4 ms·
Well worth reading. Lucid, clear. Didnt make me like Stallman more, but articulated some of the issues well. On the whole, I think the cancel/trigger thing has
by ggm 6y ago
Well worth reading. Lucid, clear. Didnt make me like Stallman more, but articulated some of the issues well.
On the whole, I think the cancel/trigger thing has got out of hand. People need to be accountable for what they say, not what people believe they think.
- etrabroline 6y ago>People need to be accountable for what they say, not what people believe they think. This sounds like a very Orwellian way of saying people shouldn't be fired for wrong-think if they profusely apologize afterwards. Is that what you mean?
- ggm 6y agoNo. That isn't what I mean. I think your wrong-think is a very big stretch from what I said. Can you show me the chain of thinking which took you there please?
- narag 6y agoDon't shoot me, just trying to make sense of what the other guy wrote. I believe that he's arguing that even if he said that, he shouldn't be punished. Only doing bad things is relevant.
- salawat 6y agoI think you may have read that wrong. What the poster is saying is that people should be accountable for what they actually say, not what other people assume they must have meant. It's subtle, but let me try to highlight the difference: Take as an example, Stallman saying "...it is entirely possible Minsky could have been unaware of the coercive dynamic [between Epstein and the young womem] going on at the time. We'll call this P. Also take, "We should wait for the facts and evidence before jumping to conclusions". We'll call this W. What Stallman said is just " We don't know if P or not P, therefore W". There's nothing wrong that was said there. People read things though that were not said; i.e. that since Stallman said P, it must mean he thought that the young women must have been voluntarily doing it. (We'll call this V). Much of the hulabaloo around the time came from people, (and journalists) adding in context that simply wasn't even there, which a quick perusal of CSAIL quickly made evident. Stallman never said it was the case that anyone involved was doing it of their own volition, merely that Minsky may not have picked up on the fact there was coercion going on, because if someone is being coerced, odds are they have been specifically instructed to hide the coersion. The fact is, one presupposes the knowing complicity of an individual by doing otherwise. Stallman cautioned that one should wait for evidence before coming to a hasty judgement. Communication is hard. One must transmit, and another must receive, and both people be able to demonstrate they took from the exchange a shared understanding of a common arrangement of circumstance and subject, mapping to the same circumstances and subjects in the real world. The clincher though, is that there is so much low stakes communication that goes on in our lives where errors in reception or coding of meaning don't have readily tangible effects that become apparent within a short enough time for people to recognize a miscommunication happened, or that even if they recognize one happened, that it will adversely effect the outcome of the attempt at communication as a whole. As a result, there is a tendency to chronically underestimate the difficulty of communication overall. EDITS: wording, punctuation, sentence flow.
- ggm 6y agoThank you. That pretty much said it, better than I did.
- chrisco255 6y agoNadine's point was that people should not be unduly punished for making intellectual arguments for or against anything. "Being punished for what they say" is precisely what happened to Stallman.
- ggm 6y agoNo, I don't agree. He was partly punished for what people THOUGHT he had said, and for past transgressions, and in large part for what people were TOLD he had said. Not for what he actually said.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Andrew_nenakhov 6y ago*Alleged past transgressions.
- ggm 6y agoYes. important distinction. Things he said and did in the past, which people got upset about, which are completely unrelated to the current Epstein context.
- sneak 6y agoHe wasn't punished, he was fired. You're allowed to revoke consent to an interaction or business relationship at any time. It's not a punishment to anyone else to say "this situation (employing rms) isn't for me and I don't want to be in it any longer". Firing isn't punitive.
- colanderman 6y agoStallman clearly has issues as many have attested. But reading these specific excerpts of his now... they just read like tone-deaf pedantry. Sarah Mei's response to someone else who pointed this out in a leveled, non-confrontational manner, of > That means you are also racist, misogynist, and a colonial apologist. Nice job just comes off as needlessly toxic escalation intended to shut down dialogue. I have several autistic friends and see this sort of interaction now and then. They will state some observation or make an argument rooted in logical pedantry, not pushing any political agenda (or, supporting certain politics but trying to cast it in a more logical framework). Someone takes offense at this and accuses them of being racist/misogynist/whatever. They are hurt. The conversation is not advanced. Both sides lose. Chalk it up to "normies" just... completely not understanding the autistic approach to the world I guess. I wish political activists were less reactive against those who just want to explore -- and ultimately strengthen -- ideas.
- smsm42 6y agoI think its because the point is not understanding - the point is gaining power, in this case - power over who leads the OSS movement. If you want to use one's words against them, you do not look for understanding, you look for maximally uncharitable and hurtful meaning possible, and declare this is the only meaning that matters. That's why political activists do it - because it gives them power.
- sneak 6y ago> People need to be accountable for what they say, not what people believe they think. I disagree. What people believe what someone thinks, even if incorrect, is a legitimate basis for someone's choice of free association. It's entirely legitimate for someone to avoid someone else (including fire them) on the basis of false beliefs about that person, due to failing to spend enough time understanding the nuance of the situation or person. I would never hire rms, for example, because he is a drama llama, and I find constantly creating controversy (intentionally or otherwise) to be mostly unproductive, even if all of the things he is saying are accurate and correct and true. Freedom of association does not require fairness or due process. Our time and attention is our own, to allocate unfairly, incorrectly, or on any other unscientific, inaccurate basis we feel is best.
- moistbar 6y agoSo every alleged criminal should be treated as guilty until proven innocent?
- sneak 6y agoYes, this is entirely permissible by society and people who know them. Violence undertaken by the state to enforce the law is a different matter, where the maxim of the law is "innocent until proven guilty". The topic of this thread is not law enforcement by the state, however. There are people I know who have been credibly accused of crimes. No trial occurred. I still treat them as if they were guilty of the crime: I assiduously avoid them. Such is my right.