4 ms·
> You'd expect a IT setup by a professional university to have redundant backups for you They very likely do. On the M: and Z: drive. As far as I can see this
by Aeolun 6y ago
> You'd expect a IT setup by a professional university to have redundant backups for you
They very likely do. On the M: and Z: drive.
As far as I can see this is just IT saying “if you stored your data somewhere you shouldn’t have, it’s now gone”.
But of course they can’t say that, so instead they have to help people recover from their mistake.
Or maybe the mistake was thinking people would actually do what you told them instead of whatever was more convenient.
- eqvinox 6y ago> As far as I can see this is just IT saying “if you stored your data somewhere you shouldn’t have, it’s now gone”. You're assuming people are aware of where they — or their niche specialty software packages — store their data. I'm not even sure I'd know where e.g. some biotech-DNA-analysis-package stores its data.
- Cosmin_C 6y agoAnd this is why computer literacy is important. I can't fathom not knowing where the stuff I put tens and hundreds of hours into is saved. And this is despite the fact I never really lost any critical data in my life - backups offline and offline, on site and off site. Recently I've been given incredible abuse by my ex who accused me I took her external HDD when I moved out. I actually considered I did and scoured all my boxes and belongings and even invited her over to search herself. Meanwhile, I asked her if she had any backups. Needless to say the abuse tripled. I never found the drive.
- Aeolun 6y agoI don’t know, if I were writing my thesis on a machine, I’d very much want to know where it’s stored, and not just trust the awesomeness.
- PeterisP 6y agoAny shared network drives can protect critical documents, but I would expect that many people in the university have critical data for which those drives are simply unusable - can they put a 20gb experimental dataset they have gathered for analysis on that drive due to quotas, and if they can, would it have reasonable performance?
- lupire 6y ago20GB? That's $20/yr Google Drive / Dropbox / whatever, synced from local disk. And a $7 USB key cold storage.
- ThrowawayR2 6y ago> "And a $7 USB key cold storage." Which is actually not safe for cold storage in any way, shape, or form. Cheap flash storage devices are optimized for minimum cost per bit stored, not long-term data retention.
- PeterisP 6y agoI agree that there are solutions available at a reasonable cost, but the question is why this organization appararently did not implement any of these solutions, and will they do it after this incident.
- lupire 6y agoNot "it's gone", but "we wrote and ran software that invaded your computer and destroyed it". Why didn't IT use their powers to deploy a backup program before they deployed a deletion program? Thought expermiment: what wuodt happen if a student accidently deleted school's files, instead of the reverse? Criminal penalties? Civil penalties?
- goatinaboat 6y agowe wrote and ran software that invaded your computer and destroyed it Were these personal laptops, or university provided? The fact they have H: and M: drives mounted suggests the latter.