11 ms·
> Maybe the actual number representation with our modern numerals is the worst way to track count, but the way to manipulate those numbers is the best that ever
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
> Maybe the actual number representation with our modern numerals is the worst way to track count, but the way to manipulate those numbers is the best that ever was from what I can tell. All thanks to the folks that laid down the foundation to Arabic-Hindu numerals.
Hmm? The manipulation and the written form are fully independent. Before the introduction of Arabic numerals to Europe, this manipulation was already common; that's what an abacus was for. It's just that you wrote your result down in Roman numerals rather than as a picture of an arrangement of beads.
- jk7tarYZAQNpTQa 6y ago> The manipulation and the written form are fully independent. No, they are related. The optimal written form for a base 10 manipulation system is a base 10 numeral written system. > Before the introduction of Arabic numerals to Europe, this manipulation was already common; that's what an abacus was for. And the abacus was base 10, wasn't it? So the natural (and optimal) way to write down that result is in a base 10 notation. This Cistercian numerals are base 10000. Try doing a pen and paper multiplication or division using this system. No, seriously, try it. You'll understand why historically we settled on our decimal system. It's basically "divide and conquer" applied to mental math. The good news is that 10000 has 10 as a factor, so base 10000 numerals come sort of natural to us, the learning curve isn't that high.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> This Cistercian numerals are base 10000. Try doing a pen and paper multiplication or division using this system. Sure, in the same way that Babylonian cuneiform numerals are base 60, which is "they're in base 10, but you combine multiple symbols into the space of one glyph". The Cistercian numerals don't have 10,000 separate symbols. They have 10 symbols, and one glyph includes four positional slots in which a symbol appears. They're exactly equivalent to the Arabic numeral system we use now, and the pencil-and-paper multiplication system we use now transfers directly without problems.
- kadoban 6y agoIt's a bit like hexadecimal and octal and binary like that, in that it's really trivial to convert between those and just see at a glance what the conversion is. Except with Cistercian it's even easier.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoIt would be exactly like hexadecimal and binary if the hex glyph for 11, instead of being "A", looked like 1 0 1 1
- dhosek 6y agopedant alert: you mean B
- thaumasiotes 6y agoRight you are.
- NoOneNew 6y agoYes and no. The format of numbers is important to how you end up manipulating them. The way we do long division with 3 or more digit numbers cannot translate to roman numerals. A different method is required. This is part of my point. No one goes into how to do complex maths with Roman numerals, Cunieform or anything else. They're just "look at how you can display a count". Once you learn to add, substract, multiply or divide 2 digit numbers on paper with Arabic-Hindu numerals, 30 digit numbers are trivial, only time consuming. Having a system that uses entirely different characters to represent hundreds, five-hundreds, thousands and more, that changes the math system. There was a British show I watched as a kid that played in the US which made a light hearted joke regarding this. I think it was called How 2 or something like that. But it was a Welsh woman that showed how 12/2 can equal 7. XII, when you erase the bottom half, it gives you VII. While a joke, it always bothered me that no one ever talked about how the Roman ACTUALLY did math with their number system. How in the hell do you XII/II on paper by showing your work? Because our 12/2 long division method can translate easily to 1212/2. How do you do the same with MCCXII/II? I find it hard to believe there isn't one. Just, no one talks about it.
- fao_ 6y agoIt's why arithmetical calculation was a role one had. They used an abacus for the calculation of complex sums. https://thatsmaths.com/2019/07/04/what-did-the-romans-ever-do-for-maths/ https://thatsmaths.com/2019/07/04/what-did-the-romans-ever-d...
- NoOneNew 6y agoSo wait... math was never really done long hand in ancient times, but calculators (the abacus or any other form) were used instead? In some respects, that makes sense. Paper like materials were never cheap and long-hand math uses a whole lot of paper. Bead calculators makes sense. I'd be curious to see if there's a correlation to "cheap" paper being plentiful right before the invention of complex math like Algebra. With a quick 5 minute peek, "cheap" paper came from China to the middle east in the ~8th century. Algebra was recorded in the 9th in the middle east. So... eh, maybe. Requires more reading, but it's interesting. Sounds like an interesting infrastructure like correlation to technology.