3 ms·
The article reminds me somewhat of an earlier O’Reilly piece, which taught me that the man’s got a bit of social consciousness in his critiques of SV: https:/
by Apocryphon 6y ago
The article reminds me somewhat of an earlier O’Reilly piece, which taught me that the man’s got a bit of social consciousness in his critiques of SV:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23657403 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23657403
I suspect the Pollyanna tone is why people aren’t actually engaging with the material in it. Applying machine learning to medical science is indeed exciting, but it’s hard to envision what exactly is the product that causes “The nexus of machine learning and medicine, biology, and materials science will be to the coming decades what Silicon Valley has been to the late 20th and early 21st century.” Not to mention, I would wager most commentators are not equipped to address his point about SV being unable to deal with medical regulations, seeing as there’s been medtech startups that have already attempted to flout FDA regulation.
> The hubs where that knowledge can be found are not the special province of Silicon Valley
Isn’t South SF a biotech hotbed?
His points about regulators actually doing able something substantive towards big tech platforms, and the end of “casino capitalism” also feel too Pollyannaish for our current lamentable moment. Maybe it has to all get worse before it’s foreseeable.
O’Reilly certainly calls it out as he sees it with the social commentary:
> When the “superstar firms” ruthlessly compete with smaller firms that come up with fresh ideas, not only starving them of talent but often introducing copycat products and services, there is decreased innovation from the market as a whole. Cities are dominated by a new class of highly paid big-company employees driving up housing costs and forcing out lower wage workers; wages and working conditions of workers in less profitable industries are squeezed to drive the growth of the giants. Their very jobs are made contingent and disposable, with inequality baked in from the beginning of their employment. Governments are starved of revenue by giant companies that have mastered the art of tax avoidance. The list is far longer than that.
Honestly, this article’s a great read.
- weinzierl 6y ago“The nexus of machine learning and medicine, biology, and materials science will be to the coming decades what Silicon Valley has been to the late 20th and early 21st century.” I've been hearing the trinity of information technology, life sciences and materials science for over a quarter of a century again and again. Since the first time and ever since it reminds me of these tests where you are presented a list of words that are related somehow and you have to find the one word that doesn't fit in the set. For me materials science seems to almost fit at first glance, but not really when you look at it. Both the other areas have already changed our life more than anything in the past decades and there is good reason they will continue to do so even more in the near and intermediate future. I don't see this to be true for materials science. At least there seem to be at least a dozen fields that are equally influential. Does anyone know why materials science is so often included?
- Clewza313 6y agoSuperconductors, buckyballs, artificial diamonds etc are all quite sexy and easy to grasp, so they have a big profile in popular news despite their comparative lack of utility, much more so than (until recently) incomprehensible mumbo-jumbo about mRNA, convoluted neural networks and whatnot. That said, materials science is vital for incremental improvements like modern composite airplanes or SpaceX rockets etc, and if we ever do get to space elevators or room-temperature superconductors, the potential is life-changing.
- webmaven 6y ago> That said, materials science is vital for incremental improvements like modern composite airplanes or SpaceX rockets etc, and if we ever do get to space elevators or room-temperature superconductors, the potential is life-changing. There are a lot of other directions that materials science is exploring that might turn out to be transformative. Higher energy densities and power densities in batteries and capacitors, weldable ceramics, thin film thermal insulators, electroactive polymers, tunable optical refraction and reflection, biocompatible materials for implants, etcetera, etc.
- bsenftner 6y agoIt sounds crackpot, but in the merger of ML enhanced medicine and bio-generics, we're gonna see attempts to push genetic manipulating cosmetic plastic surgeries into the mainstream - like tattoos, these medical enhancements will be sold like apps, and they will create novelty capabilities or novel appearance transformations for the customers. Some artist gets sparrow wings on their feet (like the Greek God Mercury) or an artist has a living hydra-snake-wig created that accompanies her with backup vocals, who the hell knows? with this tech, bizarre combinations are possible and will driven by pop culture excess curiosity. Not "if" but "when" a popular music artist embraces such technology, we'll see a whole generation of Transhumanists Entertainers flooding society.
- kortilla 6y ago> Cities are dominated by a new class of highly paid big-company employees driving up housing costs and forcing out lower wage workers This is just an ignorant hot-take though that once again blames upper middle class tech employees for a housing problem caused solely by bad govern policies. There is no “domination” here considering that tech employees are well. 21 percent [1] are now considered tech jobs and the FAANG employees clearing $500K+ to afford houses make up a small fraction of that. > Governments are starved of revenue by giant companies that have mastered the art of tax avoidance. SF tax revenue has been climbing the whole decade [2]. CA is the same [3]. The governments are absolutely not “starved of revenue”. They have been operating in a completely inept fashion for decades and the waste/corruption is eating everything up. Double the tax revenue in California and politicians will have it squandered in the year. This is just another lame attempt to blame the tech boogeyman for a failed government. How much homelessness, high housing costs, high tax rates, failed public infrastructure, etc do we have to endure before we realize crying about one of the few major successful industries isn’t an answer? 1. https://www.mercurynews.com/2019/06/14/tech-employment-bay-area-reaches-record-highs-google-apple-facebook-adobe/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2019/06/14/tech-employment-bay-a... 2. https://sftreasurer.org/annual-report-fiscal-year-2018-19 https://sftreasurer.org/annual-report-fiscal-year-2018-19 3. https://www.statista.com/statistics/313176/california-state-government-revenue-and-expenditure/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/313176/california-state-...
- throwaway2037 6y ago> Governments are starved of revenue by giant companies that have mastered the art of tax avoidance. Your rebuttal appears to miss the point that O'Reilly makes. First: This page [1] shows business tax is about 1B of 6B total for San Francisco. In most cities in the United States, business tax is a relatively small part of total tax revenue. Most cities derive the largest proportion of tax revenue from property taxes. For SF, it is 2B per year -- the highest of any tax revenue category. SF property prices have risen a lot in the last ten years, so property tax has also risen. I understand some of this could be attributed to a strong economy combined with difficult regulations to build new residential housing. Thus, SF has seen a historic rise in housing prices. Second: Speaking more specifically to O'Reilly's point about the "art of tax avoidance": Are you familiar with "base erosion and profit shifting (BEPS)"? Sometimes you hear the term "Dutch Sandwich" or "Double Irish arrangement" in media. Global (tech) companies can greatly reduce national taxes by using these tax strategies. Thus, they deny much needed tax revenue to various countries where they operate. Please note: These tax strategies are not only limited to tech. Any industry that is heavily weighted towards "intellectual property", such as pharma, uses similar tax strategies. (General Electric was one of the earliest and most aggressive.) Famously, even Starbucks, which isn't a very "IP intense" industry managed to pay zero national taxes in the UK one year. After some embarrassing news stories, they offered a voluntary payment to the UK nat'l gov't. [1] https://sfgov.org/scorecards//finance/expenditures-and-revenues-vs-budget https://sfgov.org/scorecards//finance/expenditures-and-reven...