow. Users should be in ultimate control of what they are allowed to read, not instance admins. Users should be able to opt in or out of filter feeds, whether published by their local admin or anyone else, at their own option. This is a fundamental issue with federated networks, one that has come up with email and again with AP.
- sodality2 6y ago>The instance admin has no right to dictate what the users on that server shouldn't be allowed to read or follow. of course they do; they run the server. Whether you think they should is a different story.
- mariusor 6y agoIf your content is that important for those users, they are free to choose a less restrictive instance.
- grishka 6y agoIt's only a matter of time before spam becomes a problem in fediverse. Any system that is open and popular enough will inevitably attract bad actors.
- polytely 6y agoI think it will be less of a problem then for example on twitter , because you can just mute/block/defederate instances that aren't able to control the spam on their instance. There is an incentive to stay small enough so that the mod team can keep up with the amount of work required to keep the community relatively spam free. Unlike twitter there aren't investors that want to keep growing endlessly so the hard problem of moderation at scale can just be sidestepped by the admin by closing instance signups once they reach moderation capacity.
- tuyguntn 6y ago> I got dozens of death threats when I built an AP search Do you have any idea why? conspirologist in me says, this could be targeted attack by FB, Twitter to slow down decentralized movement. But I don't want to give my inner conspirologist take over my mind.
- sneak 6y agoSome people think that they can publish information to the unauthenticated web and simultaneously have that information remain, in some sense, under their own control. This belief is false. There is a desire to be able to sort of soft-publish, accessible to the whole internet, but revocable in some way. That's not how publishing works from an information-theoretical standpoint, to say nothing of the internet. A lot of people thought their data was being stolen or misappropriated when their own servers provided it to me via unauthenticated vanilla HTTP requests to public URLs. It sometimes occurs to me that if search engines didn't exist, and you tried to invent them today, profiting off of a downloaded copy of the full text of other people's websites, you would be sued into oblivion.
- thejohnconway 6y agoFrom what I've been reading, a there is a large contingent in the Fediverse that is against people being easily found. This is due to fears of of harassment and stalking. I think this is not a sustainable view. It is trivial to write a crawler to find people's profiles using open APIs, and even more could be garnered if you scrape pages. If you don't want to be found but must put stuff on the internet, the answer is to not federate.
- eeZah7Ux 6y agoI had only very good interactions on Mastodon. It's been the best social network I've ever seen so far.