9 ms·
>Richman was even named an "innovator" winner in Goop's "The Greater goop Awards" and at its peak, uBiome was valued at $600 million. Considering how questiona
by duxup 6y ago
>Richman was even named an "innovator" winner in Goop's "The Greater goop Awards" and at its peak, uBiome was valued at $600 million.
Considering how questionable Goop is that the fraud seems about right.
In the meantime the whole medical start up where they suddenly can test, for cheaper, better, etc seems to regularly come up short on the actual testing, results, or even just valid use cases.
Much like Theranos nobody ever seems to explain how these kind of companies can just suddenly test for more so easily where the existing medical industry just hasn't been able to.
Of all the things that the start up ... "system" can do well I kinda question their ability to suddenly become amazing complex medical device inventors / scientists. I recall some folks who work in that industry and they noted that creating new tests and diagnostics and equipment is often incredibly slow and iterative. That doesn't seem very start up-ish. The magical breakthroughs are rare.
- ketamine__ 6y agoScientists don't know what this number means. Doctors don't either. And yet this number from a test result from a company in SF means something to someone in SF. And no one can figure out why.
- bioinformatics 6y agoWe (scientists) know this number, be Academia, clinical, etc. After all, we have grants and budgets to follow and we are skeptic of anything too expensive or cheap.
- ketamine__ 6y agoI was referring to biome tests that tell patients nothing.
- rexreed 6y agoRemember the wave of all those "smart" Silicon Valley CEOs who were so convinced they could build a better ventilator at the height of the COVID ventilator shortage? All those folks who thought they could just throw together their engineering knowledge and hacking skills without ever having experience building a medical device? This sort of tech hubris is all over the tech ecosystem. Folks who believe their startup prowess means they can tackle any medical device with fake-it-till-you-make-it or fail-fast-break-often mentality that often fails in reality.
- mnky9800n 6y agoLike when moocs were going to replace the University and now that University has been online everywhere for more than a year nobody even mentions the old moocs that were supposed to cause this shift when instead a pandemic did it.
- treis 6y agoThey have to a certain extent. As an example, half of med students attend class "rarely" or "never" preferring online prep material. The fundamental problem is that the utility of universities is more about credentialing and signalling than actual learning. The Moocs are fine for learning but have 0 credential value. Until that changes they won't replace universities.
- dd36 6y agoI learned a lot in university. My professors were amazing.
- dgellow 6y agoI learned a lot via MOOCs, professors (who are often also university professors) are amazing.
- ThisIsTheWay 6y agoSure, but there is a lot more going on in a university setting - particularly one one campus and learning in person - that results in learning beyond the curriculum of a student's major. While I dreaded the prospect of taking a class on feminism, which was a requirement for my degree, that class pushed me outside my comfort zone and I learned far more about the world than I did in my upper div classes. The downside of MOOCs is being able to pick and choose the classes that you want to take instead of a full curriculum that lends itself to developing a more well rounded student.
- 6y ago
- twic 6y agoI note we didn't get any SARS-CoV-2 vaccines from startups. Well, kind of except Radvac: https://radvac.org/vaccine/ https://radvac.org/vaccine/ https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2020/10/8/radvac-scrut/ https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2020/10/8/radvac-scrut/ But if you had the choice between radvac and Pfizer or AZ, which would you take?
- duxup 6y agoYeah I'm not sure I'm in the mood to have my vaccine ... disrupted.
- astrange 6y agoModerna and BioNTech were both startuppy, neither of them had any products and they were working on cancer moonshots. They happened to have already gone public, but it seems like that's because they ran out of runway.
- ipsum2 6y agoModerna and BioNTech are startup-ish. Both ~10 years old, with <1000 employees. They're not established pharmaceutical companies like Bayer (founded 100+ years ago, 100,000+ employees)
- drran 6y agoI see few vaccines from startups. They have no money to conduct a clinical trial to prove safety.
- vkou 6y ago> In the meantime the whole medical start up where they suddenly can test, for cheaper, better, etc seems to regularly come up short on the actual testing, results, or even just valid use cases. That's because medical testing is hard, more testing doesn't always lead to better treatment, and the people who have devised existing testing processes weren't so stupid that a 20-year old with no background in medicine can just come in and upend the entire system on their first try. You end up trying to build a startup to solve a decades-old-problem that already has reasonably-good-solutions, in a field where R&D takes decades, costs hundreds of millions of dollars, and where you will have to figure out an in into an established old-boys-network in order to actually sell your product, if you get it built. All in an industry that's both cost sensitive, and highly cost-insensitive at the same time. If you actually think <some modern medical procedure> is overpriced, and wasteful, it would probably be good for you to work a few years on optimizing an existing lab's processes, before you jump straight from college into trying to optimize a novel process that hasn't even been invented yet.
- bsder 6y ago> That doesn't seem very start up-ish. The "innovation" in the medical start-up space would be "indemnification". Take a startup that has real results and fund them through FDA approval and backstop them when they get sued because the device isn't 100% (no device ever is). I had a long talk at CES about 5 years ago with a doctor who created an asthma monitoring device for his daughter that would notify him and the school nurse when his daughter had an attack. I guarantee that device worked pretty damn well due to self-interest. He couldn't get anybody to touch it. Everybody knew that you were going to get sued the moment some child died and a message didn't get delivered. Nobody would indemnify him even if he somehow managed to get through full FDA approval. Want innovation in bio? Backstop the little people who have real devices and real results rather than funding well-connected, turtleneck-clad marketing charlatans.
- Karrot_Kream 6y agoYou see the same problem in aviation. Other than the largest commercial airliners that are used in the most developed countries to fly passengers, most aircraft (cargo, general aviation, etc) are all using 50 year old designs. Why? Liability. Despite instruments having become much lighter, heartier (to weather conditions such as icing, etc), and more accurate than in the past, aircraft continue to rely on old designs. Because nowadays, creating a new aircraft and certifying it costs a _lot_ of money. So Piper, Cessna, Boeing, and others continue to use old designs that have already been certified, despite there being cheaper ways to achieve just as reliable or more reliable aircraft due to newer technology.
- hellbannedguy 6y agoI think we didn’t think a certain type of person could lie like most people when it comes to their money? I remember seeing Holmes in that Job’s get up, and knew something didn’t smell right, but was embarrassed to even bring it up——knowing their would be the backlash. Looking back I don’t think I have ever met a truthful wealthy person? They seemed to make their wad on lies?
- jamiek88 6y agoBehind every great fortune lies a great crime is the old saying, seems apropos.
- chrisco255 6y agoUh, maybe try meeting more people? Many business owners run honest operations that yield good profits over time.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- starchild_3001 6y agoGoop sounds so much like poop (=> uBiome), I find the connection appropriate.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]